Become a part of the TranceAddict community!Frequently Asked Questions - Please read this if you haven'tSearch the forums
TranceAddict Forums > Other > Political Discussion / Debate > Has Our World Been Dumbed Down?
Pages (12): « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 12 »   Last Thread   Next Thread
Share
Author
Thread    Post A Reply
DJ Shibby
Amphoteric Superbase



Registered: Jul 2004
Location: Of Earthzen and the Therethen

quote:
Originally posted by Arbiter
Yes, that's pretty much it. A sound deductive argument is always the best source of truth, where possible. But, in economic terms, there are information costs associated with obtaining the necessary premises from which to reason deductively. This makes it less than ideal for most situations that organisms, including humans, typically encounter.

Take this deductive argument:

Red is a dog.
All dogs have four legs.
Therefore, Red has four legs.

The accuracy of the conclusion, given the truth of the premises, is 100%. But in order to apply that reasoning in a practical sense, we would somehow have to first establish that all dogs have four legs. That's going to be a pretty big obstacle. What are we going to do, gather up all the dogs in the world and count their legs?

Heuristics, like the categorization heuristic, are more efficient because they are inductive. Suppose you are a wild animal and you need to find a source of water. On the one side you see some rather barren, sandy looking terrain. Because you are evolved to employ categorization heuristics and you have seen terrain like this before, you are apt to categorize it as a "desert." There are abundant trees on the other side. You are apt to categorize that terrain as a "forest."

Now, it may be that there is an oasis just over that dune. It may also be that there is no readily accessible water in the forest. But I doubt anyone thinks that the animal which categorizes the terrain and acts upon generalizations relating to those categories is not more likely to survive than the organism which insists on giving each unexplored area an equal chance at proving its fruitfulness.

It is not so different when it comes to homo sapiens seeking a more cerebral sort of edification, although the stakes are likely lower (I can certainly imagine scenarios where they would be higher.) Categories of potential sources of information do help us make judgments about where we are likely to find accurate information, and what sources are likely to be intellectually barren. That is, it helps us decide where we will likely get a greater return for the investment of our time. Over many iterations of this problem, the person who chooses more efficiently is likely to possess greater knowledge, both quantitatively and qualitatively.

All that said -- and in this regard, Shibby's point is well taken -- it is best that we employ this sort of reasoning consciously, and only to the extent efficient under the circumstances, taking into consideration the extent of our knowledge of each source beyond mere categorization and also the probable cost of an error.

Human beings employ heuristics, for example, that help them gauge how physical objects are likely to move through space. In most situations, they are very useful, since most of us are not capable of performing the calculations that would be necessary to achieve a higher degree of accuracy, at least in any timely manner. But while these limitations may be entirely tolerable in aiming my garden hose, we may not find it efficient to rely on them aiming a rocket.


I advocate the use of deducation, as well as intuition, as well as chaos.

I think deducation works well over long periods of time in large populations, and is kind of how evolution itself unravels.

None of this means it displays truth in any quantity or quality; it just maps models effective to what we can use here and now in this junction.

Old Post Oct-14-2008 02:28  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for DJ Shibby Click here to Send DJ Shibby a Private Message Visit DJ Shibby's homepage! Add DJ Shibby to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by DJ Shibby
Tesla is my hero.


He's long since been one of mine, too. He probably wouldn't have lasted too long in present day society, though. He probably would have either been institutionalized or something else to that effect, IMO.

Old Post Oct-14-2008 19:16  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by Krypton
Close-minded statement? Your statement right here is more than close-minded, it's downright stupid. Nikoli Tesla studied electrical engineering at the Austrian Polytechnic, otherwise known as the Graz University of Technology, and was thus accredited. It seems like you're making a concerted effort to dumb us down in the PDD..


So what kind of accreditation did he receive for dropping out in the first semester of his junior year? I've never heard that before so that's a new one to me.

Did they give him some sort of honorary degree or something?

Old Post Oct-14-2008 19:20  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Krypton
83.798 g/6.022x10^23



Registered: Nov 2003
Location: Texas

quote:
Originally posted by Trancer-X
So what kind of accreditation did he receive for dropping out in the first semester of his junior year? I've never heard that before so that's a new one to me.

