|
Feedback/brainstorm thread for the new ID Contest (pg. 2)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| DJAntSmith |
| quote: | Originally posted by Floorfiller
but i'll still just enter the advanced one because of ego and i'll still lose and never make a contest :stongue: |
:haha:
I'd enter the easy one and try and steal some glory! :p |
|
|
| DRM |
i think some people aren't realising how difficult it is to gauge whether a track will be easy or hard to ID. Other than things like Delerium - Silence, Out Of The Blue, Urban Train etc the really really obvious ones which maybe amount to about 200 tunes max, then the rest of trance really does totally depend on each person as to whether they have heard it. Something like NuNRG - Casino that a PvD fan would think is ridiculously easy then someone who doesnt listen to PvD won't have a clue what it is.
With that in mind some of the ideas put forward here simply will not work. |
|
|
| Floorfiller |
| quote: | Originally posted by DRM
i think some people aren't realising how difficult it is to gauge whether a track will be easy or hard to ID. Other than things like Delerium - Silence, Out Of The Blue, Urban Train etc the really really obvious ones which maybe amount to about 200 tunes max, then the rest of trance really does totally depend on each person as to whether they have heard it. Something like NuNRG - Casino that a PvD fan would think is ridiculously easy then someone who doesnt listen to PvD won't have a clue what it is.
With that in mind some of the ideas put forward here simply will not work. |
i agree...like all of the ASOT tracks are easy for peeps that listen to that, but i couldn't tell you jas van houten vs armin vs anything... |
|
|
| paranoik0 |
what about adding 5 .jpgs of album covers as extras to ID :wtf:
the tables Fundamental did are pretty cool, it gives extra status to get one ID nobody else got :D should be kept going (if the ID contest maker has the patience of course)
what about having the next ID Contest made by the guy with more points that never did an ID Contest before, instead of the winner which has won it a trillion times already.. it's the only way me and others have a chance :p
or maybe.. special themed ID Contests. like, let's say a round of ID Contests per genre. one house contest, then one trance contest, then techno and so on. or by year, only 1997 tracks allowed, stuff like that
i dunno, just brainstorming really. what i know is that there's being more and more people participating on this, and they are fun, so even if the concept doesn't change it should be kept going..
by the way, anyone has the full list of winners? i could search a bit and compile one if there's interest |
|
|
|
|
