|
40 000 kids about to fail high school... (pg. 3)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| The Highroller |
| quote: | Originally posted by k0nk
Oh, boo hoo. University was hella harder than high school, and I managed to work part time through that. Now I'm on my post-grad, and I'm even considering trying to get a part time job, when I have over 35 hours of actual classes, that are much harder than highschool (and no PE, Art, or Drama, either).
I think these kids are just trying to find someone else to blame. I can understand the problem of trying to get into University, because there are double the number of kids trying. But, get a job, take a year off, and you'll have less of a student loan to manage later. The University I went to increased its entrance GPA, so If I had waited 4 years, I wouldn't have been able to go... (It now has a 84% entrance GPA). Anyway, if the student really applies themself, they can get the grade. I'll admit, I didn't work at all in highschool, and still managed to get into University. So, if these kids apply themself, get help if they need it (its available), they should do fine. |
Again, a 14-17 year old is not the same as a 20 year old. You can't compare how hard university life is with highschool life because they are at 2 different stages in their lives. |
|
|
| Fir3start3r |
| quote: | Originally posted by The Highroller
Again, a 14-17 year old is not the same as a 20 year old. You can't compare how hard university life is with highschool life because they are at 2 different stages in their lives. |
I'd say that more depends on the maturity of the person than 'level' of their life. |
|
|
| drgoodvibe |
| Although i'm not in highschool anymore i must admit that OAC was a total waste of time.. I had 3 classes in OAC, and I ended up skipping so often that you could see me in the halls more then in class.. I still managed to get into uni by the way ;) I had a spare in grade 12 too! I didnt do anything in highschool and basically it didnt teach me any real life skills either. How about a course on Organization? Time management? How to study more efficiently instead of like a dog for hours on end? How about how to take a test? These are skills that we must master BEFORE university and some never manage to do it. |
|
|
| AmbiguousBliss |
| quote: | Originally posted by Fir3start3r
| quote: | Originally posted by The Highroller
Again, a 14-17 year old is not the same as a 20 year old. You can't compare how hard university life is with highschool life because they are at 2 different stages in their lives. |
I'd say that more depends on the maturity of the person than 'level' of their life. |
Exactly. It's a bit of a pet peeve of mine when people say things like 'oh, high school/university is so much harder' (depending on what you're comparing it to), since it's all relative to the point at which you are in life, as well as maturity-wise. While you're at one point, you're building up your repertoire of skills, knowledge, etc. so that you can get to your next point.
Elementary school could've had its challenges, while you were in elementary school.
High school could've had its challenges, while you were in high school.
University could've had its challenges, while you were in university.
ETC.
To compare elementary school with high school, or high school with university, is rather nonsensical. |
|
|
| j_spot |
Its all about the job market.
In my world, high school is an end in itself. It should not be University prep, unless the Gov't wants to pay for my university and make another 4 years of schooling 'mandatory'
Jobs are demanding post secondary education. To do better in post secondary, kids are being prepared in High school(which SHOULD NOT be the purpose of it) and those who wouldnt normally go to Univ are being punished, while those on the border are also being punished. Only the academically strong will survive. Its pretty weak.
ps Im starting a charter school. I will allow snowball fights!@ |
|
|
| Provitex |
| quote: | Originally posted by AmbiguousBliss
I'd say that more depends on the maturity of the person than 'level' of their life.
Exactly. It's a bit of a pet peeve of mine when people say things like 'oh, high school/university is so much harder' (depending on what you're comparing it to), since it's all relative to the point at which you are in life, as well as maturity-wise. While you're at one point, you're building up your repertoire of skills, knowledge, etc. so that you can get to your next point.
Elementary school could've had its challenges, while you were in elementary school.
High school could've had its challenges, while you were in high school.
University could've had its challenges, while you were in university.
ETC.
To compare elementary school with high school, or high school with university, is rather nonsensical. |
wow.. even..
nonsensical she says..
Interesting perspective :)
BUT: As much as I agree with you, at some point, there must be some sort of margin given to us as a guide to achieve these supplementary skills (in order to move on to the 'next stage')
So this perimeter isn't necessarily a bad thing, but to what you were saying, yes to some extent it is relative.
