|
Uplifting trance is dead (pg. 5)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Sand Leaper |
| quote: | Originally posted by SuperFarStucker
It's a sign when people ITK consider "above and beyond", MIKE, Paul Van Dyk and "rank 1" as the "premiere artists" of an ENTIRE genre of music that it has probably gone to hell. When these artists aren't too busy making songs that abuse the already tired whore of "epic trance" (which a large many seem to thing is synonymous with "trance", I'm afraid I find it to be poorly representative), they are busy trying to come off as serious or whatnot while simultaneously producing total that is insulting to your intelligence. What I consider music doesn't come with a , it doesn't come pre-packaged into some nice little container format that is fit to abuse ad nauseum. |
Well, let's play this game like you just did with another genre, like prog. I could say about the exact same thing as you did here about trance. Everywhere I go on TA I see people praising Luke Chable, Özgur Can and Markus Schulz, even though half the productions they and all the mindless copycats churn out these days are boring effect wankery that goes absolutely nowhere and with barely enuff ideas to keep a track interesting for half of the track's duration. This shows that prog is well down the path of stagnation just like trance is with its overused supersaw blare. The fact that the fanbase of the genre have a large ratio of pathetic elitist attitudes makes it even worse. Judging this way, prog is just as "dead" as trance.
However, if people stopped judging either genre on all the artists the massive hype is directed at, one would find more than enuff material that suggests that there's plenty of talent and creativity present. |
|
|
| SuperFarStucker |
| quote: | Originally posted by Sand Leaper
Well, let's play this game like you just did with another genre, like prog. I could say about the exact same thing as you did here about trance. Everywhere I go on TA I see people praising Luke Chable, Özgur Can and Markus Schulz, even though half the productions they and all the mindless copycats churn out these days are boring effect wankery that goes absolutely nowhere and with barely enuff ideas to keep a track interesting for half of the track's duration. This shows that prog is well down the path of stagnation just like trance is with its overused supersaw blare. The fact that the fanbase of the genre have a large ratio of pathetic elitist attitudes makes it even worse. Judging this way, prog is just as "dead" as trance.
However, if people stopped judging either genre on all the artists the massive hype is directed at, one would find more than enuff material that suggests that there's plenty of talent and creativity present. |
I agree |
|
|
| starstarman |
| If it wasn't called "progressive", no one would ever care |
|
|
| Ste |
| quote: | Originally posted by Radagast
'Prog heads' think of you the same way you think of people who listen to Britney Spears. |
thats because theyre usually pretentious know it alls who think they are the high priests of electronica because they listen to slowed down trance |
|
|
| Ste |
| quote: | Originally posted by Sand Leaper
Well, let's play this game like you just did with another genre, like prog. I could say about the exact same thing as you did here about trance. Everywhere I go on TA I see people praising Luke Chable, Özgur Can and Markus Schulz, even though half the productions they and all the mindless copycats churn out these days are boring effect wankery that goes absolutely nowhere and with barely enuff ideas to keep a track interesting for half of the track's duration. This shows that prog is well down the path of stagnation just like trance is with its overused supersaw blare. The fact that the fanbase of the genre have a large ratio of pathetic elitist attitudes makes it even worse. Judging this way, prog is just as "dead" as trance.
However, if people stopped judging either genre on all the artists the massive hype is directed at, one would find more than enuff material that suggests that there's plenty of talent and creativity present. |
jan is the man |
|
|
| Trancejedi |
| quote: | Originally posted by roosh
Time to accept it and move on. Accept change and stop living in the past. Embrace the revolution of progressive house. |
Its dead?? What were my ears thinkin?? I'll go listen to something else than. Thanx for the heads up. :rolleyes: |
|
|
| The Don |
| quote: | Originally posted by roosh
Time to accept it and move on. Accept change and stop living in the past. Embrace the revolution of progressive house. |
Do you know the funniest thing about this post.. Progressive Music by far more the been and gone sound.. So shut up... |
|
|
| Cobalt |
| quote: | Originally posted by SuperFarStucker
It's a sign when people ITK consider "above and beyond", MIKE, Paul Van Dyk and "rank 1" as the "premiere artists" of an ENTIRE genre of music that it has probably gone to hell. When these artists aren't too busy making songs that abuse the already tired whore of "epic trance" (which a large many seem to thing is synonymous with "trance", I'm afraid I find it to be poorly representative), they are busy trying to come off as serious or whatnot while simultaneously producing total that is insulting to your intelligence. What I consider music doesn't come with a , it doesn't come pre-packaged into some nice little container format that is fit to abuse ad nauseum. |
So true. |
|
|
| Cobalt |
| I think a really important point to stress is that the death of uplifting trance doesn't mean the death of trance. Not at all. There are good and innovative new paths trance is currently taking, but they aren't uplifting trance. Sorry folks, but the ASoT crap is merely getting the last bits of cash out of the 1999 formula. |
|
|
| totev |
| quote: | Originally posted by Cobalt
I think a really important point to stress is that the death of uplifting trance doesn't mean the death of trance. Not at all. There are good and innovative new paths trance is currently taking, but they aren't uplifting trance. Sorry folks, but the ASoT crap is merely getting the last bits of cash out of the 1999 formula. |
exactly, and that is completely normal IMO b/c there is only so much you can do with a specific 'success' formula. the problem i think is the definition of genres: 'trance' as we know it from 1999 has been naturally depleted over several years, but trance as of now is in good shape. the sort of branching out and merging of genres we see now makes the EDM scene more eclectic and more interesting than ever before.
there are no set boundaries for genres, so you may call markus schulz 'slowed down trance' or 'prog house', why should you care really. nobody can give a specific definition of a genre, and usually productions that cross or stretch the boundaries of genres sound the best b/c they are original and dont use the set 'classic' formula of a specific genre |
|
|
| PETRAN |
Where are all these tranceaddicts arguing about urban train(aaahh brings memories flooding back)have gone now??? Are they out of trance now? What happened to all of these people??? Anyway , i think that present time is quite bad for any music genre so nothing very special at the moment. Although, its quite true that trance is steadily declining if you look at the 2001 thread there were still a few good epic memorable tunes back then(urban train!!!!epic monolith!!!!) NOT A SINGLE ONE NOW THAT WILL SURVIVE THE TEST OF TIME and yes the ASOT is really crap!!! In my opinion The only thing that still keeps it to life is that tried and tested cool formula.(you know with the big breakdown in the middle..)and young people that get into it NOW and werent back then.
Progressive house on the other hand its surely not the new revolution, although there are quite a few good tunes and producers that make astonishing works (Yunus Guvenen!!!James Holden!!!Subsky!!!Alexander Church!!!Gwill Morris!!!Hybrid!!!) so overall in my opinion there are better tunes from the progressive side of things right now.
E.g 1: Forget kilimanjaro and dig reflections/touched from firewall on activate(2001 think). If you like kilimanjaro than these will give you goosebumbs!!
E.g 2: I ve just re-discovered my love for a tune airwave-lightspeed!!!woww what a great tune that was! I hear that subsphere produces in the same style... |
|
|
| kr00t0n |
Hmmm.. and here I was rating 2003 as one of the best years for trance I've had the pleasure of experiencing, possibly my fav, as it kept me really interested, whilst 99 had the whole 'omg, all this is new n different' feel as I had only just found trance...
Last year was a corker, too many tunes for me to list.
5 years on and i aint sick of it yet, guess when you love something you really love it :D |
|
|
|
|
