quote:

Originally posted by DaveT Tiesto's track selection is all over the place. By biggest issue is taht on nights these days where his track selection actually his pretty good, the mixing is just WTF? I am not talking about his ability to beat-match. If he wants to, he's fine with it. He just struggles so bad with the phrase-matching just making the transitions sound wonkey and making me cringe.

i think the slightly erratic feel to his timing is what makes him a far more interesting dj than armin. sometimes it sounds awkward but other times it can sound amazing and make the transition feel alot more vibrant. i'm pretty sure he knows what he's doing at times like that too, he's even defended it in interviews i seem to remember

armin is a smooth mixer (most of the time) who sticks rigidly to the phrases & harmonics, but can't pull that technique off as well as ferry; he manages to sap the energy out of the tunes by not introducing them with enough impact, and he'll happily disrupt the flow of a set just to play a big tune & wake the crowd up. hopefully if/when he gets to #1 he'll start realising he can play what the hell he likes and still be worshipped for it..

I imagined this thread to just turn into pointless & uninformed Armin-bashing, I'm pleasantly surprised by the content, some excellent points made.

Generally I agree with the initial comment by Rebel9,pretty much summed it all up

___________________
Visit http://www.myspace.com/djtombailey

quote:

Originally posted by RJT They already do, and those who choose to post tend to last about a week before throwing a tantrum and running off.

I only know of Matt Darey, Flemming, Gareth Emery? JOC, Luke Terry, G&D... do any of the big name DJs ever come on here? ie, the van Dyks, the Tiestos and the Armins?

quote:

Originally posted by Cobalt Paul van Dyk's decline coincided with the release of Reflections. Now I don't want to play the cynic, but in retrospect the change seems deliberate. Back then, everyone though it was a momentary career misstep, or an unhinged flight of fancy. His fan base gave him the benefit of the doubt, until they couldn't take it anymore. Looking back, his commercial shift feels calculated.

I was really interested in what you wrote; can you elaborate on this? Are you saying he was copying Tjis / trying to?

quote:

Originally posted by Cobalt Aside from the reliable explanation of money, I can't understand what would motivate him to sell out so shamelessly. With Armin, I can at least construct a somewhat believable chain of events and market influences that carried him away into boggy nonsense. I can't build any such excuse for Paul.

Was it purely for money that Matthias 'sold out'? How has he 'sold out'? I'm confused too about the Armin bit; how can you 'excuse him'?

I'm always cautious when I criticise DJs. For a start, I can't DJ, so I marvel at what they do. I'm musically trained, but not from DJ perspective. To me, it all seems a case of beat-matching, but that's how much I know!

Second, the main reason why I don't like criticising is I think; people change. In '99/'00, it was good. Very good. Heck, even Dave Pearce played some quality trance! But things move on. Would you want to be stuck in the same job in a packing room for the rest of your life because your manager thought it was good, or your customers thought you packed those boxes really well every day? I guess that 7 years ago, all these top names wanted to take a different direction, and why not? I expect they think they're in a better position now than they were then. Although, having said that, I would love to know if they actually listen to constructive criticism, and if they take it on board, and who from.

Chicane has gone the same route. He'll never top FFTMC or BTS so why continue in that style. Those albums were perfect for that time, then. The moment has passed, so although ETA and Somersault were a massive let down to some, is it not good that he at least tried something different? I often think they're damned if they do and damned if they don't. If they stay in the same genre, they'll get accused of being samey, if they take another route, they'll get accused of going commericialised etc.

In your eyes (and this is for everyone reading this thread) Is it ever possible to produce quality music and not be "commercialised". The way I've seen it in my 3 - 4 years on TA so far, if you sell more records than to a few thousand clique, you're commercial, and commercial = rubbish.

Maybe we'll be in for another '99/'00 and we just don't know it yet?

PS If anyone has a link to PvD's set at Cafe Mambo in '99 (I think), please let me know!!!!

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by DJ Mikey Mike Social outcasts are often of the opinion that they must have a drink before being able to loosen up with their inhibitions, thus being able to have a good time. There's a word that sums up this sort of behaviour, and that word is 'reject.'

Armin is one of the trance demi-Gods.

quote:

Originally posted by MichaelBoogerd! That'd be a good point except the for the fact Tiesto isn't a phrase matching DJ. He can't be "failing" to match phrases, if he wasn't even attempting to mix them in the first place.

Do you realize how senseless your statement was? Don't be such a fanboy, please. If he isn't even "trying to match phrases" as you claim, don't you think that's just lazy? No, it's not imaginative, creative or innovative. If I paid to go see a DJ who is deemed as "the best DJ in the world for 3 years in a row" and didn't even bother to phrase-match, I'd feel insulted and pissed. How some people fail to acknowledge this and defend it is just beyond me.