Yup..as to comparing one's university lifestyle, to that of a highschooler -- pretty sad I must say. |
|
|
| Your Mother |
| quote: | Originally posted by drgoodvibe
Although i'm not in highschool anymore i must admit that OAC was a total waste of time.. I had 3 classes in OAC, and I ended up skipping so often that you could see me in the halls more then in class.. I still managed to get into uni by the way ;) I had a spare in grade 12 too! I didnt do anything in highschool and basically it didnt teach me any real life skills either. How about a course on Organization? Time management? How to study more efficiently instead of like a dog for hours on end? How about how to take a test? These are skills that we must master BEFORE university and some never manage to do it. |
Well said...
That extra year of OAC's were absolutely useless. When I compare my knowledge in first year university with others from out of province, it gets humiliating. All it did was waste a year of my life.
-Your Mother |
|
|
| DigiNut |
Sigh... you kids in high school see the forest through the trees. You have to step back and see the whole issue:
1) School IS a waste of time. After 4 years of engineering I can't remember using any of the math or science I was taught in high school - if I don't use it in engineering, I don't know where people would use it.
2) Education is NOT a waste of time. It's just that public schooling is, was, and always has been a means to control the masses rather than a means of personal development. Many studies have shown that ordinary (not necessarily bright) kids who have home schooling or private tutors show MUCH better intellectual performance. Why? The biggest reason is that they actually have a measure of control over what they learn, and can seek out what actually interests them.
3) Stop bitching about the teachers. There are bad teachers just like there are bad doctors and bad lawyers and bad cooks. You think it's hard for YOU adjusting to a new program? Think how hard it is for THEM to learn this new material that they were never taught in THEIR schools and thought they'd never have to deal with in their entire lives! And then to sit there and mark a hundred papers and try to figure out where you made a mistake, when they barely know how to answer the question in the first place. Oh yeah, teachers are a bunch of jackasses - try being one yourself and you'll see how motivated you are after a year or two, dealing with students who don't listen and don't care.
4) START blaming the PARENTS. If a kid gets plopped down in front of a TV all day watching Barney videos, you can rest assured s/he's going to grow up with a distorted view of life. Likewise, when they're watching MTV, MuchMusic, crappy soap operas, reality shows and pop star contests all day, they're probably going to grow up with short attention spans (hey here's an idea, why don't we actually address that problem instead of calling it "ADD" and "fixing" it with drugs?). Yes it's true, parents can't control everything that their kids are exposed to, but they can certainly have a profound effect on it up til age 5 or 6 before they go off to school, and those formative years are the most important ones anyway.
5) I'm sorry but the Ontario curriculum is ridiculously easy compared to a lot of Asian and European curricula. It's a lot harder than it was BEFORE, yes, but it's still low by international standards. One valid point that was brought up by Graham was that people haven't been adequately prepared for it by elementary & junior high, and this is completely true - unfortunately the government just decided to "fix" the high school program without "fixing" the preceding 8 years, so high school has become a slap in the face to people who are used to NOT being challenged, paying attention, or having to work.
I've always been an advocate of doing away with public education altogether. But if that's not going to happen, then honestly, don't blame high school or its teachers, blame the lower school and parents, who both didn't do their jobs properly. |
|
|
| AmbiguousBliss |
| quote: | Originally posted by DigiNut
1) School IS a waste of time.
2) Education is NOT a waste of time. |
 |
|
|
| The Highroller |
I agree with you Aaron. Yes it is hard for teachers, I'm not trying to pretend it's not. They keep changing the curriculum, material, and marking scheme on them, and it's definately making their jobs very difficult.
But that does not mean that they should take it out on the students. When they do, they risk our futures just because they are dissatisfied with their working conditions. Most jobs where this happens, it will effect the dissatisfied employee's work, but when you're dealing with something like someone else's future, you can't let it effect your work. |
|
|
| rabbitjoker |
| Toronto Star = Liberal Propaganda = Not worth the paper it's printed on (or the bits it's stored with). |
|
|
| rabbitjoker |
| quote: | Originally posted by The Highroller
Wow! |
Graham - I respect your opinion the most on this issue. Very well put.
IMO - The problem isn't the curriculum - it's the streaming of students into the university stream who just shouldn't be there. |
|
|
|
|
