|
You'll never walk alone - who sings it better
|
View this Thread in Original format
| chesco |
liverpool or celtic
after the barcelona game last night i swear i've never heard anything so beautiful in all my life, 62,000 hoops and barca fans joining in for what was the best rendition of the best song ever made.
celtic sing it far far better than their scally rivals. |
|
|
| PacMan |
| erhm this isnt even discusable its liverpool, and for fun you could add germanys national side to the list. as they will be singing it in euro2006 |
|
|
| evil_bastard |
| Sounds dull whoever sings it to be honest, much rather hear the Blaydon Races. Both grounds are full of Irish people anyway, so it should sound the same ;) |
|
|
| Xavier |
hmmm Celtic sing it better for the short time being. The whole stadium is bothered to raise their scarves unlike Anfield.
check out the 1974 FA cup final, You'll Never Walk Alone sung immaculately, nice slow,, softly the way its suppose to be sung.
The song that the world knows as the Liverpool song sums up so much for the club and supporters alike. It captures the importance of unity crucial to everything achieved by the club, and it remains a source of comfort to those affected by the tragic events (Heysel & Hillsborough) that have hit the club.
Why do fans of dutch clubs & other clubs sing it? It got no real meaning for them and to them it seems like a normal song. |
|
|
| evil_bastard |
| quote: | Originally posted by Xavier
it remains a source of comfort to those affected by the tragic events (Heysel & Hillsborough) that have hit the club. |
Why would Liverpool fans need comforting about Heysel?
Wasn't You'll Never Walk Alone once a pop song as well? |
|
|
| Xavier |
| quote: | Originally posted by evil_bastard
Why would Liverpool fans need comforting about Heysel? |
Those who were there on that day, saw 39 people killed. Those who were retaliated were guilty (a miniority), those who were not involved watched in horror. Of course it would be a day that Liverpool FC would rather forget. Like Hillsborough it was another dark day for the Club and its supporters.
| quote: | Originally posted by evil_bastard
Wasn't You'll Never Walk Alone once a pop song? |
Yes it was, though before it became that popular, it was written for the musical "Carousel."
| quote: | "You'll Never Walk Alone" (music by Richard Rodgers, lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II) was written for the 1945 Broadway musical play Carousel. The song highlights a momentous plot turn early in Act II, and is reprised as the musical's powerful and inspirational finale.
From the very beginning, this song has always had a special resonance and meaning beyond its context and function within the score for Carousel. During the musical's original Broadway run, with the world at war, many in the audiences who had a husband, a brother, a son or a lover fighting overseas, found solace in its meaning and its message.
In addition to numerous recordings of the song on Carousel cast albums and the motion picture soundtrack, "You'll Never Walk Alone" has been recorded by dozens of pop, rock, gospel, country western, and opera stars, including: Louis Armstrong, Chet Atkins, Shirley Bassey, Glen Campbell, Ray Charles, Perry Como, Michael Crawford, Placido Domingo, Aretha Franklin, Judy Garland, Gerry and the Pacemakers, Marilyn Horne, Mahalia Jackson, Patti LaBelle, Cleo Laine, Mario Lanza, Darlene Love, Jim Nabors, Olivia Newton John, Pink Floyd, Elvis Presley, The Righteous Brothers, Nina Simone, Frank Sinatra, Kiri Te Kanawa, Conway Twitty and Dionne Warwick.
"You'll Never Walk Alone" has a unique history in Great Britain where it was adopted as an anthem of the Liverpool Football Club and has, over the decades become a standard at virtually every British soccer stadium. True to the song's intent, it has also provided inspiration in times of peril, and has served as a potent fundraiser for causes borne out of disaster. In 1985, for instance, a recording of "You'll Never Walk Alone" featuring British pop and rock stars, was put together to raise funds for victims of the Bradford Stadium Tragedy and did; the song was a Number One single in Britain throughout the summer of 1985, and raised hundreds of thousand of pounds for the cause.
In the United States in recent years, "You'll Never Walk Alone" long associated with Jerry Lewis' Labor Day Muscular Dystrophy telethons, has also been adopted by such causes as Hurricane Andrew relief and the annual national AIDS Walk campaigns. Marilyn Horne, Joan Baez and others have sung You'll Never Walk Alone at AIDS Walk rallies in New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Philadelphia and Chicago, and in 1992 Patti LaBelle made a new recording of the song for a national AIDS Walk public service announcement. Bringing the song full circle, at the 1994 AIDS Walk New York, Shirley Verrett and the cast of the Broadway production of Carousle sang "You'll Never Walk Alone" on the Great Lawn in Central Park before a crowd of 30,000. |
You'll Never Walk alone is a song about going through the bad times to the good times in life and recovering from whether it is tradegy or loss, not to mention the happier times such as triumph.
You'll Never Walk Alone is not just another football song or an old pop song to some.
After Hillsborough "You'll Never Walk Alone" had more meaning than ever to Liverpool fans. Why would a club have a "pop" song on their crest? Answer: because it has lots of meaning.
I hope I answered your question thoroughly. |
|
|
| chesco |
last nights rendition of you'll never walk alone from the celtic fans actually had me in tears..
It was just like one big choir singing in perfect harmony...
the love i have for celtic has no bounds..:D |
|
|
| SPANIARD |
| The thing we are missing here is the best tifosi groups in the world don't sing it, since they have their own anthems. Imagine OM, Boca, Roma, Hajduk, Atletico, Fener, Panathiniakos singing this song... |
|
|
| chesco |
| quote: | Originally posted by SPANIARD
The thing we are missing here is the best tifosi groups in the world don't sing it, since they have their own anthems. Imagine OM, Boca, Roma, Hajduk, Atletico, Fener, Panathiniakos singing this song... |
but i don't want to know about any of these teams.. the point of the thread is to findout who sings you'll never walk alone better..:rolleyes: |
|
|
| chesco |
i rest my case
mms://play950.servecast.com/celtic/mail/ynwa.wmv
copy and past and listen to the best rendition of ever...
skip to 2.00 mins then the fans take over from the record.. |
|
|
| PacMan |
| how about we say both the fans togheter is the best ever performance of it ;) |
|
|
| Martin McG |
| ive heard it a few times from both sets of fans including at parkhead and anfield and when its done together its just quality |
|
|
|
|
