|
New York Giants Thread (pg. 12)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Groundhog Boy |
| quote: | Originally posted by phuzzyfish12
painful to watch already....so what happens if Eli doesn't win?? I am all for getting a new QB for sure. |
Why are you all for getting a new QB? Who in the NFL would you replace him with? The Giants went 10-6, losing to only other playoff teams (except the Vikings). They lost to Dallas twice, to Green Bay, New England (in a very close game), and Washington (where he played a horrible game).
I don't think that the Giants have the team to compete with Green Bay, Dallas or New England this year (or the Colts, who they never played). That's not Eli Manning's fault. His major flaw this season has been the turnovers, both INTs and fumbles, but he's got a 56% completion rating, his TDs are normal considering how much running the Giants do, and his QB rating is pretty respectable.
Sure, the Giants might be better with Peyton, Tom Brady, Roethlisberger, Tony Romo, Brett Favre, maybe a few others. That said, he's still one of the top 10 QBs in the NFL and pretty much all the others are staying put. |
|
|
| RoBDaWG |
| BIIIG MUTHA FUGGIN BLUE!!!!!! Lookin GOOD out there today! |
|
|
| ReenTeenTeen |
| Dallas is getting their arses wooped next week!!!:whip: |
|
|
| saltytheseagull |
| quote: | Originally posted by Groundhog Boy
Why are you all for getting a new QB? Who in the NFL would you replace him with? The Giants went 10-6, losing to only other playoff teams (except the Vikings). They lost to Dallas twice, to Green Bay, New England (in a very close game), and Washington (where he played a horrible game).
I don't think that the Giants have the team to compete with Green Bay, Dallas or New England this year (or the Colts, who they never played). That's not Eli Manning's fault. His major flaw this season has been the turnovers, both INTs and fumbles, but he's got a 56% completion rating, his TDs are normal considering how much running the Giants do, and his QB rating is pretty respectable.
Sure, the Giants might be better with Peyton, Tom Brady, Roethlisberger, Tony Romo, Brett Favre, maybe a few others. That said, he's still one of the top 10 QBs in the NFL and pretty much all the others are staying put. |
Anyone who can make better decisions than Eli. As far as not having the team to compete did you not watch the games? The should have won the 1st Dallas game and beat the Pats. Eli threw the Pats game away (I can't remember if he threw the Dallas one away because it's been so long ago.). He had a good game for himself on Sun. If it were any other quarterback though it would have a been a below average game. |
|
|
| phuzzyfish12 |
Well I eat all my negative words from this season. WAY TO GO GIANTS!!!!
Romo was a mess today :wtf: |
|
|
| vtec junkie |
| quote: | Originally posted by trunks1022
g-men! |
nah correction......J-men ;) lol |
|
|
| ReenTeenTeen |
| I am on cloud nine |
|
|
| vtec junkie |
| Today sucks.....because the only two teams that had a chance of beating the Patriots....lost. :whip: |
|
|
| djquick83 |
| quote: | Originally posted by vtec junkie
Today sucks.....because the only two teams that had a chance of beating the Patriots....lost. :whip: |
Greenbay will beat em in the Superbowl. ;) |
|
|
| southbound24 |
| giants played the Pats hard and almost won, so dont despair, although winning in Lambeau againts the legend is not an easy task |
|
|
| djquick83 |
| quote: | Originally posted by southbound24
giants played the Pats hard and almost won, so dont despair, although winning in Lambeau againts the legend is not an easy task |
All i know is Favre's experience outweighs any heroics of Brady over the past 3 seasons. When it comes down to it, I dont see them winning against the Packers. Close game yea, but I have a feeling Favre will win it this yr. |
|
|
|
|
