|
Johan Gielen - For You (CD) (pg. 2)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| A.J. |
Mr Mystery is right, you know.
This CD doesn't really offer anything new - you could hear the same tracks on countless compilations that have been released recently. |
|
|
| Sand Leaper |
Why should we reserve our opinion just cos someone might take offense to it? If you can't take the fact people are critical to your own musical taste, you have a very unhealthy relationship towards music in general. Also, if people didn't post their criticisms when they come across music that doesn't meet up to their standards, there would be 0 progress.
And MrMystery is right, this CD looks like a cash grab de luxe, with 12 hits slapped together quickly in order to make a quick buck. |
|
|
| Rich-Art |
what a discussion :)
I'm going to buy the cd to review it. |
|
|
| nwopper |
| Everything ends up into a flamewar lately. |
|
|
| Phortastic |
| quote: | Originally posted by Romain
what if he's negative, just live with that man, you can't change people. should we all be some sort of Care Bears?
and contrary to some people on ta, he is negative BUT respectful & polite.
|
+1 |
|
|
| deibero |
i believe you guys should understand first what was argued before stating your opinions...
i also agree that this cd sucks...if you post your negativity once or ten times is fine, but if any single thread that mentions avb or tiesto he's flaming and bringing his sarcasm then this got to stop...this kills the feeling for any fan who posts on the thread...
so basically, i wasnt commenting just for this thread, is something im doing for the past 2 years ive been in TA... |
|
|
| Sand Leaper |
| quote: | Originally posted by deibero
i believe you guys should understand first what was argued before stating your opinions...
i also agree that this cd sucks...if you post your negativity once or ten times is fine, but if any single thread that mentions avb or tiesto he's flaming and bringing his sarcasm then this got to stop |
Frankly I haven't seen him post in here for quite some time now, and as other people pointed out, when he does critcize he does it thoroughly. And as long as the criticism is thorough people can do it all they want. That some people who like the music may get offended by his opinion means nothing. |
|
|
| deibero |
i agree with what you're saying, but listen to my point:
this is not about respect anymore...
if you critizice various artists for a couple of years and his one of the people that posts most frequently in these forums, everybody already knows what he thinks and what he feels about the gielen cd or about tiesto's love comes again or avb asot 2005...
so for everyone, who does like it and posts on those threads it would be more comfortable if he stays away...
he's not saying anything new for anyone here and his sarcasm does bother some people... |
|
|
| Sand Leaper |
| quote: | Originally posted by deibero
i agree with what you're saying, but listen to my point:
this is not about respect anymore...
if you critizice various artists for a couple of years and his one of the people that posts most frequently in these forums, everybody already knows what he thinks and what he feels about the gielen cd or about tiesto's love comes again or avb asot 2005...
so for everyone, who does like it and posts on those threads it would be more comfortable if he stays away...
he's not saying anything new for anyone here and his sarcasm does bother some people... |
Same thing. People are free to voice their opinion on whichever artist/release they feel like, and as long as they do it thoroughly people will just have to deal with it, regardless of how offended they may get. That they have voiced this opinion many times already is irrelevant. For those who really are bothered so much about these people, there is a handy function called ignore. |
|
|
| deibero |
fine, i see that this is going nowhere...
i'm done also... |
|
|
| LeopoldStotch |
| quote: | Originally posted by n0bben
02. Find (Andy Moor Mix) - Ridgewalkers
this seems to be on ALL recent "trance" VA compliations |
+1 .. i think i have seen this track in about 10 various mixes cds, and many many live sets ...
good tune though .. kudos to the ridgewalkers, and also to one of my fav producers andy moor .. |
|
|
| LeopoldStotch |
| i am not going to diss johan gielen in a big way, but i am going to say that his productions post-svenson&gielen have been a notch down ... svenson is good and everything .. liked the single 'inside outside' .. but i think they need to come back together, and put down a couple of more production tracks .. just my opinion .. |
|
|
|
|
