|
Top Chef... (pg. 5)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Ed G |
| quote: | Originally posted by EXTREMUM
Unfortunately, I think Ilan will get it - gut feeling. |
Your guts are smart.
The Bravo editors really had me believing that Marcel had won it. My take on what the judges thought of him is that he's a more creative and original chef, but that he needs time to mature. Leaving behind key ingredients is totally amature. That and the salad thingy did him in. Give me a break do0d, lettuce, radishes and cucumber!
Ilan. Dewd, did you really say that you "would love to piss on Marcel"? Oh, and the canned worms weren't worth all of the build up. Bravo clearly commented on this with the cheesy "all hail the King" music they played when it was presented. You're just lucky that you didn't have to go up against Sam, he would have erased you.
I think what ed Sam was the 2 month lay off period before the Hawaii trip. I'm thinking that everyone around him was drilling him constantly with comments about how he was going to win. By the time he got to the finals he was fryz0rd. Don't worry too much Sammy, in most peoples eyes you're the winner. The success will come. |
|
|
| EXTREMUM |
| quote: | Originally posted by Ed G
Your guts are smart.
Ilan. Dewd, did you really say that you "would love to piss on Marcel"? Oh, and the canned worms weren't worth all of the build up. Bravo clearly commented on this with the cheesy "all hail the King" music they played when it was presented. You're just lucky that you didn't have to go up against Sam, he would have erased you. |
I had a bad feeling about this. I really wanted to see Marcel win, only because his dishes have top-notch creativity, which proves he can create excellent dishes of any culture. What I don't understand, is why Marcel picked Michael to help out, since he's lousy under pressure. Ilan stuck to what he knew most, playing it safe, as usual - blah, blah, blah, one-dimensional Spanish... For Ilan saying he wanted to piss on Marcel - that's just flat-out GAY! The way he said it, added to the suspense. However, I LOL'd so f'in hard. :wtf: :haha:
| quote: | Originally posted by Ed G
I think what ed Sam was the 2 month lay off period before the Hawaii trip. I'm thinking that everyone around him was drilling him constantly with comments about how he was going to win. By the time he got to the finals he was fryz0rd. Don't worry too much Sammy, in most peoples eyes you're the winner. The success will come. |
Sam would've destroyed Ilan. Face it... Line Cook vs. Executive Chef - no contest. However, seeing Sam and Marcel in the finals would've been kickass, too... |
|
|
| Ed G |
| quote: | Originally posted by EXTREMUM
I had a bad feeling about this. I really wanted to see Marcel win, only because his dishes have top-notch creativity, which proves he can create excellent dishes of any culture. What I don't understand, is why Marcel picked Michael to help out, since he's lousy under pressure. Ilan stuck to what he knew most, playing it safe, as usual - blah, blah, blah, one-dimensional Spanish... For Ilan saying he wanted to piss on Marcel - that's just flat-out GAY! The way he said it, added to the suspense. However, I LOL'd so f'in hard. :wtf: :haha:
Sam would've destroyed Ilan. Face it... Line Cook vs. Executive Chef - no contest. However, seeing Sam and Marcel in the finals would've been kickass, too... |
I think the problem might have been that None of the potential sous chefs liked Marcel. Hell, nobody likes him. In the end maybe he screwed himself with the cocky attitude.
If I was one of his sous chefs he would have won. He would have had the fish, and I could have found a way to make the "glass" thingys work. Also I would have clued him about the in salad omg. |
|
|
| EXTREMUM |
| quote: | Originally posted by Ed G
I think the problem might have been that None of the potential sous chefs liked Marcel. Hell, nobody likes him. In the end maybe he screwed himself with the cocky attitude.
If I was one of his sous chefs he would have won. He would have had the fish, and I could have found a way to make the "glass" thingys work. Also I would have clued him about the in salad omg. |
The salad was lame. Plus, I don't believe Michael really cared in helping out Marcel. Sam was nice enough to help redeem Marcel's third course, from the absence of the fish - still turned out to be a good dish, according to the comments given. Again, all Sam.
The layout of the last elimination was very lame, as a finals elimination. This should've been a 1 vs. 1 elimination with extra time to prepare, not 1 vs. 1 plus two sou chefs which turned out to be losers of the previous rounds. This did put Marcel in a bind, since everyone hated him - his Ghosts of Episodes Past, if you will. Karma prevails, once again... |
|
|
| OurManFlint |
Personaly, I thought the fact that they had to pick two chefs that were previously eliminated was a bad call. All of those people kind of had bad blood with Marcel. And why the did he pick Micheal. Definently wouldn't depend on him to be there 100% for the final.
