|
Weighted synth or digital piano plus other stuff?
|
View this Thread in Original format
| imokruok |
I'm fairly new to trance, but I am a somewhat accomplished pianist. I no longer have the time to go find a real piano and practice on - I need something at home. So I've started looking into digital pianos and also weighted synths.
Now, I would like to make a purchase that gives me a dual ability. I would like something that sounds and feels like a regular piano, but also something that I could use if I wanted to get involved with Cubase and Reason for trance production.
Should I just go all out and get a weighted synthesizer? Or would it be better to get a digital piano, save a few bucks, and then add on some new control surfaces/hardware synths later? Thanks for your opinions-- |
|
|
| paranoik0 |
| uhm, maybe try buying just a cheap midi keyboard. that way you'll be able to play it just like a piano, yet do all the production and knob tweaking on the computer. |
|
|
| dj-sean |
| If you want the complete feel of a piano (and as an accomplished pianist, anything less than the complete feel will probably piss you the off ;)), then you should probably just get a digital piano. Another option would be the Triton workstation full 88-key weighted synth; from what I hear this also has a very "real" feel to it, and is pretty sweet for producing too based on reviews I've read. Unfortunately it also comes with quite the price tag, hehe. |
|
|
| imokruok |
Thanks for the Triton tip. I hadn't even looked at those models yet. Damn! The one at the top of the range is $3,400, but it's got some sweet built-in hardware. (An onboard CD burner? Cooool.....)
Pretty much out of my price range right now, but I'm definitely taking a trip to the music store over Christmas to try some of this stuff out. |
|
|
| hey cheggy |
| Get a keyboard that will allow you to play the piano, but one that also has midi out so that you can hook it up to cubase and play softsynths or hardware rack synths. The Triton will do this but there are cheaper options out there I'm sure. |
|
|
| imokruok |
Thanks for the tips.
I just took a trip to the music store to try a few things out. A digital piano is clearly the way to go for just playing piano. There really is no comparison between the "piano" feel on the digital pianos and the keys on the weighted synths. So my primary purchase will probably be a full-size Yamaha digital piano. Great piano and organ sounds, great action, under $1000. 'Nuff said about that.
But I still needed some kind of MIDI/synth/controller solution for the computer. I took a look at some bare controllers, but the cheapness of feel on those was pretty bad. I felt like I would be spending at least $150 for something made by Fisher Price. So I checked out some real synths.
There wasn't much of a selection, but I did like what I heard on the Yamaha CZ2X. The Alesis Ion was there too, but its software seemed really difficult to use. I'll have to spend more time checking out the synths.
Any other thoughts are appreciated- |
|
|
| moth |
One way or another, if you plan to buy some hardware, you will need something to control them (if they're rack mount synths), so a MIDI keyboard would be a good idea. Midiman makes great midi keyboards, i've tested them all out, very high quality. The Oxygen 8 is very inexpensive (150 bucks) and works perfectly. Only drawback is that you can only use two octaves at a time. The Ozone is the same as the Oxygen 8, but it has a built in soundcard.
Most music stores carry them (from what i've seen), or you can order online. |
|
|
| imokruok |
Back from another music store, and wow! They had a Yamaha S30 with an expansion pack in it that emulates the sounds of the AN1X. The price was $1000, which after looking on the web is actually reasonable compared to what people want for just the S30.
Bottom line is I've got a whole bunch of info to look at and think about. Whatever I get won't be until after Christmas.
But whatever board I get, along with Cubase/Reason, I think I'll have a pretty good setup. |
|
|
| hey cheggy |
| Whatever you get, just make sure it has a midi out port. That way you can use it to controll reason, cubase, etc. and you won't need to get a ty cheap feeling midi controller. |
|
|
|
|