Did they give him some sort of honorary degree or something?


Spent most of his college education in Graz, graduated from the University of Prague.

Tell me, you need a heart transplant, who are you going to trust with the scalpel. A guy who says he's watched internet videos of the surgery, or the guy who spent 10 years learning how to do heart surgery in medical school? Goddamn...didn't think we'de have to stoop to such elementary levels...really is an insult to all who have taken the time to pursue higher education. And the vast majority of intellectuals of our age have engaged in such pursuits. Not just our age. We can go back to the time of Isaac Newton, who was at Oxford. Even in that far back, the vast majority of intellectuals were learned individuals who pursued higher education.


___________________

Old Post Oct-14-2008 19:29  Korea-Democratic Peoples Republic
Click Here to See the Profile for Krypton Click here to Send Krypton a Private Message Visit Krypton's homepage! Add Krypton to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by spdandpwr
I am still in the process or reading all the posts, so more relevant posts will follow, however, I wanted to make a quick comment about wikipedia: I think the people who use wikipedia as a legitmate source for proving a point or arguing in a debate are not helping in making anyone smarter -- wikipedia should be used as a starting point, nothing more.


Actually, Wikipedia has been professionally assessed as being about as accurate as the Encyclopedia Brittanica while also boasting more in-depth articles.

What it basically boils down to is that there is no single, definitive source for anything and that no matter what the source, it's always good to compare it to other references as well.

And for whatever it's worth, that we "the people" are able to employ open sources of information (beyond the control of those in power) must be a growing problem for the handful of governing elites (AKA the Custodial Management Team) who like to keep us "dumbed down" in a relatively constant state of ignorance.


See Who's Editing Wikipedia - Diebold, the CIA, a Campaign

Old Post Oct-14-2008 19:45  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by Capitalizt
Back when I used to listen to talk radio, Sean Hannity did a "man on the street" segment, where he sent his assistant out to the street to do live interviews on the air. I swear, he received the exact same types of answers from random folks.. People who didn't know the Vice President...who didn't know the leader of Iraq (just before the war began, etc). A huge chunk of Americans really are that ignorant.


And sadly enough, having graduated from four year colleges and universities, a lot of those people are supposed to be "highly educated."

Old Post Oct-14-2008 21:01  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by Krypton
Spent most of his college education in Graz, graduated from the University of Prague.

Tell me, you need a heart transplant, who are you going to trust with the scalpel. A guy who says he's watched internet videos of the surgery, or the guy who spent 10 years learning how to do heart surgery in medical school? Goddamn...didn't think we'de have to stoop to such elementary levels...really is an insult to all who have taken the time to pursue higher education. And the vast majority of intellectuals of our age have engaged in such pursuits. Not just our age. We can go back to the time of Isaac Newton, who was at Oxford. Even in that far back, the vast majority of intellectuals were learned individuals who pursued higher education.


I figured you'd probably twist it around but I guess I just wanted to see if you actually would.

As per his closest associates and his school records, he dropped out of college but later received HONORARY DEGREES from several institutions. What isn't certain is whether or not it was because of his father dying or because of his lack of funds.

Anyway, good straw man but there are plenty of bad doctors out there just as there are plenty of good ones and to say that one is better than another judging simply by the school which they attended seems to me like a pretty foolish prospect to begin with. Sure, you might be able to form a decent picture of the individual's ability via the accomplishments/achievements at their attended school(s) but those accomplishments don't always correlate into success or continued ability outside of that formal environment. Some people are just good ass-kissers, some cheat, some lie, and some even steal other's work in order to rise above the crowd. Of course, there are also some who are given a free pass due to their political connections (as did our current Harvard and Yale graduated moron of a President.)

Experience is what really counts and I would take a good, experienced, UNaccredited doctor over one who went to the best schools but lacks real-world experience and I would do it in a proverbial heartbeat.

Anyway, that's all aside from the fact that Western Medicine itself is still an imperfect practice but of course that's an entirely different subject altogether.

Also, not to further change to subject but how do you expect that people would have pursued certain courses of study back then if it weren't for the mode of formal education? Up until the advent of the internet, one required the means to travel far and wide in order to access the same learning materials that we have so readily available to us now - all at the touch of our fingertips.

