quote:

Originally posted by :CrasHeR-kiD: Ghostland - Feat. Sinnead O' Connor - Guide Me God (Paul van Dyk Remix) & Paul van Dyk - Nothing But You One is a production and the other a Remix

not quite .. Nothing but You is a remix of Hemstock & Jennings - Arctic

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by webmeister not quite .. Nothing but You is a remix of Hemstock & Jennings - Arctic

Webmeister

Id love to agree with you but on a technicallity:

quote:

The Sessions 02 VANDIT022 Release Date: January 27, 2003 It will including tracks from Vandit vinyls: 019, 020, 021 and 023. Paul van Dyk's new single 'Nothing But You' to be released on Vandit/Mute/Deviant on February/March 2003. Press release soon. Vandit whites will be available next month.

Vandit has/will release PvD's Nothing But You as his new single.

quote:

Originally posted by X-Hale This thread sux *nobs off back to the UK forum*

and stay out!!

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by X-Hale This thread sux *nobs off back to the UK forum*

I know you - your that British twat

quote:

Originally posted by :CrasHeR-kiD: Webmeister Id love to agree with you but on a technicallity: Vandit has/will release PvD's Nothing But You as his new single.

even if it isn't technically his

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by webmeister even if it isn't technically his

Theres nothin technical about it matey - its his

Well I beg to differ. Just because Vandit are releasing it as his, doesn't mean it's his. At the end of the day it's still a remix of someone else's track.

And you still haven't respondent to the other 6-7 tracks I mentioned that have pretty much identical bass/percussion patterns...

___________________

I can argue this until im blue in the face and its not going to signify anything within this context - you and i both know that its going to come down to a matter of opinion.

You can happily beg to differ - but the fact of the matter is that its signed to Vandit and its being released as his track - i admire your acknowledgment of Les Hemstock but the site and the malinglist has it down in black in white as:

quote:

Paul van Dyk's new single 'Nothing But You' to be released on Vandit/Mute/Deviant on February/March 2003

As for your comment regarding what you would call the 'similarities between tracks' the keywords used by yourself were:

quote:

pretty much

Just like the technicality regarding Nothing But You - you yourself have used the phrase 'pretty much' which to me implies descrepencies in sound.

Nothing is identical - what your mistaking for this 'bassline' is the signature Paul sound; the notorious high hats and half beats but clearly not the percussion especially within the context on those tracks that you listed webmeister.

Identical - never.
Similar - hardly.

The pitch, the buildups/breakdowns whether you agree or not are always different.

In suffice i clearly disagree with ur proposed notion.

Look im sorry if im coming across as rather anal Webmeister.

But i promise im still the same guy who you PM'd on ITM and who admired you for your taste...but just slightly more defensive.

i was talking about the beats and bassline of the track not the format.

Second of all

Au.Ta's answer to starf0x?!?

Format?

What are you referring to then?

Starf0x?

Explain.