|
if i was one of the remix comp judges.....
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Psy-T |
here is how i score the remixes:
rb2k1/alphablue remix:
originality/creativity - 17
sounds/effects: 19
percussion - 7 (simple stuff, nothing fancy)
effects & other - 12
arrangement: 32
basic layout - 7 (too basic & repetative)
overall sound - 25
total: 68
tzar/chillful remix:
originality/creativity - 20
sounds/effects: 23
percussion - 10
effects & other - 13
arrangement: 45
basic layout - 23
overall sound - 22
total: 88
chrisle/retro mix:
originality/creativity - 18
sounds/effects: 18
percussion - 11
effects & other - 7
arrangement: 40
basic layout - 17
overall sound - 23
total: 76
christofa/christofa remix:
originality/creativity - 14
sounds/effects: 14
percussion - 8
effects & other - 6
arrangement: 18
basic layout - 14
overall sound - 4 (due to massive disharmony & lack of bass)
total: 46
costa del sol/costa del so remix:
originality/creativity - 18
sounds/effects: 24
percussion - 14
effects & other - 10 (this was a hard call because of the beautiful synthes you had on the postivie side and the awfull disharmony on the other)
arrangement: 34
basic layout - 21
overall sound - 13 (due to disharmony)
total: 76 (remove the vocals completely, make this your own track and not a remix, and youll get a 100)
meix/dj marko meigas remix:
originality/creativity - 18
sounds/effects: 19
percussion - 7
effects & other - 12
arrangement: 25
basic layout - 17
overall sound - 8 (due to complete lack of the high frequencies and maybe that's because of the strange encoding? 192kbps 32khz???)
total: 62
ele/ele remix:
originality/creativity - 9
sounds/effects: 18
percussion - 9
effects & other - 9
arrangement: 22
basic layout - 8
overall sound - 14
total: 49
en2t/escape n2 trance remix:
originality/creativity - 18
sounds/effects: 29
percussion - 14
effects & other - 15
arrangement: 49
basic layout - 25
overall sound - 24
total: 96
fatboy/fatboy remix:
originality/creativity - 18
sounds/effects: 28
percussion - 13
effects & other - 14
arrangement: 47
basic layout - 24
overall sound - 23
total: 93
kewlness/JayL remix:
originality/creativity - 19
sounds/effects: 27
percussion - 15
effects & other - 12
arrangement: 40
basic layout - 22
overall sound - 18 (why the hell is the lead panned?)
total: 86
lew_d/lew d mix:
originality/creativity - 17
sounds/effects: 29
percussion - 14
effects & other - 15
arrangement: 49
basic layout - 25
overall sound - 24
total: 95
nightflowers/nightflowers remix:
originality/creativity - 16
sounds/effects: 20
percussion - 9
effects & other - 11
arrangement: 44
basic layout - 22
overall sound - 22
total: 80
phorte/phorte remix:
originality/creativity - 19
sounds/effets: 28
percussion - 15
effects & other - 13
arrangement: 49
basic layout - 24
overall sound - 25
total: 96
pjotr g/pjotr g remix:
originality/creativity - 20
sounds/effects: 26
percussion - 14
effects & other - 12
arrangement: 36
basic layout - 18
overall sound - 18 (too muddy)
total: 82
shoes/point remix:
originality/creativity - 15
sounds/effects: 26
percussion - 15
effects & other - 11
arrangement: 30
basic layout - 13
overall sound - 17 (due to disharmonies)
total: 71
djprototypex/protox remix:
originality/creativity - 15
sounds/effects: 20
percussion - 7
effects & other - 13
arrangement: 29
basic layout - 16
overall sound - 13
total: 64
psy-t & halcyon/psy-t & halcyon complete revision mix: (feels strange to review myself)
originality/creativity - 20
sounds/effects: 25
percussion - 11
effects & other - 14
arrangement: 47
basic layout - 23
overall sound - 24
total: 92
dj dimwit/syntagma remix:
originality/creativity - 19
sounds/effects: 28
percussion - 13
effects & other - 15
arrangement: 49
basic layout - 25
overall sound - 24
total: 96
djtezz/tezz barker remix:
originality/creativity - 16
sounds/effects: 26
percussion - 14
effects & other - 12
arrangement: 46
basic layout - 23
overall sound - 23
total: 88 |
|
|
| Psy-T |
| how bout the rest of you guys who were in the compo,, how would you score the remixes? |
|
|
| extalin |
could you score my mix even though i wasnt officially in the competition? i just wanna see how it compares to the other mixes.. you dont have to, but if you wouldn't mind i would appreciate it.
if you decide to the link is in my sig.
thanks,
-rob |
|
|
| tor8024 |
wow, some pretty high marks you've got there..
there's like 4 over 90% or something? no need to exagerate.. ;) |
|
|
| Psy-T |
i did feel as though i was exagerating, but i think it's due to the scoring system, i kept imaginating a really n00b production on the other side of the spectrum to keep track,,
and btw, those that "got" a good mark from me,, actually deserved it |
|
|
| Psy-T |
orignality/creativity - 20
sounds/effects: 27
percussion - 14
effects & other - 13
arrangement: 46
basic layout - 24
overall sound - 22
total: 93 |
|
|
| tor8024 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Psy-T
i did feel as though i was exagerating, but i think it's due to the scoring system, i kept imaginating a really n00b production on the other side of the spectrum to keep track,,
and btw, those that "got" a good mark from me,, actually deserved it |
whatever, 96% means nearly perfect!
push - strange world, that is worth 96%, but not damaged (phorte remix)
no offence phorte ;) |
|
|
| Phorte |
| quote: | Originally posted by tor8024
whatever, 96% means nearly perfect!
push - strange world, that is worth 96%, but not damaged (phorte remix)
no offence phorte ;) |
HAHAHA none taken.. :stongue: i know my remix was pretty poor, especially compared to the other ones!
i think its just the way the scoring system was set up that ends up giving ppl higher than usual marks. all the scores are comparitive only within the competition results, not against real world percentages. |
|
|
|
|
