|
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
Fixed that for you. |
I thought it was pretty obvious what I was trying to say with that. Its one of the best examples of paradigm shifts in the music industry and the way people perceive and accept entertainment, since you were talking like you were such a proponent of such things as manual beatmatching.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
Oh, I don't know. Sorting by genre, or BPM, or by notes I've put into the ID3 tags of the music. You know... stuff EVERY OTHER FUCKING DJ APPLICATION MADE SINCE 2000 HAS. What if I don't know what specific song I want to play next, but would like to search by BPM or key instead? Again, it's fine if you've preproduced your set and KNOW that luke chable is next, but I prefer to NOT sound like a fucking robot when I spin. |
because not having a flow chart from your said djing applications with bpm and keys and genres laid out is not robotic? come on guy. i dont preproduce any flow to any of my dj sets at all, that would defeat the art of what djing is, see above post.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
I thought I put it pretty plainly, but obviously you don't get it. Ableton Live requires some fairly extensive preproduction before tracks are ready for any kind of on the fly performance - ESPECIALLY if you play genres that break time. Conversely, DJ apps like TDJS and Torq put beat markers in as part of the song analysis. In TDJS the beat markers do a very good job of warping around broken beats on thier own (of course you also have the option of making a beat grid on the fly, and adjusting the beat phase that is used in conjunction with the beat markers to match time). |
it does not require extensive amounts of preproduction, i know a pretty good local dj here in chicago that buys his stuff on beatport and warps it at the club while hes djing. i dont preproduce anything other than analyzing files before a gig. everything else is on the fly. i could even construct my template live on the fly while playing if i had to. to say that your aforementioned programs do a perfect job analyzing files and putting in makers is idiotic, as we know no one has perfected song analysis yet.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
Speak for yourself. Some of us actually like to DJ, and there are even (hold on to yourself) TURNTABLISTS that are interested in new technology. |
oh i love to dj, otherwise i wouldnt do it. the JZ stab thing was more a poke at the amount of bad scratching that happens in dance music, its very few and far between to find a good turntablist, its a dying art.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
Blakey, you'll no doubt take offense to this. But I could give a shit, and will say it anyway.
YOU ARE NOT AN ACCURATE REPRESENTATION OF DJ'S AS A WHOLE. |
dont flatter yourself with thinking that you could offend me by saying something like this. I never attempted to represent djing as a whole, the only thing i did say remotely close to that is that beatmatching is not THE ONLY art in djing, and to base any djs skill on wheter or not he beatmatches manually or automattically is a joke.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
For every one of you, there are literally thousands of others that aren't "destination DJs". Someone like you CAN walk into a gig and press play. That's great. But there are also OTHER KINDS OF DJs out there who have to (or want to) work a crowd in a different way. So for every one of you, for whom DJing solely with Ableton Live is an option, there are THOUSANDS of others that wouldn't dream of it. And amazingly, some of these guys aren't confined to their bedrooms, either. Think about this the next time you break out your Ableton friendly track seperated remix of Okoboji. |
I am a montly resident at vision in chicago and was a 2 year resident at ampersand in new orleans before the storm. dont tell me about working a crowd and proper opening etc. if i wasnt doing that, i wouldnt have the residencys i have/have had.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
The general gyst of my post was that in it's current form, Ableton Live doesn't offer the tools a majority of digital DJs want. |
no i think your totally wrong when your saying this, and that is the point of my argument. i dont think its the total package or tools that keep the majority of djs that you are speaking for want, its the stigmata of not manually beatmatching that they fear that has become attached to ableton.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
No one's chiming in and saying that you "gotta keep it old school" and do all manual anything. I've been a proponent for digital DJing for a long time, and have been active in the development of some of the more groundbreaking products released in the last couple years. But I don't have my head so far up my own ass that I think what works for me works for everyone. |
it sure didnt seem like it in your previous posts. you and others were coming across as beatmatch nazis. and dont suggest that i have my head up my own ass, thats such a cheap shot to take in public with someone who has had some success.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
I've been DJing since 1987, and was rocking the 504 for Moon Patrol and the Freebase Society when you were singing nursery rhymes. |
im sorry but i fell out of my chair laughing when i read this. playing raves for donnie at state palace does not mean you know how to work a floor bro, sorry.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
I currently have the pleasure of working as an audio engineer for a large production house, and get to sit in front of things like an SSL 4056G and a full blown PT|HD system with a 5 bucket ProControl surface 4 days a week. But I also understand that not too many people have these tools. |
not too many people need those tools guy. i know tons of producers, such as myself, that do just fine with a laptop and headphones. i think your the one with your head up your ass with such an irrelevant gear nazi post.
| quote: | Originally posted by nem0nic
And as of right now, only a couple retailers I know of are offering anything approaching Ableton friendly downloads for DJs. So until it's accessable for everyone (or until Ableton releases a DJ product that addresses the current lack of functionality), I'll keep my opinion about Live. |
cool i could see ableton becoming all of the things you said, easily, in the next 5-6 years.
___________________
Click Here to Subscribe to the Blake Jarrell Concentrate Podcast
|