|
| quote: | Originally posted by Beatflux
What's a good DJ to you? A good marketer? |
No, I know I've seen a good DJ when I get up and dance around. There are lots of factors that lead into that, starting with good technical skills, good track selection, leading to more advanced skills like being able to build and program a good set and deliver tracks in surprising ways, and finally being able to attract a good crowd of people who are like minded. Marketing a part of that last bit, but its not really what its about.
| quote: | Originally posted by MrJiveBoJingles
Good questions. I would say the answer to (2) is much larger than the answer to (3).
I think it is generally assumed on TA -- and not just by the DJs, but by most who care about music here -- that the producer forums are full of people stuck in the year 2000, trying to make the perfect supersaw lead and snare roll. While this was perhaps closer to the truth five or six years ago, it has been false for quite a while, but for some reason the perception hasn't changed much. |
See the post below you for why its still true. Most people in the production forum still like trance, they don't go to clubs to listen to music 9/10 times IMO. There are a few regulars who that doesn't apply to, but overall, most of the "producers" here are either kids who are too young to go out or older guys who don't like it any more.
In my opinion Eddie is spot on. Most of the stuff that comes out of this forum lacks distinctiveness because the producers here don't go out in search of new genres or tracks. Look at the hostility that gets shown towards dubstep here. Even worse, the new tracks they do hear seem to be ones they've heard on the radio, which totally distorts your perception of any new genre that does come along.
Generally, producers on TA just aren't plugged into the scene in any meaningful way, and that's why their productions are boring, they've been doing the same shit and chasing the same sound since 2002, and its grown completely stale for them.
___________________
New Mix: March 2010 Promo
Soundcloud|Facebook
Last edited by kitphillips on Apr-23-2011 at 05:04
|