|
Mixed in Key - Any Good?iews about thi (pg. 3)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Ryan0751 |
Sadly though... lots of bedroom DJ's heard the phrase "harmonic mixing" and "the big DJ's do it..." and don't really want to be bothered with learning scales and keys.
| quote: | Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
um, which is why we write the key on our tracks perhaps?? "doing your research" does not equate with using ripoff software like mixed in key. my ears are cheaper and far more accurate. |
|
|
|
| miamitranceman |
I totally feel you on this. Sometimes you play a track and you recognize part of it in another track and you go "wow I really need ot mix that one next". It's true sometimes it doesn't work and it doesn't come to me all the time, but more often than not it works out well.
| quote: | Originally posted by nefardec
the best track-track mixes i've ever done have always been those where i am just getting into the track that's currently playing and suddenly in my mind's ear i 'hear' another sound and then when i catch that sound in my head i think "where did that come from" and then i realize it's part of another track and then the more I think of it the better it will sound.
even before 'key matching', i would stress 'sound matching' or 'tone matching', where you're mixing tracks with similar tonal, sonic, and rhythmic concepts. the key is just sort of a basic metric that doesn't tell you much about anything. just because two songs are in related keys doesn't mean anything
Problem is this sort of creative flash doesn't come ALL the time, and sometimes the intuition is just wrong, so when you have your tracks keyed it gives you an affirmation of what you already knew |
|
|
|
| Stu Cox |
| quote: | Originally posted by nefardec
the best track-track mixes i've ever done have always been those where i am just getting into the track that's currently playing and suddenly in my mind's ear i 'hear' another sound and then when i catch that sound in my head i think "where did that come from" and then i realize it's part of another track and then the more I think of it the better it will sound. |
I get that but because when I remember songs I never remember them in the right key they're rarely in the same key as the track I think they'd fit with!
I have no absolute/perfect pitch ability whatsoever although my relative pitch isn't too bad - play me a note and as far as I'm concerned it could be any note on the keyboard whatsoever, but play me another note and I can usually tell you the interval between them without any trouble at all. |
|
|
| basilisk |
| quote: | Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
um, which is why we write the key on our tracks perhaps?? "doing your research" does not equate with using ripoff software like mixed in key. my ears are cheaper and far more accurate. |
Sure, but where do you see me advocating using mixed in key? I don't think it's any good. RE2 is the way to go. The time saved in automation makes it far superior to some kind of old-fashioned system involving a notebook at a keyboard. Not only that, but there are collaborative possibilities that I suspect most people don't even consider.
I find that proper harmonic mixing necessitates having lots of options. Simply because a track seems compatible (complimentary key and close in tempo) doesn't mean it is going to blend--the production quality, energy level, style, or some other factor could cause an issue. Additionally, I play many styles of psytrance and progressive in different sets. As a result, I need a lot of tracks keyed and analyzed. Currently my database has about 10,000 tracks (incidentally, with RE2 all of this data is publicly accessible through the shared server).
RE2 is smartly designed. I use it to automatically analyze the keys of tracks that I import into the database. Questions of accuracy have always plagued harmonic mixing software. You will read, in different places, all sorts of different results. In my experience, RE2 is 80%+ accurate. Last year some friends and I ran our own tests using a variety of psytrance releases old and new. We keyed by ear and also automated the process to find out just how accurate RE2 could be. On the average 9 track album, only one would typically have been analyzed improperly. In those instances, the "key accuracy" field usually had a low rating, so even the program knew something was up. Knowing this, one can run through and manually key tracks with low accuracy counts to improve the quality of the database. In most cases where the key was analyzed wrong, the song featured one or more key changes. RE2 is only set to uncover one key at this stage in its development, but there is an option to specify an ending key as well as the starting key. In these cases, it's just a matter of busting out the internal piano and doing some verification. I do some of that anyway, simply to increase the accuracy of the information in the database. This is what I mean by smart design: the automated analysis is good to begin with, and the program also provides for manual verification and easy updating.
Years ago I used to keep notebooks and slips of paper around my decks to mark down when a mix really worked out. Now I just use the mix-out feature in RE2 to record a connection between tracks in the database. Any time I practise or get into composing a mix I end up making what feels like real progress. When I find songs that are simply made for each other, not only do I record this in my RE2 database, but (this is the cool part) anyone else with those same songs can access my notes. What we're looking at here is open source DJing--collaborative networking of information that anyone can benefit from... as far as I'm concerned, it's brilliant. Too bad it is so poorly understood. But I like the idea that all my practise sessions go on record now. Whatever information I find--whatever networks I create--that data is saved. The informational complexity of the universe increases.
So, if you want to stick with a piano and a notebook and sort things out the hard way, be my guest. As for me, I'm going to continue to explore what the future has to offer. |
|
|
| starboy |
| BAM! lol good post :) |
|
|
| pkcRAISTLIN |
| quote: | Originally posted by basilisk
So, if you want to stick with a piano and a notebook and sort things out the hard way, be my guest. As for me, I'm going to continue to explore what the future has to offer. |
10 seconds with a keyboard hardly qualifies as "the hard way" ;) plus, i mix exclusively with vinyl so importing tracks into any program is actually a whole lot harder. but, that system you have does sound pretty damn cool! |
|
|
| starboy |
| ^ sounds like its time to embrace new technology |
|
|
| pkcRAISTLIN |
| quote: | Originally posted by starboy
^ sounds like its time to embrace new technology |
lol. i have a mortgage, car repayments, a massive credit card bill. cant afford the CDJs just yet ;) plus, vinyl rocks :tongue2 |
|
|
| basilisk |
| RE2 is designed to make entries for vinyl records. You can key the tracks yourself and record an entry, or simply analyze an MP3 recording. Like I said, it's a smart piece of software :) |
|
|
| starboy |
| quote: | Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
lol. i have a mortgage, car repayments, a massive credit card bill. cant afford the CDJs just yet ;) plus, vinyl rocks :tongue2 |
i know how it is :( |
|
|
| Alex |
I think you guys crap on mixed in key way too much, for wankers like us that buy (or steal) dozens of tracks every week, its a very good tool to organize your collection with, to pre-test mixes and get yourself in the right direction!
I agree it isnt THAT accurate, but it always gives me a general idea and points me in the right direction of picking the tunes I want to play and shortens the search of finding a track that works with another, of course it all boils down to whether or not those two tracks work together, but Mixed in key is accurate enough to lay out my options for me, at which point I can go and listen to them more carefully and figure out what works BEST with what.
By no means does this program provide "flawless" harmonic mixing or anything, but it has it's uses, and they help me a lot when I'm getting to know my new tunes. |
|
|
| starboy |
| quote: | Originally posted by Alex
Mixed in key is accurate enough to lay out my options for me... |
i downloaded the free trial of mixed in key just to try it out, i uploaded about 20 songs to which i knew the keys of.. every single one of them was wrong :nervous: no joke 20 tracks... |
|
|
|
|
