|
Whiteroom - Someday (pg. 6)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| flavdave |
| quote: | Originally posted by djranpage
Man, i dont know what to say, i always hate reading things on posts that have nothing to do with the track. whiteroom - someday is a great record. The mix is really tight, production is top notch, chord progression is beautiful. this is a great follow up to whiteroom - whiteroom. Adam white and andy moor are two hard working, respective dj's / producers, that have been around for a long long time, probably longer than some of you have been listning to trance, so no matter what you thinnk of the song, my question to you negative people would be "wheres your music"? haters dont hate, support, if you dont like a track thats cool, we all love constructive critasism, dont bash a good track. if you know anything about music and production, you would know this is a good choon. By the way the EnMass remix is coming out on captivating sounds (armada) on tuesday! |
I don't like the track. I guess I don't know anything about music. And I thought Mr.Mystery's post was an excellent example of constructive criticism, and people who replied to his post with the same feelings weren't harsh either. |
|
|
| djranpage |
The bassline is awful. The percs are overly simplistic and create no drive whatsoever. The bleepy synths get highly annoying after a while. The vocals are OK at best... typical trance nonsense.
Very weak track that tries to ride on the success of White Room. And fails.
Ok, so you call this constructive criticism? I think someone could re word this a little better, or at least I would if I was giving someone constructive criticism, that’s pretty much inconsiderate and giving no respect. Mr. Mystery, I would love to hear your tracks that you have produced, is there any available? Please post a link. Anyway I like this track alot, I think the bass line is rocking, and creative, the percs fit the song perfectly, tuned nicely, and the bleepy synths and vocal are very nice as well. Glad to see all the big djs playing it avb, g&d, Markus Shultz, the list goes on and on! |
|
|
| trance-ecj |
| quote: | Originally posted by djranpage
The bassline is awful. The percs are overly simplistic and create no drive whatsoever. The bleepy synths get highly annoying after a while. The vocals are OK at best... typical trance nonsense.
Very weak track that tries to ride on the success of White Room. And fails.
Ok, so you call this constructive criticism? I think someone could re word this a little better, or at least I would if I was giving someone constructive criticism, that’s pretty much inconsiderate and giving no respect. Mr. Mystery, I would love to hear your tracks that you have produced, is there any available? Please post a link. Anyway I like this track alot, I think the bass line is rocking, and creative, the percs fit the song perfectly, tuned nicely, and the bleepy synths and vocal are very nice as well. Glad to see all the big djs playing it avb, g&d, Markus Shultz, the list goes on and on! |
What more do u want??? most people say awful and that's it....he said what exactly in the track was awful and why....if he wanted to, he could write pages about it just for you, but then you prob wouldn't want to read something that long |
|
|
| Mr.Mystery |
| quote: | Originally posted by djranpage
Ok, so you call this constructive criticism? I think someone could re word this a little better, or at least I would if I was giving someone constructive criticism, that’s pretty much inconsiderate and giving no respect. Mr. Mystery, I would love to hear your tracks that you have produced, is there any available? Please post a link. Anyway I like this track alot, I think the bass line is rocking, and creative, the percs fit the song perfectly, tuned nicely, and the bleepy synths and vocal are very nice as well. Glad to see all the big djs playing it avb, g&d, Markus Shultz, the list goes on and on! |
Why are you taking my comments so damn personally? What difference does it make if I had worded my post differently? The message would still had been the same.
What do my productions have anything to do with this particular track? You can find them easily enough anyway without me pointing them out for you if you really want...
You like this track and I don't. I didn't bash the track mindlessly but I told very clearly what I dislike about the track. You also elaborated your point very clearly. I don't agree with it but I can respect your opinion.
I don't see what your problem is. |
|
|
| varun |
| quote: | Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
The bassline is awful. The percs are overly simplistic and create no drive whatsoever. The bleepy synths get highly annoying after a while. The vocals are OK at best... typical trance nonsense.
Very weak track that tries to ride on the success of White Room. And fails. |
The harsh and cold truth.
Not much to this track at all. There's a heaven and earth difference between this and Whiteroom. |
|
|
| Phortastic |
| quote: | Originally posted by placebo
It sounds awesome when you jack the speed of the song up. |
thats exactly what Enmass did :D
best remix by far imo. |
|
|
| Camwin |
| quote: | Originally posted by Phortastic
thats exactly what Enmass did :D
best remix by far imo. |
I'm sure it's the only rmx :P but i love this song very much, the vocals are different, she's got a very nice voice! but i would like to hear this rmx as i think this tune could really be pushed up a notch to a mass uplifting trancer :) |
|
|
| Phortastic |
| quote: | Originally posted by Camwin
I'm sure it's the only rmx :P |
nope there is a vocal mix and a dub of the original ;) |
|
|
| Trance-Fiend |
| well .. the enmass release is out .. 1000 better then the original |
|
|
| Porky |
| quote: | Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
As you probably saw, I reviewed this track purely from a producer's viewpoint. It's lacking in so many areas that it's not even funny - I hear better tracks on the amateur producer section here every day. |
i have to agree with nik on this
song is nothing special, even worse than the overhyped whiteroom-whiteroom. it just tries to hard, and yes, i've heard better on the amateurs section
4/10
pork |
|
|
| Tenshi |
| quote: | Originally posted by Porky
i have to agree with nik on this
song is nothing special, even worse than the overhyped whiteroom-whiteroom. it just tries to hard, and yes, i've heard better on the amateurs section
4/10
pork |
i also have to agree with mr mystery and porky!
the bassline is just weak, the vocals are 08/15 - melody is quite okay though!
whiteroom is much better! |
|
|
| ACID_Tnce |
| quote: | Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
As you probably saw,]I reviewed this track purely from a producer's viewpoint. It's lacking in so many areas that it's not even funny - I hear better tracks on the amateur producer section here every day. |
Sayin that you are a producer and you heard tracks that are better i would suggest you post a link of some tracks you heard in the amateur section. You compared a production of Andy Moore & Adam White with amateur productions that you listened . If i was a professional producer and compared my songs with songs you heard from "amateurs" i would considere that bashing |
|
|
|
|
