|
William_Orbit_-_Barbers_Adagio_For_Strings_(Gil_Shwartz_Mix)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Gil Shwarts |
Hi again, i've been working on this tune for a while...
I this its a great tune to open up a Club Trance set...
very uplifting and energetic...
the concept was alittle diffrent but then again, what r remixes if not for a concept diffrance? :)
William_Orbit_-_Barbers_Adagio_For_Strings_(Gil_Shwartz_Mix).mp3
enjoy |
|
|
| dJohn |
Sounds good and well produced, but you killed the song.
This song(and the amazing FC remix) relies HEAVILY on the effects of the strings in the backround, as it's melody backbone. Youll notice certain(if not all) melodic tracks have usually a lead, synths, and bassline...what made the FC remix so amazing was the way his signature synths expanded the melody by hundredfolds, and his signature bassline kept the rhythm energetic. And you'll notice the main melody doesn't come the hook, but rather in the back.
The point I'm trying to make here is that your remix lacks what gives this track it's meat & potatoes: it has a synth, and lead, but it doesn't have a melody in the backround to play off of...to tell you the truth, compared to the other remixes, yours is very dull and repetitive, almost like trying to convert this epic original into a techish type of track. Don't be offended...it sounds really good and clean, but you need to integrate to the most important part of the song, and unfortatly with this remix, you failed to do that.
Look forward to hearing your work in the future! |
|
|
| Gil Shwarts |
wow, hehehe, thanks for the comment dude...
and yeah, i recall FC's remix... but you can't compare me to FC dude :)
thanks for the compliment tho :D
Anyways, your point is well taken, and no i didn't get offended, its exactly the other way around...
you now told me that i've succseeded turning the concept to a diffrent direction - clubby direction, and for that, I thank you :)
In my country, if i'll play the FX mix.. people will sleep on the floor, but if i'll play mine, people will be hanging off the seeling :)
Again, thanks alot for your comment, it is highly appriciated!
Oh and as for my future stuff... this remix was the last one in a series of tune bombing...
next tunes of mine will be longer and more 'invested'... no more remixes for the time being :) |
|
|
| GrimReaper |
| Thanks for yet another remix Gil! |
|
|
| DJ_Ampz |
having a listen. as usual, you always seem to do these up within like 10 min. lol. well done
Ampz |
|
|
| McBigMac |
Id say most of what john said, but to make it different is tough task.
And you did try alright, however i will have to smack if you dont get another lead sample, it sounds horribly stupid and that particular sample is WAY overused in the amatuer community, atleast alone.
But the whole track sorry to say, sounds like a bad remake of the fc remix....
Its one rule not to mess with classics, they wont get better!
Especielly this one, since it has one of the most beautiful melodies ever!
Nice try to, gil, keep it up ;)
cheers, |
|
|
| Gil Shwarts |
i've been waiting for a "flame", and i don't blame u dude, i knew i'm gonna get flamed for it and i don't know why i kept going with it :)
ah well, it IS a classic that no one can get any better! |
|
|
| Endre |
take a rest dude, you produce too much. every time i check this section i see your stuff floating around, take a nap, vacation, play comp games, rest your mind man :) good stuff btw.
|
|
|
| Flotser |
I actually dont like the FC remix,
so i won't say that you killed the song.
it is hard ....
i dont like this very metalic synth you use until 2:11 though
but after 2:11, the sound it so cool, and fits great in the atmosphere of the track, !
overall, (espcially seocnd part)
very good in my opinion!!!
:wtf: |
|
|
| DaveC |
Sorry gil....
i have to say... i hate it! lol :(
|
|
|
| Robert |
| yeah.. im sorry to say but this is not good... |
|
|
| Gil Shwarts |
each one and his own taste (thank god for that) hehehe
no worries dude, personally... i hate it too :)
(but keep it as a secret)
rofl
thanks for your time though! |
|
|
|
|
