|
Underwater - The Deep Field (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| tylerc |
| quote: | | Originally posted by retiro You criticize others yet I haven't seen anything on this forum (production wise) from you! Unless you can do any better I suggest not being so harsh with your critics! |
This is just rediculous to say. With this logic I'm not free to criticize the president because I'm not a better president......
Anyway, on to the tune. Sounds good man. Its very obvious that this was made in reason. I personally don't like the clap, its a little too grainy for me. I also really dont like that bass drop sample you're using, it just sounds kinda akward.
Otherwise your sounds are very nice, good melodies. Keep it up. |
|
|
| Dj_Underwater |
Oh cmon gyus stop argue please :) Thanx for all comments ,you really helped me :)
Oh and im not producing in reason but in RENOISE :D:D |
|
|
| DJ_Silverstone1 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Dj_Underwater
Oh cmon gyus stop argue please :) |
think i owe u a aplogie mate .. sorry :S
its a definatly a nice track its just one of those tracks which i will listen to amongst others |
|
|
| thoughtlessjex |
Sorry, Underwater, I just had to say this.
| quote: | | Some ppl can't take critics very well therefore will think 'why should I bother?' then no ppl will post tracks! |
Frankly, these people don't deserve to post tracks here. People post their tracks so that they can improve, if not on the track they posted, then on their next track, not to be showered with empty compliments. If someone wasn't expecting to be told they were doing something wrong, and refuses to take advice on it, then they don't deserve that advice, thus they don't deserve to post here. |
|
|
| retiro |
| Wow awesome comment! Lets finish this disagreement because its been thrown out of all proportion! |
|
|
| dbl |
| quote: | Originally posted by retiro
Come on man this is not what I mean! Some ppl can't take critics very well therefore will think 'why should I bother?' then no ppl will post tracks! I thought you were a bit heavy handed when dishing out comments - you did it on a another tune the same day! Remember we are not Above & Beyond or AvB but aspiring producers who want to make it in trance, although we appreciate critics some ppl take it to heart and will give up for it! I respect that you comment on tunes but my advice is use your forum name when commenting and be subtle rather than abrazive! No hard feelings just like yourself expressing an opinion! |
it's hell of alot better to get "negative" comments on a track then just a "damn good track.. it rock's"..
if you only get comments like that and if noone is saying what they really think.. you wount get any better... and you will never come to where A&B or AvB is...
so i think subtles comments where just fine...
and if you can't take the comments... don't post a track.. it's pretty simple...
but to the track.. i think it sounds really nice.. sounds kinda lofi thou even for being in 160kbit...,
wount comment on anything more now thou.. to tired so i don't really trust my ears right now.. hehe :) |
|
|
| Dj_Underwater |
| Hahaha,ok so i'll wait :),and still dunno why it sounds lofi :( |
|
|
| JohnOC |
| beautiful track, main melody sounds really nice. looking forward to final version :) |
|
|
| Timothy |
Again a very good track from you! :) You are one of my favorit producers on this board m8 ;)
The sound quality isn't bad by the way. It's really well produced imho. |
|
|
| EtherealSL |
wow... this track sounds very very pro to my ears
i'm sure mastering will be worked on but the layering of melodies and synths sounds great to me...
a slower bpm and i could definately picture myself chilling at cafe del mar or mambo to this.. has a very "sunset" feel to you, y'know? I hope you understand what i meant
It's fine that there's no big lead and things like that, it's more chillout, the track you play in between huge epic songs to relax you a little, i think it's perfect for that purpose.
I dunno why ppl are hating on ASOT and Anjunabeats... i love that stuff, it seems like a lot of people are not liking the things released by those labels, yea it's epic and mellodic, but can't that be a GOOD thing??
Constructive critism is awesome, but unfortunately that's outta my range for this track, i just wanted to say that an epic lead isn't necessary for this production, i hope this comment helped |
|
|
| d-miurge |
| I love this track, excellent work, the melody is nice, the percs are well too (the clap is top notch :crazy: ), keep it up mate !! ;) |
|
|
| Dj_Underwater |
| Thanks for comments :D |
|
|
|
|