Anyways, getting back on the AvB subject...I remember he used to be really good. I really enjoyed his early comps, as they were somewhat different to what other "Trance" DJs were releasing at the time. I was really delighted by his first series (001: A State of Trance, 002: Basic Instinct, 003: In Motion, 004: Transparance), specially by "Transparance". "Universal Religion: Chapter One" was brilliant as well in my opinion. You could really see that he actually put a lot of work into his compilations, selecting awesome tracks, blending several styles, and spot-on mixing. Shame the same cannot be said for everything he has released from his "ASOT 2005" compilation, onwards. It's like apples and oranges now. All that hard work and inspiration has been replaced by bland mixing, and even worse track selection in what can only be described as an obsession to conquer the #1 spot on the DJ Mag poll. With the announcement of the release of his latest compilation: "Universal Religion: Chapter Three", I thought this was a way for him to get back at his old sound. A simple glance at the tracklist proved me dead wrong. I even dared to listen to it, hoping to at least be surprised by other aspects of the mix...all in vain. I think this is by far the worst mixing I've ever heard. I wrote a transition-by-transition breakdown here .

___________________

My Set Archive - MY BLOG

quote:

Originally posted by woscar99 Don't be such a fanboy, please.

Fanboy? meh. I'm just being a realist. Don't be such a hater and whine on about Tiesto regarding the scientifics of DJing, when the guy you're slating, doesn't give one shit about phrases or synching or whatever you want to describe it as.

I'd prefer to see a DJ who occassionally slips a beat, but DJs on "instinct" what to play next, as opposed to some dude with a calculator and a set of freaking harmonically ordered CD bags, attempting to make the perfect audial tonic.

If tiesto was trying to phrase match & harmonically mix, then by all means he is failing like a turd; but as he's just selecting tracks and spinning by instinct what the crowd might want next... I'm not going to call him out on that..

Armin has great control of his mixing, but what he lacks is everything Tiesto has above. The "Feel" to DJ successfully from instinct, not from practice. I guess it just boils down to natural talent, i think Ishkur covered that re: BT already

___________________
Tiesto Tracklist Archive - Independently Online

quote:

Originally posted by MichaelBoogerd! If tiesto was trying to phrase match & harmonically mix, then by all means he is failing like a turd; but as he's just selecting tracks and spinning by instinct what the crowd might want next... I'm not going to call him out on that..

Tiesto doesn't phrase match? Well, what half technically adept DJ doesn't do phrase matching?

Haven't heard recent Tiesto sets, but did he fix his trainwreck problem yet?

___________________
Latest mix: Yohan - Full Spectrum (Fall 14 promo)
Like my stuff? Join my FB group here!

quote:

Originally posted by chinamon not true. i say "ugh" but i am a tranny.

quote:

Originally posted by kotsy lol colour me retarded

quote:

Originally posted by MichaelBoogerd! Fanboy? meh. I'm just being a realist. Don't be such a hater and whine on about Tiesto regarding the scientifics of DJing, when the guy you're slating, doesn't give one shit about phrases or synching or whatever you want to describe it as. I'd prefer to see a DJ who occassionally slips a beat, but DJs on "instinct" what to play next, as opposed to some dude with a calculator and a set of freaking harmonically ordered CD bags, attempting to make the perfect audial tonic. If tiesto was trying to phrase match & harmonically mix, then by all means he is failing like a turd; but as he's just selecting tracks and spinning by instinct what the crowd might want next... I'm not going to call him out on that.. Armin has great control of his mixing, but what he lacks is everything Tiesto has above. The "Feel" to DJ successfully from instinct, not from practice. I guess it just boils down to natural talent, i think Ishkur covered that re: BT already

You have undeniable talent for taking the most embarassing features of your idol and turning them into something positive.

Well played, mate

___________________
"All revolutions are the sheerest fantasies until they happen; then they become historical inevitabilities."

back on topic

thank god, the fans finally put him out his misery...

___________________
Tiesto Tracklist Archive - Independently Online

saying tiesto can't phrasematch for shit is a gross exaggeration. he does it fine 95% of the time, but the times where they aren't rigidly matched don't always sound shit because of it

btw, i'm not defending the way he mixes because i like him.. i like him because of the way he mixes

Other reasons I hope Armin fucking finally wins the DJ Mag Poll:

-We won't have to put up with the annual whining and complaining of his fanbase for not winning

-Nor their incessant 'promoting' to lure more kids into voting for him

-Having achieved their life long dream of seeing Armin's name at the top of the poll, they will promptly commit mass suicide as they know nothing will ever top that triumphant moment in their lives again

-Or they'll finally move on and actually discover more music besides Armin's playlist ...where they'll come to the horrible realization they've wasted these last five years

-Upon winning the Most Popular vote, Armin will now see it fit to prove to the critical world he actually is musically talented and begin producing minimal tech house to win their approval, simultaneously alienating all the fans he gain to win the Popular vote. Mass hilarity ensues in the following years.

-With all the trancecrackers having finally gotten all their heroes the 'numbah one' position in the poll, they'll loose interest in it, and more knowledgeable votes will take over.

-Or the same three twats will remain in the top forever after, dragging DJ Mag's credibility further into the mud

___________________
Everyone has an opinion. Mine just happens to be a little more informed than most.
Electronic Music Critic: Near-Daily Ruminations Of Music I Own, In Alphabetical Order!