|
| quote: | Originally posted by DarkAngel
Sure ash hell made sense to me and I agree with that.
By the way, Boomer what is/was PPR? I'm not familiar with it. I'm usually only in FLTA & COR. |
Post padding room
Aussie thread
| quote: | Originally posted by Redeye
see, thats where I don't think you follow. the PPR thread "started" as a spam thread only as a joke between 4 people. Then it totally went off on a tangent and became the 1st true freinds thread with PPR meet-ups happening frequently. Titles to me mean nothing, I could post a title of "get your pussy here" and it could be all about chinese food, but if you go in and read the content you will see they all share the same characteristics of a group bonding and outsiders trying to stir shit up. In your case Sandstorm, Mikey Mike, and a few others are the outsiders, in PPR it was a different cast. In the aussie one the same thing happened. You hope that your thread can stay happy through 13,000 replies, but I know you have been here long enough to know that that isn't going to happen and the thread will eventually be closed. Everyone seems to think that if the thread is closed all that was said is lost. All we are asking is that instead of keeping the old 1 going start a new one and close the old one once it gets too large. |
I see your point and i never did keep up on those threads, just a few snippits of each. If thsoe threads served that bonding purpose then why were they closed? cause a couple of people didn't like the thread?
to me that is ridiculous, letting a select few others clsoe a thread because they have a certain distaste for it? Especially when they reason they dislike it is unfounded.
there has been absolutely no flaming in our thread since its inception until a few ukta's decided to go against it, why did they go against it, it was a mixture of hatred for whiskers and boredom. and if that is the criteria for closing threads...time to get busy closing.
anyways, I see your point in that closing big threads shut those trolls that dislike it up. However I think we are looking at the wrong end of the solution. I think measures should be taking so that they don't stir up shit in those threads. Instead, if they dislike a thread, or someone, they go through the proper channels to get it closed (ie, pm a mod or post in suggestion forum). then when the mods make their decision, they live with it.
and lol @ ste in the FFS thread in here. he said something like +ban for spamming...you should of seen his flooding of our thread.
so to summarize, if I can, thsoe other two large threads serve the same purpose as these two. Since those other two were closed, then these two should be closed. Why where those others closed, because a select group of people bitched and caused trouble in those threads. so to avoid further bitching and flaming, the mods caved into their requests and closed the threads. SO to prevent the inevitable bitching that will occur in threads, you think there should be a thread size limit, after reached, the thread is closed and started over.
I am saying stop the flaming and bitching end in that thread. Take that through the proper medium. then if the proper medium decideds it is time to close, close. I think long threads can stay flame free. as we have done since nov of last year with 13000 replies. until these guys jumped in and flamed and spammed.
so we are fighting the saem thing with two different methods. I like my method, I am sure you like yours....now START TO LIKE MY METHOD :P
|