|
Giving me a headache , just might call it that.
|
View this Thread in Original format
| adi_hanson |
I have been working on this few a few days now and ive sorta come to a bit of a wall.
My personal gripes are
1.The transition at 2.19 im totally unsure about.
2.Not sure at all about the piano bit
3.Some effects do have to much low end , i know that one.
So i just thought id throw it up here for you guys to see if you could give us any ideas?
[[ LINK REMOVED ]]
feedback would be much appreciated |
|
|
| Sinnica Hax |
Exhale, immediatly thought of the old Ferry tune. Let's see..
I'm a sucker for ambience in a song, so i like your introduction, also liked what you did to the FX that goes along with the kick. Sounds like the typical full-on trance track to me (nothing bad about that, eventhough its not my bag). Personally I'd like to have a more euphoric feeling to the melody that comes in 2:19, it feels a little low on freq, but maybe thats just me. considering the buildup I expected something really energic. That's about it I think, a little more variation on the piano perhaps, eventhough you've made small changes to it occationally.
I never write reviews here and that's for a good reason, I suck at it. But that was my two cents anyway.
Regards, Fredrik |
|
|
| adi_hanson |
cheers for the post , and yes this was going to be a take on exhale , but i was pleased with the intro and decided to make it my own:D
but thanks for the feedback anyways. |
|
|
| adi_hanson |
| no other takers? |
|
|
| Wilko |
Just had a listen, will relay my comments. Please bare in mind, some of these comments will be personal taste.
I'm not a great fan of the kick, felt it needed a bit more low-end to sit more with the bassline. I'll use an example, because that always helps me get a better understand of what people mean. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfWleCXK5Wk Is what stuck in my mind when I was listening to your track.
Not a fan of the closed hi-hat that's introduced at 26secs that sits on the 1st and 5th, doesn't sit well for me.
As Fredrik pointed out, like the ambience also and the neat little flicks, it fills it out nicely and keeps your ear.
Bassline sounds slightly old-style Tiesto esque. Could do with a little more groove / complexity, but that's purely my opinion. Maybe some cheeky twitches on it, during bar ends to add some human element to it.
Percussion sits well, not too much, but possibly too little. Could do with some more elements to fill the hi frequencies a bit more. Again, purely personal taste on that one.
As you highlighted, the transition at 2:19 seems a bit quick and rushed, to be honest. I think the main aim is to build it slightly, but obviously not too much and then drop it right down, in view of building it back up again. It kinda sits on the same level and doesn't build as such.
Love the main synth that comes in, however I don't like the key. It has an old skool type feel to it and instantly grabbed me. It tries to come across as melodic though, which I didn't feel was right for the sound.
Brutal, but honest; Scrap the Piano, it ruins the tone in my view.
Perhaps some Breakbeat or heavy sub-bass drum flicks during the build, to add some depth to the building sound.
I hope this helps. :) |
|
|
| adi_hanson |
Great post , you have pretty much detailed some things i dont like about this , but i feel it needs continuing and finishing, and your comments will help greatly ,
cheers |
|
|
|
|
