|
Mixmags top 100 dj poll???
|
View this Thread in Original format
| djbruuen |
| who thinks this poll should be left to a panel of reputable experts opposed to being open to the public? i'm sorry, but somethings the public shouldn't be aloud to vote on. in a real poll tiesto wouldn't be the #1 dj. just my opinion, so voice yours! |
|
|
| RapidFire |
| In my oppinion; neither. Ask top DJ's to name an artist they think is the greatest (aside from themselves) and base it on which DJ's were chosen the most (from 1-100). Experts and fans aside, the masters of the craft know best. |
|
|
| djbruuen |
| i could see some bias in that though. i think a proper criteria that experts use to properly evaluate all eligable djs would be the best solution for a more accurate result. |
|
|
| Mark Walker |
| Its just a vote for the most popularist dj, and with tiesto playing the olimpics hes bound to be number 1. I think they shouldnt even bother with it!!!! |
|
|
| isoterra |
| kept how it is, since it's never claimed to be anything more than a popularity vote. |
|
|
| UnBracKo |
everybody should know dj mag list doesn't show the quality of the dj's, dj mag is just a list of the most popular dj's!
so the vote system should still being the same as now, |
|
|
| sthus |
| Well, the public to be a good Dj you gotta be a crowd pleaser so i guess it makes sense |
|
|
| shades_of_gray |
| the mixmags top 100 will be even worse than the dj magazine poll, |
|
|
| sEpH |
| only professional Djs |
|
|
| infinity0908 |
| there are no experts. |
|
|
| bananas |
| quote: | Originally posted by infinity0908
there are no experts. |
+1 |
|
|
| Lira |
It should be an objective contest, with entries like:
- Introduction of new scratching techniques
- Difference in BPM from the slowest to the fastest tune of most sets (the broader, the better)
- Introduction of new mixing techniques
- Range of macro-ranges playes (really, playing "uplifting trance" and "progressive trance" is nothing more than what a trance DJ should play - but playing house, trance, drum'n'bass, jazz and country music with competence is something that should be praised).
- Number of tunes played every 60 min (the more, the better... spending 6 minutes playing the same tune should be considered a joke)
- Number of tunes played throughout the year.
That would make things a tad bit more challenging, for example. |
|
|
|
|
