return to tranceaddict TranceAddict Forums Archive > Main Forums > Music Discussion

Pages: [1] 2 
Same Basslines..
View this Thread in Original format
Bidor
just noticed when i heard :

"Pink - Stupid Girls (Hanis Stupid Remix)"

that the bassline is stolen from :

"Dave Mccullen - B*tch."


why do some producers have to steal from others in order to make their song sound better?!:mad:



*(&^!*%@*^%#:whip: :toothless
SMC
How exactly does one come to own a bassline?
Bidor
quote:
Originally posted by SMC
How exactly does one come to own a bassline?


well i mean not own.. but Dave mccullen had it first created. and simply other people are mimic'ing it. is that not like uh stealing? :conf:
stevieboy32808
Already been covered. For more about sampling (illegal or not) see here:
http://www.tranceaddict.com/forums/...threadid=376363
Bidor
quote:
Originally posted by stevieboy32808
Already been covered. For more about sampling (illegal or not) see here:
http://www.tranceaddict.com/forums/...threadid=376363


how could i have missed that thread.. tnx mate! :)
ASFSE
quote:
Originally posted by Bidor
just noticed when i heard :

"Pink - Stupid Girls (Hanis Stupid Remix)"

that the bassline is stolen from :

"Dave Mccullen - B*tch."


why do some producers have to steal from others in order to make their song sound better?!:mad:



*(&^!*%@*^%#:whip: :toothless


a lot of music is recycled, sometimes you can tell, other times no, and that's where top 10 hits come from.
SYSTEM-J
quote:
Originally posted by Bidor
well i mean not own.. but Dave mccullen had it first created. and simply other people are mimic'ing it. is that not like uh stealing? :conf:


Right. So before writing a piece of music, you must listen to every track ever written to make sure you're not going to replicate something?
Bidor
quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
Right. So before writing a piece of music, you must listen to every track ever written to make sure you're not going to replicate something?


uhh...


i get your point... :o
SMC
quote:
Originally posted by Bidor
well i mean not own.. but Dave mccullen had it first created.


First of all, you can't possibly know that. Second, it's irrelevant.



quote:
and simply other people are mimic'ing it. is that not like uh stealing? :conf:


No, it really isn't.
Bidor
quote:
Originally posted by SMC
First of all, you can't possibly know that. Second, it's irrelevant.





No, it really isn't.


pls be more detailed with your feedback. :thepirate

SMC
quote:
Originally posted by Bidor
pls be more detailed with your feedback. :thepirate


What is unclear?
Bidor
quote:
Originally posted by SMC
What is unclear?


my right eye.. :thepirate





:stongue:
CLICK TO RETURN TO TOP OF PAGE
Pages: [1] 2 
Privacy Statement