|
Trance is Dead! Long Live Trance! (pg. 3)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| dj tek |
| quote: | Originally posted by mizzuno
d00d ur in NY...cool...I'm always chillin in the city...
BTW i don't think we have to worry about mainstream trance here lol
Mizz |
yeah.. my next party is this sat. Nov. 8th.. should be cool, come check it out if u aint got no plans.. if u need/want further info hit me on aim[in profile..] aight ? peace.:) |
|
|
| mizzuno |
| quote: | Originally posted by dJohn
You know, it's kinda sad to see that you are differntiating yourself from other EDM fans just because it's a different genre...that paragraph you wrote has got to be the STUPIDEST argument I've heard on this board even since I registered(even outting my pointless rants that I used to do...just like this)
Since you made your point, lemme make mine relative to yours...it's not the progressive heads or the non trance fans who say trance is dead or dying...miss their chance to shine? What the are you talking about? Since when did EDM create divisions between fans, and who the are you to tell them that it's their turn to shine? So ridiculous...and yes, there are always facts to base assumptions, because that's what they are...assumptions are based on facts.
It's nice to see how such a EDM cultured indivudual "old school TA" like you can relate to a STUPID poll like this...this poll tells you NOTHING...it's a ing popularity contest,just like your high school ASB or Homecoming court. No point, no use. So quit using this as a reference to judge other types of music.
FACT: Progressive is not a genre. FACT: Trance DJs represent nothing when it comes to "DJing".
You say that trance will never die or go out of place from where it is right now...
Yet you relate to a popularity poll where the top 3 "DJs" are trance DJs...
Why don't you look further into what he is saying rather than trying to force your point...Tek does have a point: in a popularity poll, the top few are trance DJs...what does that tell you? I really don't think I need to tell you(and no, the answer is NOT "trance is not dying"...think harder).
Your argument serves no point and has no basis of fact. So quit your whining about how people think trance is dead because they know how to observe musical trends while you get off on popularity polls.
Peace. |
first off ...don't bring your condescending this way...
secondly if we're not supposed to go by polls then what do we go by...the Trance Council?....
You should probably learn something about scientific method while your at it...the only metric we have to measure if trance is dying etc...is popularity...so use the in grey matter that is left and do some research...
As for the supposed slight about my old school ta designation..thats right dickie i was here in the beginning and i remember all the lamers just like you, who we have fought to ban from this board...
Oh and popularity polls....what else is there? You make dumb statements and show your stupidity by calling polls something that they blatantly are..popularity contests...thats what polls do ..they measure popularity...
So do this message board a favor and STFU...
Mizzuno |
|
|
| mizzuno |
| quote: | Originally posted by Christopher B
Using the DJ MAG poll to determine the validity/"well-being" of a genre is pretty silly. The top DnB DJ (Andy C) is ranked only at 71, so would you say DnB is dying? If you brought that up to anyone in the DnB scene they would laugh in your face. It's just about what is popular right now and what people are more exposed to. Between the top 3 DJ's, there are 2 new artist albums, one new compilation, the first 3 EDM DVD's ever released, and the first stadium concert performed by a DJ. When you look at Sasha and Digs, there are no new compilations, artist albums, or DVDs. They've mainly only been gigging this year, which means they haven't been broadening their fanbases like the top 3. Make sense? |
note: I addressed this to the fools that post threads about trance dying..is this applicable to you?
I never said drum and bass etc etc et al is dying....
I have been on this baord for three years and have seen the classic trance is dying BS...this is just MORE proof that its not...
As for all you idiots (not necessarily yourself) who keep asking why i use the DJ Mag poll as a reference to that I ask:
what should we use as a metric to judge...
answer that before u go dissing me and my choice of references u dumbass disgruntled progressive heads..
Mizz1
SHI SHI |
|
|
| BeeJay |
genres will change, thats normal. The pop at the moment is not the pop we had 5 years ago, rock is completely different from what it used to be.
Those people who say that trance is a dead are probably fans of the trance we had 5 years ago. Im just new in the trance, I think it's completely alive and kicking.
Just watch at the number of livesets that contain trance tracks, just watch at the number of people going to parties. Trance is getting more and more fans. If it's getting better is another question. I don't know, Im just a new kid ;) |
|
|
| dJohn |
| quote: | | what should we use as a metric to judge |
Thats exactly it. How can you use a scalar quantitative approach do judge music, something that is not measured by numbers, but emotions? What next, your gonna place a value on how much you hate this track, or like that track? Polls and ratings are ing useless when your measuring something that can't be measured.
As far as my condescending tone, can you really blame me after what you posted? I'm not trying to start beef, but you shouting and bitching and denouncing every "prog" fan out there is kinda ridiuclous...doesn't serve up to your 3 year rep that your so proud of watching the trance scene evolve. Big dude. I've been listeing to trance just as long if not longer than you, and while I agree that trance isn't dying, it IS becoming more main stream. Get it?