Old Post Oct-14-2008 21:04  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Krypton
83.798 g/6.022x10^23



Registered: Nov 2003
Location: Texas

quote:
Originally posted by Trancer-X
I figured you'd probably twist it around but I guess I just wanted to see if you actually would.


Please, spare me your arrogant higher-than-though non-sense...

quote:
As per his closest associates and his school records, he dropped out of college but later received HONORARY DEGREES from several institutions. What isn't certain is whether or not it was because of his father dying or because of his lack of funds.


Wrong. Tesla graduated from the University of Prague before it split into separate entities, one being German, the other Czech. He is listed by them as an alumni. That's not even the point. Tesla was an extremely learned individual. But that doesn't matter. He had to learn how stuff worked before he could go off creating all his invention. He has to learn about electricity, physics, engineering. What you're telling me is, anyone can learn by themselves how to be an engineer, without ever going to a school of engineering. Ok then, do that, and see if you'll be commissioned to construct a building...It won't happen.

quote:
Anyway, good straw man but there are plenty of bad doctors out there just as there are plenty of good ones and to say that one is better than another judging simply by the school which they attended seems to me like a pretty foolish prospect to begin with. Sure, you might be able to form a decent picture of the individual's ability via the accomplishments/achievements at their attended school(s) but those accomplishments don't always correlate into success or continued ability outside of that formal environment. Some people are just good ass-kissers, some cheat, some lie, and some even steal other's work in order to rise above the crowd. Of course, there are also some who are given a free pass due to their political connections (as did our current Harvard and Yale graduated moron of a President.)


What's the straw man? I am not misrepresenting your argument. Clearly, you are asserting one can become an expert/professional in a certain field of science without ever studying the subject at an institution of higher learning.

quote:
Experience is what really counts and I would take a good, experienced, UNaccredited doctor over one who went to the best schools but lacks real-world experience and I would do it in a proverbial heartbeat.


Guess what? You won't find a "good, experienced, unaccredited doctor." Why? Because they don't exist. It is against the law to be a doctor and not be accredited. Tell me. How does an unaccredited doctor learn how to perform procedures, tests, examinations, diagnoses, etc., without having studied it at medical school? Guess where such individuals belong? PRISON.

quote:
Anyway, that's all aside from the fact that Western Medicine itself is still an imperfect practice but of course that's an entirely different subject altogether.


Tell me one science that is perfect? If science were perfect, there would be no disease, no energy problems, no death, no poverty, and most of all...no more questions. So just because there are still unanswered scientific questions, you say, we shouldn't what...not trust a heart surgeon to perform our heart transplant? Not believe the laws of physics?...There are still a myriad of unanswered questions about the universe! Ohhh, but it's an imperfect science, let's not believe anything the physicists say. Oh, that PHD they took 12 years to get, that's just a piece of paper, it means NOTHING!! Give me a break dude...

quote:
Also, not to further change to subject but how do you expect that people would have pursued certain courses of study back then if it weren't for the mode of formal education? Up until the advent of the internet, one required the means to travel far and wide in order to access the same learning materials that we have so readily available to us now - all at the touch of our fingertips.


The internet can not make you into a doctor, an engineer, a pilot, financial advisor, etc. etc. etc. Your faith in the internet is very naive. Did you know anyone can post ANYTHING without so much as a peer review? I can't learn to be an economist by reading www.investopedia.com. I have to earn the damn degree before I'll even be considered for hire, by ANYONE.


___________________

Old Post Oct-15-2008 06:18  Korea-Democratic Peoples Republic
Click Here to See the Profile for Krypton Click here to Send Krypton a Private Message Visit Krypton's homepage! Add Krypton to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Originally posted by Krypton
What you're telling me is, anyone can learn by themselves how to be an engineer, without ever going to a school of engineering. Ok then, do that, and see if you'll be commissioned to construct a building...It won't happen.



What's the straw man? I am not misrepresenting your argument. Clearly, you are asserting one can become an expert/professional in a certain field of science without ever studying the subject at an institution of higher learning.


