|
Gabriel & Dresden (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| starstarman |
| quote: | Originally posted by AngusG
I like gabriel and dresden and do say they make good progressive trance.. i haven't heard that chuggy prog feel that portobello has...
build a bridge and get over it :nervous: |
May I reiterate,
| quote: | Originally posted by starstarman
But if you even challenge and say they make good music. Sorry, they do not. |
And build a bridge and get over it is not a knowledgeable statement to prove anything.
Thank you. |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
Was a big fan 'til Tracking Treasure Down... :nervous:
Well... that, and the whole Jamie/Lunasea/Davedresden incident, right?
:p |
|
|
| AngusG |
| quote: | Originally posted by starstarman
May I reiterate, |
No...
| quote: | Originally posted by starstarman
And build a bridge and get over it is not a knowledgeable statement to prove anything.
Thank you. |
To say 'Sorry they do not make good music' is not a knowledgable statement to impress your opinion on anyone else...
show me where i said you have to like their music...
as I said I like their music, and I think they're quality...
In regards to what I said about Portobello, I meant it's quite an original sound In My Opinion
Thanks for coming, have a nice day
| quote: | | The latest by them sounds like trancy pop imo. |
Is this Tracking Treasure Down?? not a fan of that track at all... |
|
|
| Cobalt |
| quote: | Originally posted by Col
Couldn't agree more.
Their remix of 'Beachball' is a brilliant production, really captures the summery feel.
Pretty much everything else is e though. I really mean that. I just detest the "natural" style of trance they provide us with, it should be considered a different genre altogether, in my view.
'Tracking Treasure Down' is plain awful, their remix of 'No-One On Earth' might just be the most overrated track in trance history, and 'Around You' (Motorcycle) might as well have been a pop-rock ballad. The 4/4 beat is only there so Armin can play on his show.
It makes me wonder how many people who listened to trance during the "good old days" actually like G&D. I mean, I'm really trying not to come across as an elitist. But their style of trance isn't just pushing the boundaries, but it's a complete reversal, a demolition of what trance actually is. It takes the piss. |
Yeah, I agree.
In fact, I think I'm going to start saying "Regressive Trance" instead of McProg or American Progressive, because it's pretty damn accurate. |
|
|
| starstarman |
| quote: | Originally posted by AngusG
No...
To say 'Sorry they do not make good music' is not a knowledgable statement to impress your opinion on anyone else...
show me where i said you have to like their music...
as I said I like their music, and I think they're quality...
In regards to what I said about Portobello, I meant it's quite an original sound In My Opinion
Thanks for coming, have a nice day
Is this Tracking Treasure Down?? not a fan of that track at all... |
Umm.. I guess you have a serious misunderstanding. Something that one likes does not mean that is good. It's like popularity does not equal to quality. Hope it makes things clear now. I will not ever want to change your taste in listening anything but if you want to comment and rate a track or producer about any technical criteria, I wish you could give certain proof that is convincible enough.
Good day to you too. |
|
|
| FiK |
| quote: | Originally posted by starstarman
Sorry G&D are neither prog nor trance, or maybe rarely they had been for a few tracks. Anyways, classification is just up to per individual standard. If you say you haven't heard a thing like Portobello, then you should search and try to listen more. MIKE has done so much of such electro-ish bassline ages ago and moreover they sound much better than this. What G&D's done is just replacing the deep depressive melody with another lousy and superficial cheesy progression which they are good at.
If you said simply coz you like it and it's your taste then all fine. But if you even challenge and say they make good music. Sorry, they do not. |
Your an idiot. How can you tell someone what good music is, music is something that each person can enterpret however they like and take it however they like, which is what is so good about it.
I'm not a fan of a lot of styels of music, but i can still respect that to the fans of that music it is extremely fulfilling.
How about you let people focus on the positives and not come in and focus on the negatives all the time. Go listen to n Trance nation 1999 and leave us to have our posts |
|
|
| AngusG |
| quote: | Originally posted by FiK
Go listen to n Trance nation 1999 and leave us to have our posts |
Hehe... that series was mint |
|
|
| starstarman |
| quote: | Originally posted by FiK
Your an idiot. How can you tell someone what good music is, music is something that each person can enterpret however they like and take it however they like, which is what is so good about it.
I'm not a fan of a lot of styels of music, but i can still respect that to the fans of that music it is extremely fulfilling.
How about you let people focus on the positives and not come in and focus on the negatives all the time. Go listen to n Trance nation 1999 and leave us to have our posts |
I dunno if you have taken any musical education. There are a lot of theories behind, in any criteria like melodic progression, harmonic progression, emotional expression, etc. And there are other studio technics, history knowledge, producing skills, etc. that can be discussed and commented.
If you just want your post to be a full thread of regressive electronica praising then fine. And that only shows how coarse members of the board has become these years.
I really wish someone that could give convincible proof to show how idiot my comments in this thread is. If that happens, I will surely bend and appreciate one's insight. |
|
|
| FiK |
| quote: | Originally posted by starstarman
I dunno if you have taken any musical education. There are a lot of theories behind, in any criteria like melodic progression, harmonic progression, emotional expression, etc. And there are other studio technics, history knowledge, producing skills, etc. that can be discussed and commented.
If you just want your post to be a full thread of regressive electronica praising then fine. And that only shows how coarse members of the board has become these years.
I really wish someone that could give convincible proof to show how idiot my comments in this thread is. If that happens, I will surely bend and appreciate one's insight. |
ok thats fair enough, but essentially what i said was in the same vein as what you did in your previous post. imo, and a fair few others, G & D are still creating very entertaining music with extremely good "melodic progression, harmonic progression, emotional expression, etc.". granted this isnt present in all their productions but its still something that can be pretty subjective, which is why i didnt agree with you saying it was "not good music". |
|
|
| miamitranceman |
| quote: | Originally posted by FiK
Go listen to n Trance nation 1999 and leave us to have our posts |
:stongue: |
|
|
| InterMilan31 |
| Even with all the hate they get here including me on Dave I enjoy Gabriel & Dresden alot...I find them to be my perfect balance between house and trance. Love their productions and remixes and would easily find myself going to pay no more than 25 bucks to see them live....let my flamming begin |
|
|
| starstarman |
| quote: | Originally posted by FiK
ok thats fair enough, but essentially what i said was in the same vein as what you did in your previous post. imo, and a fair few others, G & D are still creating very entertaining music with extremely good "melodic progression, harmonic progression, emotional expression, etc.". granted this isnt present in all their productions but its still something that can be pretty subjective, which is why i didnt agree with you saying it was "not good music". |
How do you define their progression being "extremely good" then? 90% of the melody is in major key, ok there's nth wrong with major but the progression is almost repeatedly going thru a perfect cadence or even staying on the I. That is good? And lately their bassline is even more horrid. Just exactly a simple square pulse in low pass. Well that had been good when I was stilling fooling with my red & white nintendo listening to those game music. But regretfullly, the melody in those game music is even more complicated and well spotted than theirs. |
|
|
|
|