And why are you so angry at all the people who support progressive house and trance? I've never met anybody who was so angry and resentful against a particular group of people, especially music wise. Wow.
| quote: | | secondly if we're not supposed to go by polls then what do we go by...the Trance Council?.... |
Since when did we NEED to rank DJs? Since when did eletronica and trance become a competition rather than a way of communication through music? Maybe your listening to trance for the wrong purposes...kinda funny how you seem to think that trance isn't going mainstream, yet you use a "metric" poll to judge the state of the music...WHO GIVES A ABOUT THE POLLS...if the top 3 were progressive, would you say trance is dying? What happened 4 years ago when Sasha won it, then Diggers...it doesn't mean .
| quote: | | Oh and popularity polls....what else is there? You make dumb statements and show your stupidity by calling polls something that they blatantly are..popularity contests...thats what polls do ..they measure popularity... |
What else is there? I could tell you, but I really don't feel like writing a huge argument to prove an obvious point. Again, your point on polls kinda serves as a joke to yourself...
Like I said, I'm not trying to start beef, or argue with you, I'm just trying to make a point against yours because I completly disagree with you...and when you see ignorant comments like u dumbass digrunteled progressive heads, it kinda serves as a reason to talk.
Peace. |
|
|
| Buddhistics |
| quote: | Originally posted by BeeJay
genres will change, thats normal. The pop at the moment is not the pop we had 5 years ago, rock is completely different from what it used to be.
Those people who say that trance is a dead are probably fans of the trance we had 5 years ago. Im just new in the trance, I think it's completely alive and kicking.
Just watch at the number of livesets that contain trance tracks, just watch at the number of people going to parties. Trance is getting more and more fans. If it's getting better is another question. I don't know, Im just a new kid ;) |
Well said. Succint and to the point. The best post in this thread......next to the gorilla-humping pic :haha: |
|
|
| DJDigDug |
| So techno is dead, because a majority of underground clubs bump that but for some reason thousands of DJs who spin it arent recognized by DJ mags poll(Save for the major names)? So acid jazz doesnt exist? cause dj mag doesnt have an acid jazz dj on there Oh my, so many genres must have become extinct last week! Anyone who has half a brain places no faith or relevance in the Dj mag bull tally, it is less accurate than a vote in florida, PvD is probably on one of his worst years, yet he is rank 2, Whilst some talent did place decently, much of it is who promoted more, if anything having 'trance' Djs at the tops spots is only a further sign of its slow grimacing demise:rolleyes: |
|
|
| mizzuno |
| quote: | Originally posted by dJohn
What else is there? I could tell you, but I really don't feel like writing a huge argument to prove an obvious point. Again, your point on polls kinda serves as a joke to yourself...
|
Please oh great one of quantitative statistics please explain mean distributions and bell curve theory...sorry dude i don't need a scientific explanation as to how polls work, all i can say is that polls are used as a guage of public opinion...and you're right its all opinion, thats why as i have been here for over 3 years i have seen many posts proclaiming the "death of trance". As you weren't here, you may not have seen all the dumb and uniformed posts that i have. So in essence this thread was not directed toward or has any pertinence to you. So maybe you should be asking yourself why you took offense to it.
And yes its usually the progressive heads who start these types of threads, so although your comments are welcome they are irrelevant. You may have been a fan as long as I have but you haven't been on this particular board.
As far as trance becoming mainstream...in europe and asia maybe but not in the US, I live in the largest city in the US and I (and anyone in the NY forums) can tell you that trance dj's here are few and far between, so your point which may be relevant in other parts of the world is completely relative and holds no water here.
Ranking dj's is like ranking anything else that has not real quantitative aspect. Its a qualitative subjective judgement and always will be.
And angry..d00d i'm far from angry, ask anyone on this board who knows me..swamper, redeye, ian, tempest, tta etc..the list goes on, I am not angry in general, just with dumb posts and lamers...
The whole point professor is that there are no definitive ways of proving trance is dying or is alive and kicking, but there are indicators...and its just possible that its popularity (ie polls) is relative to its overall health. I could care less if you agree with my synopsis, because last i looked you weren't grading my papers or paying my salary..
MizzUNo |
|
|
| mizzuno |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJDigDug
Whilst some talent did place decently, much of it is who promoted more, if anything having 'trance' Djs at the tops spots is only a further sign of its slow grimacing demise:rolleyes: |
A course in logic would do you well.
Mizz |
|
|
| rafale |
No doubt trance is going mainstream. Not in the USA maybe, but in many other parts of the world. Anyway, becoming more mainstream has its pros n cons.. one of its pros being that it will widen its fan base, and more people will be listening to trance.
This would probably result in more up n coming producers, new ideas, collaborations etc. which would be only too good for the trance scene.
As for the cons, I'm leaving it to the rest of u guys to give your opnions on how this might be bad for trancE??
The genre might be going mainstream, but the music itself is always evolving... for the better IMO. It won't die folks! Not just yet!
:toocool: |
|
|
| mizzuno |
| quote: | Originally posted by rafale
No doubt trance is going mainstream. Not in the USA maybe, but in many other parts of the world. Anyway, becoming more mainstream has its pros n cons.. one of its pros being that it will widen its fan base, and more people will be listening to trance.
This would probably result in more up n coming producers, new ideas, collaborations etc. which would be only too good for the trance scene.
As for the cons, I'm leaving it to the rest of u guys to give your opnions on how this might be bad for trancE??
The genre might be going mainstream, but the music itself is always evolving... for the better IMO. It won't die folks! Not just yet!
:toocool: |
I totally agree..
Mizz |
|
|
|
|