For the sake of brevity and mainly because I'm just tired of you and wish that I had never taken you off ignore, my paternal grandfather was a rather successful General Contractor who was self-taught in just about everything that he knew and that often included the drawings for the building projects that he oversaw. So while he might not have been an engineer, I sincerely doubt that he wouldn't have been able to teach himself engineering if had so put his mind to it. And heck, for all I know he could have gotten an online degree in that field if he had lived in the time of the WWW - in all of it's educational glory. lol

There are still a few autodidacts out there, you know. Not everyone has been dumbed down to the point of total subjugation through the same thought conditioning process that was apparently all too successful on you.

No higher-than-though involved. I just like to call a spade a spade when I see one.

Old Post Oct-15-2008 06:37  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Trancer-X
mutatis mutandis



Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Shambhala

quote:
Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt was the Senior Policy Advisor in the Office of Educational Research and Improvement (OERI) in the US Department of Education under President Reagan and is the author of The Deliberate Dumbing Down of America.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDyDtYy2I0M



I thought that this next one was good as well. Within the first few minutes Charlotte Iserbyt talks about their of use language similar to Orwellian Newspeak (semantic deception) while in the process of carrying out their plans for a one-world socialist government. She brings up the Patriot Act as one example.



What she didn't mention, however, is something that I think is currently happening and that's that we're experiencing a modern day form of Gleichschaltung. But I guess you'd actually have to listen to Naomi Wolf's warning to hear someone talking about that.

Old Post Oct-15-2008 06:40  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Trancer-X Click here to Send Trancer-X a Private Message Visit Trancer-X's homepage! Add Trancer-X to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Krypton
83.798 g/6.022x10^23



Registered: Nov 2003
Location: Texas

quote:
Originally posted by Trancer-X
For the sake of brevity and mainly because I'm just tired of you and wish that I had never taken you off ignore,


Of course, you're intolerant of criticism.

quote:
There are still a few autodidacts out there, you know. Not everyone has been dumbed down to the point of total subjugation through the same thought conditioning process that was apparently all too successful on you.


You seem conditioned to automatically assume there is a conspiracy behind everything. If you read my posts, I am against preemptive warfare, I believe our public school system is a shame, and a myriad of other things considered "outside the status quo". If I am conditioned, you are fucking brainwashed to hell...

quote:
No higher-than-though involved. I just like to call a spade a spade when I see one.


I express my opinion. Of course, since you're intolerant of criticism, my expression of opinion is in your words, "twisting" an argument, or essentially, I'm out to deceive the world. You're right, I'm wrong, and if I don't agree, it's because I'm a conditioned NWO bot. Seriously, spades?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

How about this. We agree to disagree. I respect your views, if you respect mine, we end it now.


___________________

Old Post Oct-15-2008 16:48  Korea-Democratic Peoples Republic
Click Here to See the Profile for Krypton Click here to Send Krypton a Private Message Visit Krypton's homepage! Add Krypton to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
DJ Shibby
Amphoteric Superbase



Registered: Jul 2004
Location: Of Earthzen and the Therethen

quote:
Originally posted by Krypton
Spent most of his college education in Graz, graduated from the University of Prague.

Tell me, you need a heart transplant, who are you going to trust with the scalpel. A guy who says he's watched internet videos of the surgery, or the guy who spent 10 years learning how to do heart surgery in medical school?


The guy with experience, surely.

Which is not necessarily the guy who went to school and has been practicing his trade for years, unfortunately.

If I think about it, very few trades in this world actually require going through the "system" in order to be validated, especially these days with information spread reaching critical mass.

Old Post Oct-15-2008 22:17  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for DJ Shibby Click here to Send DJ Shibby a Private Message Visit DJ Shibby's homepage! Add DJ Shibby to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message

TranceAddict Forums > Other > Political Discussion / Debate > Has Our World Been Dumbed Down?
Post New Thread    Post A Reply

Pages (12): « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 12 »  
Last Thread   Next Thread
Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackid this tune!!! [2003] [2]

Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackLeama - "Melodica" [2002]

Show Printable Version | Subscribe to this Thread
Forum Jump:

All times are GMT. The time now is 08:05.

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
 
Search this Thread:

 
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict

Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
Support TA!