|
James Zabiela - Weird Science [RENX038] (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| isoterra |
| yet you wouldn't have batted an eyelid if a non-producer said it, which is what makes it ty. just in the way people don't have to be producers themselves to criticise the productions of others, those who ARE producers shouldn't have to use their own material to back up their criticism |
|
|
| Tayfoon |
| I think people who work in the same industry and do the same thing have more weight to their words |
|
|
| RapidFire |
| quote: | Originally posted by Tayfoon
I think people who work in the same industry and do the same thing have more weight to their words |
not when they dont produce the same genre of music. |
|
|
| placebo |
| quote: | Originally posted by Tayfoon
WTF ?
Where did I say my opinion matters more ?
I thought it was Ironic that a producer said another one shouldnt produce
Let it go |
flamewar, yay! |
|
|
| Mike_Foyle |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
Are you saying that you think his remixes of Ficta - "Eli" are somehow lacking?
:conf:
If so, no offense Mike, I really dig your productions and even the ones I don't, I recognize and respect as, for the most part, being VERY well produced, but those remixes (Rave Lizard and RL Reprise) are both better than most of what I've heard in your discography.
IMO, James doesn't produce enough. |
ive only heard the rave lizard remix of ficta - eli and i thought it was disgraceful.
anyway why would the fact that im a " producer" stop me being allowed to comment on someone elses productions? this forum is full of critics, few of which can make music at all, but that doesnt mean they dont have a right to critisize someone elses work. i think that my discography is completely irrelevant.
james' remix of eli that ive heard sounds like it has not been mixed or eqed at all. is is excrutiatinly basic and boring and lacks imagination... thats just my opinion.
when it comes to djing he is the dogs bollocks and i was blown away when i last saw him. |
|
|
| paranoik0 |
personally, i think his mix of ficta - eli is his best track to date. perhaps not very complicated technically but i don't give a about that, it's definitely a good track in my opinion.
how come it lacks imagination, the vocals he added fit perfectly and actually enhance the track, who could have seen that coming? |
|
|
| adi26 |
Yo Mike!!
Shipwrecked = AWESOME PRODUCTION!!! |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by Mike_Foyle
ive only heard the rave lizard remix of ficta - eli and i thought it was disgraceful.
anyway why would the fact that im a " producer" stop me being allowed to comment on someone elses productions? this forum is full of critics, few of which can make music at all, but that doesnt mean they dont have a right to critisize someone elses work. i think that my discography is completely irrelevant.
james' remix of eli that ive heard sounds like it has not been mixed or eqed at all. is is excrutiatinly basic and boring and lacks imagination... thats just my opinion.
when it comes to djing he is the dogs bollocks and i was blown away when i last saw him. |
Not once did I call you a " producer."
Quite the contrary.
Respectfully disagree. |
|
|
| Mike_Foyle |
| quote: | Originally posted by paranoik0
personally, i think his mix of ficta - eli is his best track to date. perhaps not very complicated technically but i don't give a about that, it's definitely a good track in my opinion.
how come it lacks imagination, the vocals he added fit perfectly and actually enhance the track, who could have seen that coming? |
fair enough man its just my opinion thats all. i guess i expected more because hes such a good dj.
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
Not once did I call you a " producer."
Quite the contrary.
Respectfully disagree. |
oh i was reffering to that other guy, sorry lol.. wrong quote. :) |
|
|
| placebo |
| why can't we be friends, why can't we be friends |
|
|
| djarecebo |
| Heard this played out during WMC, its definately fun live. Like most Jz productions, its something that fits well into his own sets, but can prove hard for other djs to fit into their sets. Its not as catchy as Robophobia and I don't think itll be as big of a track either, but definately a nice complement to his sets. Skanksuary is still my favorite original production of his. I'd give it a 6/10 |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by djarecebo
Heard this played out during WMC, its definately fun live. Like most Jz productions, its something that fits well into his own sets, but can prove hard for other djs to fit into their sets. Its not as catchy as Robophobia and I don't think itll be as big of a track either, but definately a nice complement to his sets. Skanksuary is still my favorite original production of his. I'd give it a 6/10 |
Really well put Garth! |
|
|
|
|
