|
Picard or Kirk? (pg. 2)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| ChemEnhanced |
| I will not vote until all captains are available for voting. |
|
|
| smuncky |
| quote: | Originally posted by Dr. DAS
This is how you decide who is better at commanding an interstellar vehicle? I pray you don't ever work for NASA.
Picard FTW. Patrick Stewart is a seriously talented actor, no doubt due in part to his extensive work in theatre - where there are no second takes.
Also, Kirk just leapt at the opportunity to get into fist fights and seduce women (I'm getting to the part where Picard is better) whereas Picard knew how to diffuse a situation through diplomacy, but if you picked a fight he knew how to play rough. Repeated use of the auto destruct, willful intrusions into enemy space, going face to face with the Borg on numerous occasions despite all they had done to him and his genuine belief in the best of humanity, coupled with his willingness to bend the rules to explore it.
Besides, who ever heard of the 'Kirk Manouver'?
I'm a loser.:( |
aaaaaaand kirk never had the pleasure to meet Q. Q would've easily manipulated him. Now picard on the other hand...wow. sisqo and janeway never really were the same with Q as picard and him were. |
|
|
| Dr. DAS |
| quote: | Originally posted by ChemEnhanced
I will not vote until all captains are available for voting. |
Closet Janeway fan...her character seems strangely modeled on which Captain?
Please god don't tell me you're a Sisqo fan. And surely not that 'Enterprise' garbage. |
|
|
| smuncky |
| quote: | Originally posted by Dr. DAS
Closet Janeway fan...her character seems strangely modeled on which Captain?
Please god don't tell me you're a Sisqo fan. And surely not that 'Enterprise' garbage. |
they all grew on me after watching the both series. i will however put janeway in front of sisqo though. she had more guts than sisqo. not to mention that they were the only federation star ship in the delta quadrant (besides the equinox episode) while sisqo sat in a space station which could get help at any time.
i did like DS9 for the 2nd half of the series due to the war. those star ship battle scenes were remarkable. i loved it. |
|
|
| phlog |
| quote: | Originally posted by ChemEnhanced
I will not vote until all captains are available for voting. |
I thought about adding the others, but i'm curious to see who will win been these two. |
|
|
| Dr. DAS |
| quote: | Originally posted by smuncky
they all grew on me after watching the both series. i will however put janeway in front of sisqo though. she had more guts than sisqo. not to mention that they were the only federation star ship in the delta quadrant (besides the equinox episode) while sisqo sat in a space station which could get help at any time.
i did like DS9 for the 2nd half of the series due to the war. those star ship battle scenes were remarkable. i loved it. |
Early DS9 sucked and I couldn't get into it again until the Dominion started tearing up.
"Space, the final frontier,
These are the standing perfectly stills of the former enemy space station, DS9.
It's continuing mission to explore new ways not to move, to seek out new ways of not blowing up and imploding.
To boldly sit where everybody's been and continues to go with relative safety."
Cue music... |
|
|
| Djsketchbag |
| quote: | Originally posted by phlog
|
Cam you are the biggest trekkie i know :toothless |
|
|
| Endlesswave |
| Picard for sure. Especially the "Q" episodes. |
|
|
| yankeeBaby |
| I dont know but about them, but George Takei left me an ENORMOUS tip when I waited on him last summer in Times Square.... so he is officially my favorite. |
|
|
| EvilTree |
| quote: | Originally posted by Dr. DAS
Gorn? |
fixed :toothless
| quote: | Originally posted by Dr. DAS
Closet Janeway fan...her character seems strangely modeled on which Captain? |
You're a lesbian if you like Janeway.
| quote: |
Please god don't tell me you're a Sisqo fan. |
Sisko had balls. Well, until all that Emissary crap really came along.
| quote: | | And surely not that 'Enterprise' garbage. |
Enterprise wasn't bad last 2 seasons. Up to Voyager standard. Which doesn't say much since Voyager sucks.
| quote: | Originally posted by smuncky
they all grew on me after watching the both series. i will however put janeway in front of sisqo though. she had more guts than sisqo. not to mention that they were the only federation star ship in the delta quadrant (besides the equinox episode) while sisqo sat in a space station which could get help at any time. |
Kinda unfair comparison because well, Voyager made Borg look like kittens.
| quote: |
i did like DS9 for the 2nd half of the series due to the war. those star ship battle scenes were remarkable. i loved it. |
Berman and Braga must die. Recycling footage for the series finale! :whip:
Sacrifice of Angels is one of my fav eps ever. Big massive starship fights = win |
|
|
| phlog |
| quote: | Originally posted by EvilTree
You're a lesbian if you like Janeway.
|
lol |
|
|
| jchung52 |
THE END |
|
|
|
|
