Pablo Gargano-Arcana = Second Sun-Crush?

Become a part of the TranceAddict community!

Frequently Asked Questions - Please read this if you haven't

TranceAddict Forums > Main Forums > Music Discussion > Pablo Gargano-Arcana = Second Sun-Crush?

Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Last Thread Next Thread

Author

Thread

VisionsofPVD
Trousy Defined

Registered: Jul 2001
Location: New York City

Pablo Gargano-Arcana = Second Sun-Crush?

I was listening to a recent PVD set when I realized that Pablo Gargano's Arcana has a strikingly similar melody to Second Sun-Crush...has anyone else realized this? I also remember Paul playing Arcana followed by a remix of Crush at the most recent gig here in NY and at that moment, I thought he was playing 2 mixes of Crush back-to-back....

Have a listen..and state your opinon..

___________________
"I don’t want to lead people, I want to tempt them, to create a new world for them, just for that very small moment when they are losing themselves in my music. I want to inspire them.”-Paul van Dyk

Dec-09-2003 20:42 United States

Click here to Send VisionsofPVD a Private Message

Scottaculous
habitual line crosser

Registered: Mar 2001
Location: On a plane

Hey Suneel. The two melodies are very similar indeed. Perhaps Pablo borrowed parts of the melody and made something more to his liking.

Dec-09-2003 20:44

Click here to Send Scottaculous a Private Message

arturob
Supreme tranceaddict

Registered: Jan 2001
Location: Miami

you guys have no ear...

___________________
www.arturobonetti.com // www.giuseppeottaviani.com

Dec-09-2003 20:48 Italy

Click here to Send arturob a Private Message

Scottaculous
habitual line crosser

Registered: Mar 2001
Location: On a plane

quote:
Originally posted by arturob
you guys have no ear...

if you can't hear the similarities, you need to open yours -->

Dec-09-2003 20:54

arturob
Supreme tranceaddict

Registered: Jan 2001
Location: Miami

quote:
Originally posted by Scottaculous
if you can't hear the similarities, you need to open yours -->

heh.

mine are very well open. i just dont hear the similaritie. arcana is very mellow and and kinda dull. dont like it that much. but crush, omfg. <3 for life! heh.

___________________
www.arturobonetti.com // www.giuseppeottaviani.com

Dec-09-2003 21:00 Italy

Pio
Supreme tranceaddict

Registered: Jun 2002
Location: NYC-New Haven- San Juan-Amsterdam / PRTA #1

I hear the similarities but I guess they're just a trivial product of the formulaic trance-making process. There is no such thing as an 'original' melody in the 21st century.

Dec-09-2003 21:02 Puerto Rico

Click here to Send Pio a Private Message

arturob
Supreme tranceaddict

Registered: Jan 2001
Location: Miami

oh yessssssss. NU NRG!

___________________
www.arturobonetti.com // www.giuseppeottaviani.com

Dec-09-2003 21:04 Italy

Technaut
tuanhceT

Registered: Nov 2001
Location:

can't say i had noticed. infact the thought never even crossed my mind

___________________

Dec-09-2003 21:30 Scotland

Click here to Send Technaut a Private Message

Sgus
Senior tranceaddict

Registered: Oct 2003
Location: Athens,Greece

i don't find any similarity....i love them both...really good tracks.May be the sample that it's being used from the producers are similar,but i don't think the melodies.i heard so many times these two tracks to find any similarities but i couldn't.

___________________
Tourouruoruoruoruourorouruo!!!!!
#tRaNcE On GrNeT. . .

Dec-09-2003 21:48 Greece

Click here to Send Sgus a Private Message

VisionsofPVD
Trousy Defined

Registered: Jul 2001
Location: New York City

To be more specific, its just one portion of the main melody that is similar to Crush...if you have the Adrenaline Rush hour mix by PvD, listen between 16:15 and 16:55.... this buildup melody has almost the exact same chords as Crush!

Scott, I'm glad you hear it! I know I wasn't losing my aural abilities!

Dec-09-2003 23:29 United States

sandstorm03
...

Registered: Feb 2003
Location:

i hear it also

___________________
Time exists so everything doesn't happen at once. Space exists so everything doesn't happen to you

Dec-10-2003 00:02 Italy

Click here to Send sandstorm03 a Private Message

umes23
BeatAddict

Registered: Feb 2001
Location: Spiritually in IBIZA

hehehe. i know exactly what you are referringto, and those chords have very similar rhythm and length but the melody itself that comes from whatever notes are played is most definitely not the same as crush.

it is a trivial similarity that by no means is likely to have been itentional or borrowed/jacked

Dec-10-2003 00:46