I thought Marcel was better than Ilan in the creativity of the dishes. Ilan kept making Spanish dishes. I don't think any other chefs on the show focused their dishes on one cuisine. Marcel showed he was more versitile and more creative in his approach. Ilan just stuck to the same old method of Spanish focused dishes.
ing Elia. She blurted out right away when asked who she thinks should win should be Ilan. Total bias and probably still has a grudge against him when she looked like an ass last week. Again, bringing the chefs that have lost the competition back into the competition just seems to worsen the situation. They shouldn't even have asked for their opinions. What I get from this show is that it's not a "top chef" competition, it's a cooking competition. How well you can display your culinary talent. By asking the sou chefs how they liked working in the kitchen with the two finalists, it brings in elements that are not important in judging the food. It probably just makes for good TV.
So, did Ilan win based on his food. I think both Marcel and Ilan had equal amounts of complimants and rants about their dishes. In my opinion, Marcel won it through versitility and creativity. They probably knocked off the points for having the disorganization in the kitchen, but is this a cooking competition or a competition based off your ability to run a kitchen? |
|
|
| EXTREMUM |
Sam - total pro in the kitchen. Good team leader - his job title speaks for itself...Executive Chef.
Betty - not a chef. She's a homecook, at best. I wouldn't invite her over, to cook for me.
Elia - good cook, and creative. However, she turned into a real bitch, after Betty left. It just goes to show how SOME women try to "hold it down" on their own, and fail. It all started, with the head shaving thing. Sorry, she's not badass.
Cliff - control freake, hot-tempered , as a teamplayer, and cannot handle pressure. Need I say more?
Michael - he looks, acts, and performs like your average 6am Monday morning deli cook, serving scrambled egg sandwiches, bagels, and coffee.
Ilan - One-dimensional Spanish Cuisine cook - that is all. Oh yeah, I forgot - he publically announced that he wanted piss on Marcel. I see an R. Kelly video, in his future... :wtf:
Marcel - I'll admit, he's a little cocky, but he has to talent to back it up. He'll turn any food culture into a masterpiece.
Padma - I hit it. |
|
|
| kid nyce |
| quote: | Originally posted by EXTREMUM
Sam - total pro in the kitchen. Good team leader - his job title speaks for itself...Executive Chef.
Betty - not a chef. She's a homecook, at best. I wouldn't invite her over, to cook for me.
Elia - good cook, and creative. However, she turned into a real bitch, after Betty left. It just goes to show how SOME women try to "hold it down" on their own, and fail. It all started, with the head shaving thing. Sorry, she's not badass.
Cliff - control freake, hot-tempered , as a teamplayer, and cannot handle pressure. Need I say more?
Michael - he looks, acts, and performs like your average 6am Monday morning deli cook, serving scrabled egg sandwiches, bagels, and coffee.
Ilan - One-dimensional Spanish Cuisine cook - that is all. Oh yeah, I forgot - he publically announced that he wanted piss on Marcel. I see an R. Kelly video, in his future... :wtf:
Marcel - I'll admit, he's a little cocky, but he has to talent to back it up. He'll turn any food culture into a masterpiece.
Padma - I hit it. |
thats pretty accurate! elia i'd definitely bang out the bitch in her...she sounds like she needs her butthax'd and i'd give it to her too...padma can get it too, she even sports that scar on her right arm with class...very pretty woman! |
|
|
| Ed G |
| quote: | Originally posted by OurManFlint
They probably knocked off the points for having the disorganization in the kitchen, but is this a cooking competition or a competition based off your ability to run a kitchen? |
There were conflicting comments about this by the judges, but I think it's clear that Top Chef is about more than just straight cooking skills.
The position of chef is a management position and people skills are vital. That doesn't mean you have to be nice, or popular, but you have to be able to get people to do what you want consistantly. |
|
|
| EXTREMUM |
| quote: | Originally posted by kid nyce
thats pretty accurate! |
Thanks, I think I've followed the show too well, for my own good. :haha:
| quote: | | padma can get it too, she even sports that scar on her right arm with class...very pretty woman! |
She is very high class, and sexy. Those Blonde Bimbos of Orange County don't have on her. :toocool: |
|
|
| EXTREMUM |
| quote: | Originally posted by Ed G
There were conflicting comments about this by the judges, but I think it's clear that Top Chef is about more than just straight cooking skills.
The position of chef is a management position and people skills are vital. That doesn't mean you have to be nice, or popular, but you have to be able to get people to do what you want consistantly. |
All about Sam... |
|
|
| djmaxima |
| quote: | Originally posted by XoxidE
makes me hungry. |
true that :toothless |
|
|
| Miss Bliss |
uncreative, boring episode, not enough suspense, ended way too fast, Michael sucks, Ilan sucks, I'm never watching Top Chef again if there's another season becuase I'm so disappointed Marcel lost.
BTW I can't believe the comments about the women that you dumbasses are capable of making is about how either she's a bitch or you wanna put it in her ass... or both... I can't believe you don't realize how disrespectful you little children are sometimes |
|
|
|
|
