|
Re: no
| quote: | Originally posted by extepan
no, trance is not dying, it is huge in japan, that's why ayumi hamasaki is releasing so many trance albums
and IMHO trance is still big in uk, and house has been dead for 10 years already. that's why M People are not selling anymore :-< (i used to like M People) |
X Press 2 (Lazy hits #2 in the UK)
Tim Deluxe (It Just Won't do in the top 20)
Mint Royale (Sexiest man in Jamaica in the top 30)
Roger Sanchez (Another Chance #1)
Dave Lee (Regularly charting with the Jakatta and Raven Maize guises)
mmm...don't see how what you said can be true (assuming we are using chart places as an objective measure of selling records).
As for trance dying....
well I do feel it can be traced (to a certain extent) to producers producing very cookie cutter, uninspiring tracks (many of the Flip n Fill, Fragma, Darude (post Sandstorm), DJ Aligator, etc.) and while these do get high chart positions and loads of radio play, it's not the same because most of these people are listening to these tracks on a regular basis are not the same audience who put great deal into the type of music they are listening to so much as they choose it simply because it's what everyone else is listening to (much like Lemmings)and it's obvious that these aren't the people who are going to be paying great deals of money to go to clubs (as we know them) on a regular basis, shelling out loads of money for vinyl and CDs, etc.
However, another effect, I feel is that there is great deal of elitism in effect. Those who have been around when the scene was in its infancy cannot bear this loss in quality, thus they leave the scene for prog (most of them) because it's still in its infancy, relatively unfettered by the "evil of commercialism" (which I think is bullshit). By leaving the scene, they leave it to those who refuse to support it and it dies (for an example, just see why Cream closed)
Personally, while I am disturbed with the number of dance music by numbers tracks, I don't feel it is as much as a danger to trance as mindless elitism.
|