|
What was the problem?
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Synchronicity |
I'm baffled.
The guy asks what equipment his favourite producer uses, then he gets the piss taken out of him and the thread closed?
The question was legitimate because different synths have different characters and can create different sounds.
What if GOY wants to sound like Jaytech? So what, if he has fun doing so then good for him, I'm all for it.
If a guy went on a Hendrix forum and asked how to get the tones that Hendrix did, should he be told 'buying same as Hendrix won't make you as good as him.' Of course not, because that's making the assumption that the guy thinks he will instantly sound like Hendrix. For all you now the guy knows fine well he'll have to practice his ass off.
From what I see, you had an answer before GOY even asked the question. |
|
|
| Synchronicity |
I don't want to start a flame war. I just didn't see what was wrong with the question.
If any kind soul knows what stuff Jaytech uses, maybe they can pm GOY or something. :tongue2 |
|
|
| michaelconway |
| yea, I just read the thread too. Its not like he was asking "how do i make trance" which actually get more answers than i saw in that thread. :conf: |
|
|
| Allied Nations |
I said I'd ask him next time he's in town... :p
As for the thread, it was going nowhere so I closed it. It seemed lost. |
|
|
| echosystm |
| there was no problem, its just more fun to tease people than to help them. |
|
|
| BOOsTER |
| quote: | Originally posted by Allied Nations
As for the thread, it was going nowhere so I closed it. It seemed lost. |
as is this one going anywhere though...
Synchronicity: I don't think I'm that unhelpful type of guy to deserve to be quoted like this...kthxbye |
|
|
| Fledz |
It's TA, this is a rather common practice so don't take it to heart. Hopefully he will ask somewhere where it's more friendly. I thought the question was fine.
How nice of Booster to take it off on a tangent :rolleyes: |
|
|
| Mr.Mystery |
The thing is he could had easily found it out himself by doing a bit of research. I just spent 5 seconds of my life and I immediately found out his contact details where I could ask the info from.
How are we supposed to know what equipment a certain producer uses? |
|
|
| DigiNut |
I interpreted the question as asking what sequencer he used, not which synths (hence my answer in that thread). If that was the intended meaning, it was a very dumb question, because sequencers don't have any character or distinctive sound whatsoever.
But it's not a good question even if he meant soft-synths. Post a sample and ask how the sound is made. Those questions always get answered, to the best of our members' abilities. Nobody has a problem with those. A non-specific question like "what software does DJ Tiesto use cuz I wanna sound like him" only seems to reveal a deep and willful ignorance about how the music is created, and I'm not inclined to encourage such people who really shouldn't be producing at all. |
|
|
| Synchronicity |
| quote: | Originally posted by DigiNut
I interpreted the question as asking what sequencer he used, not which synths (hence my answer in that thread). If that was the intended meaning, it was a very dumb question, because sequencers don't have any character or distinctive sound whatsoever.
But it's not a good question even if he meant soft-synths. Post a sample and ask how the sound is made. Those questions always get answered, to the best of our members' abilities. Nobody has a problem with those. A non-specific question like "what software does DJ Tiesto use cuz I wanna sound like him" only seems to reveal a deep and willful ignorance about how the music is created, and I'm not inclined to encourage such people who really shouldn't be producing at all. |
I lolled at the ejay crack and a couple of the other posts actually.
I'd say I half agree with you here.
In terms of posting a sample - that would be helpful. But I do think sometimes it can be more suitable to create the timbres on the same synths as the pro in question. For a perfect replication of someones sound you will probably need to use exactly what they use but I guess if you just want the general picture of what sort of settings to use then most synths will do the trick.
I was always uber-fussy that way.. A big part of the reason I bought my synths was that I knew a lot of the songs I like had been created on them. I used to moan to myself about how I hated Vstis and they weren't up to the job etc. Whether this is true or not doesn't matter, buying the synths just shut up that nagging voice in my head and now I have no excuses! That's more of a personal thing but still kinda related.
And to Booster: It's not like I'm trying to insult you, I just disagree with you on this occasion. |
|
|
| BOOsTER |
| quote: | Originally posted by Synchronicity
And to Booster: It's not like I'm trying to insult you, I just disagree with you on this occasion. |
ok man, whatever, peace ;) |
|
|
|
|
