|
simple question on kick and bass eq's
|
View this Thread in Original format
| lowski |
hi guys me again with maybe another noobie question. yes at this point i should already be past this but with a new recent monitor set up and studio building ( well which is coming eventualy this week or next once i get time)
i am back at a square one. this point is a conflict with EQing my kick and sub bass
the age old quetion i guess, or at least i hope it not just me.
well let me start off saying i use vengeance uk trance kicks, pretty much exclusivley up until restenly when i got the house essentails to tone down my style a bit.
anyway i was once and maybe even more then that told that vengeance samples come processed and bassicaly ready to be put into any song. so what i have been doing is using my kick sample as a foundation point and building a song around it in hopes that it is actually true that the sample can be used with so much confidence.
so what i have had troubles with latley is eqing my kick and bass together.
my theroy from what i have read on this board (vengeance kicks being a great standard point and foundation) i have eq'ed my bass line around that, with the kick being the main focus and the sub bass being fit in to where ever it can fit.
now what i have done is usually cut the bass at a low level in freq while keeping the kick in a freq just a bit lower (kck low freq "maybe around 60 - 80- , while i have the sub bass being cut at 80- 120, hich gives the sub bass a push throw the mix but i don't think it's low enough and can lack that pumpin' sound that we all go for)
i belieave this is tech is what other people do from what i have read on this site. but my problem of concern comes from a simple fact and that is this.
when i think i have my kick and bass eq's just right with each other (and this i do on solo of the two parts)
i find tha when the sub bass comes in it shortens the kick decay.
although i have heard this happen in ather pro songs that have been realeased i'm still wondering if this is right or wrong.
to me it seems wrong, in theroy that is. i feel that the kick should have it's own space, and that is the space to ring out fully and the sub bass should also have it's own (and from what i have heard it's a higher freq of the sub bass , which essentially give the kick it's own space)
so really i'm trying to build my bass around the kick (which sometimes if not most has little to no eq on it, for the reason that i am trusting the vengeance pre procesd samples. to have already done half the work for me and give me my starting point.
oh yeah , sorry , i think another main thing i'm trying to fiure out here is if the kick sits lower in freq then the sub bass?! (this may be my main question !!!!) i can offer this beacuase evry exaple is different
i almost always have my sub bass sitting very low in the mix , to a point where it is alomst a struggle to get it to sound just as strong when the pitch changes (usually from f sharp down to d?? i think i actually don't have my key baord in front off me but i will specify later.
i have found that the sub i use kinda always sits on pair with the kick ass the root note. then and only then can i really fell ifit fits is when i change pitches throw out the song. (another part i have been having trouble with, but that is probably another thread in it's own). and yes i use me ears, f course , but some samples seems way to far pitched to fit into my song oncei hear it on better speakers.
always thanks for your help. it is greattly appreciated !!!
:toocool:
and i really hope this isn't too noob although i have n asking and learning things on this site for over a year. i have just come to the point where i just need to get this part solved so it doesn't take up any more creative time and space.
thanks again !!! |
|
|
| cenik |
Try side-chaining the two sounds (with the kick as the trigger for compressing the bass-line).
I *believe* this is one possible solution to your problem. |
|
|
| lowski |
i have tried it and done it. but yes a very good techniqe. i almost always add at least a bit of sidechain on my basslines.
mainly what i'm curios of is if it is normal for the sub bass to take up some of the kick freq, whcih results in a shortening of the kick.
i must say that i still have the kick pressing threw on the original hit , like it doesnt get drowned out in level or volume but just shorted when the sub comes in after the 32 measures, which i'm sure well all understand.
i'm just kinda confoused beacuse i have hear this in other songs and from toher producers that i look up to, but i still don't think it is quite right??? or maybe i'm wrong and it is a natural thing that happens when you add a sub bass of the same pitch with a kick.
stoneface & terminal productions is where i have heard the differance in kick to kick and sub. i love there sound but still can't get my mind over the simple freq issue. maybe i'm just trippy and spending too much time on tryin small perfections, but really that's the point i'm at. still learning what works and sounds best.
again thank you for any help an insight to this on going delema, much appreciated :) |
|
|
| Eldritch |
| quote: | Originally posted by lowski
mainly what i'm curios of is if it is normal for the sub bass to take up some of the kick freq, whcih results in a shortening of the kick. |
Yes, that is normal. As long as the kicks sub frequencies are louder than the bassline's it's okay. Sub frequencies will always be a bit messy. |
|
|
| lowski |
| quote: | Originally posted by Eldritch
Yes, that is normal. As long as the kicks sub frequencies are louder than the bassline's it's okay. Sub frequencies will always be a bit messy. |
thanks for the input. i was actually hoping to ... well this just sounds stupid (well now that i said it i will say it the best i can).
but to actually find back on on some kind of freq track that lets the kick and the bass sit as close as they can before sounding like mud, would have been perfect.
so i will make a simple question.
When eqing your kick to your bass, what usually sits lower?. |
|
|
| Eldritch |
| Kick, definately. but I suppose it depends alot on what style you're producing. |
|
|
| gr8ape |
| quote: | Originally posted by lowski
thanks for the input. i was actually hoping to ... well this just sounds stupid (well now that i said it i will say it the best i can).
but to actually find back on on some kind of freq track that lets the kick and the bass sit as close as they can before sounding like mud, would have been perfect.
so i will make a simple question.
When eqing your kick to your bass, what usually sits lower?. |
Actually I think that depends on the type of music your making...
But whatever you do, eq both, or one, so that they are compatible with the other (basically just sounds clean and good, without killing the bass in the process) |
|
|
| theartfulducker |
| quote: | | now what i have done is usually cut the bass at a low level in freq while keeping the kick in a freq just a bit lower (kck low freq "maybe around 60 - 80- , while i have the sub bass being cut at 80- 120, hich gives the sub bass a push throw the mix but i don't think it's low enough and can lack that pumpin' sound that we all go for) |
Thats some funny EQing. I dnt quite understand what your tyring to do there. Sound like your trying too hard. It shouldnt be that hard to get kick and bass sounding allright together. |
|
|
| davidbuhau |
you should just spend some time on it, a good idea is to sidechain LAST, after it already SOUNDS GOOD, this way you're just adding a little extra oomph to the bottom end...
david |
|
|
| Theran |
Seems like you're having the classic lower frequencies problem, I guess we've all been there ;)....
First of all, a little tip. Club systems usually cannot go any lower than 50Hz, so try not to go under there, actually, what I do, is put an EQ on the master and cut anything below 50Hz, that will also remove some rumble under there.
But for your lower frequency problem. As said before, sidechaining could really help your problem, and you said you already tried that but you want to know how your kick and bass can co-exist without sidechaining. First of all, you can avoid this by setting up the following pattern of kick and bass:
K---K---K---K---
--B---B---B---B-
or (like in Stoneface & Terminal - Pictures)
K---K---K---K---
-B-B--B--B-B--B-
In this way, the kick and bass won't clatch, that is ofcourse if the release on you subbass isn't to long.
The other thing is to use a spectral analyser to see which frequencies are used by the kick and bass, and just cut those with your EQ.
BTW: It's true that the vengeance samples have been processed so you should be able to use them directly in you track. However, I've never found a kicksample from Vengeance that I could use directly in one of my tracks, I always process them myself. |
|
|
| theartfulducker |
| quote: | | First of all, a little tip. Club systems usually cannot go any lower than 50Hz, so try not to go under there, actually, what I do, is put an EQ on the master and cut anything below 50Hz, that will also remove some rumble under there. |
I dnt think that correct at all. |
|
|
| Theran |
| quote: | Originally posted by theartfulducker
I dnt think that correct at all. |
And yet, very true....Link |
|
|
|
|
