|
RD - I Hate Computers [with DD] (pg. 3)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Benjamin B |
I <3 PC... macs :whip:
Overpriced, underpowered and not much versatility with software. They are cute and fun to play with ... and G5s are cool. The only substantive reason to buy a mac for music is for Logic, since it's the bee's knees when it comes to production. But then again, anyone worth their salt could produce well on any other platform.
Different strokes, as they say. I'll just take a dual core, dual-64 bit processor PC and run both Windows 64 (or the new OS) as well as Mac OS and be set for life :tongue2 |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by Blake_Jarrell
it's really not this big mac vs pc debate that you are now turning this into. i was just telling the guy that he shouldnt jump on the mac bandwagon because ableton hiccuped since macs are certainly not free of problems. i then posted what i think are great examples of why i think that my argument holds water:
A) apparats mac crashed twice and smartbar the other night
B) protools 7 on G5 macs in my class crash all the time.
and those were just two off the top of my head. i could have gotten way more elaborate with it.
thats just dandy that you wouldnt go back, most people are usually overprotective of their investments. Updated XP machines are fine too, especially if you run a little antivirus now and then and dont go ing with the registry like i do all the time and burn myself.
those G5s are cleaned daily and kept up pretty well from what i see. not to mention they are used ONLY for music production. i open 4 wave files in protools at once, poof crash. wtf is that all about?
you dont see a strong argument from me because im really not trying to have a mac vs pc debate. they both capable of having signifigant problems that are undeniable, ESPECIALLY WHEN DEALING WITH AUDIO SOFTWARE AND VST BASED . with that being said, and like i said twice earlier, i just warned the guy to shy away from the elitist mac bull bandwagon, and not to jump on it purely because ableton crashed on him, thats all.
on a lighter note, check this out:
http://jeremy.zawodny.com/media/bitch.mpg |
I wasn't trying to turn it into a Mac v. PC debate in the least, simply stating my opinion in opposition to yours. That's terrific that "Apparat" had his Mac crash twice, I don't know how he has it setup, or how much BS he's installed on his computer to make it run worse. Beyond that, what are the specs of your G5 macs in class? I guess I just see you referencing very specific situations that clearly do not apply across the board. I simply stated "to each their own" and provided my opinion on a subject that I felt you addressed with overly simplistic and situation specific arguments as opposed to anything concrete. I also never called you "wrong" or attempted to instigate you into defending your position, I understand that there are plenty of producers and "DJ's" out there using both Windows and Mac OS based PC's and that each will have their own preference. Unfortunately, as I said, you simply referenced, at the very least, incomplete, if not entirely inaccurate, information regarding the Mac vs. PC debate.
People are often quick to say that Mac users are bandwagon elitists, but I seem to find it often the case that the people who argue most vehemently "bash" the other side are PC users who seem to have this preconceived notion that all of "us" Mac users think all of "you" PC users are somehow lacking in refinement or credibility as they haven't made the appropriate leap to the "better" machine. This clearly is not the case with me or my response to you.
In the same sense that you are offering the possibility that you weren't attempting to start a "mac vs. pc" debate, then you should respect the fact that neither was I. Your initial statement was hardly objective, and I felt it deserved a courteously stated counterpoint, your decision to address that was your own. I respect your opinion and know that you've done plenty as a producer, including what I think is possibly the greatest progressive track ever created. That, however, doesn't change the fact that I felt your initial post deserved at the very least a counterargument from someone on the other side of the fence.
Whether or not you wish to turn it into a debate is up to you, but for now, all I'm saying is the following:
Pro Tools runs, no problem whatsoever, on my PowerMac G4 SE, and on my iBook G4. Ableton runs fine with up to 3 VSTI's open at once, however I will admit that beyond that is pushing it and will likely make whatever program you're running crash.
My opinion of Macs is based solely on my experience, and so is yours. So debate or not, we've both offered our opinions and those considering their options are at the very least, not being bombarded with information that is displaying a single clear bias, but rather two very different points on a singular issue.
Cheers.
Edit:
| quote: | Originally posted by Blake_Jarrell
top of the line mac book pro with all bells and whistles is $3700
same exact specs on a dell are about $1600 last i checked. |
And again, Apples & Oranges. |
|
|
| Benjamin B |
| LOL @ you , RJT. |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by Benjamin B
LOL @ you , RJT. |
Heh... just trying to offer "Fair & Balanced" information in honor of my hero:
:rolleyes:
Plus, TA keeps me "Oh I need to type something long-winded for class and only have 5 minutes" skills sharp... ;) |
|
|
| jonze234 |
| psshh, you're all n00bs. commodore 64 ftw |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by jonze234
psshh, you're all n00bs. commodore 64 ftw |
Pfffft.... My REAL setup:
 |
|
|
| jonze234 |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
Pfffft.... My REAL setup:
|
for the on-the-go-dj |
|
|
| born2trance |
| quote: | Originally posted by SENECA
bitchin' tracklist mate...!
what kind of comp did you get?
ps - appple owns jooo 1:) |
if u got a few grand saved up, HHAHA |
|
|
| Blake_Jarrell |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
I wasn't trying to turn it into a Mac v. PC debate in the least, simply stating my opinion in opposition to yours. That's terrific that "Apparat" had his Mac crash twice, I don't know how he has it setup, or how much BS he's installed on his computer to make it run worse. Beyond that, what are the specs of your G5 macs in class? I guess I just see you referencing very specific situations that clearly do not apply across the board. I simply stated "to each their own" and provided my opinion on a subject that I felt you addressed with overly simplistic and situation specific arguments as opposed to anything concrete. I also never called you "wrong" or attempted to instigate you into defending your position, I understand that there are plenty of producers and "DJ's" out there using both Windows and Mac OS based PC's and that each will have their own preference. Unfortunately, as I said, you simply referenced, at the very least, incomplete, if not entirely inaccurate, information regarding the Mac vs. PC debate.
People are often quick to say that Mac users are bandwagon elitists, but I seem to find it often the case that the people who argue most vehemently "bash" the other side are PC users who seem to have this preconceived notion that all of "us" Mac users think all of "you" PC users are somehow lacking in refinement or credibility as they haven't made the appropriate leap to the "better" machine. This clearly is not the case with me or my response to you.
In the same sense that you are offering the possibility that you weren't attempting to start a "mac vs. pc" debate, then you should respect the fact that neither was I. Your initial statement was hardly objective, and I felt it deserved a courteously stated counterpoint, your decision to address that was your own. I respect your opinion and know that you've done plenty as a producer, including what I think is possibly the greatest progressive track ever created. That, however, doesn't change the fact that I felt your initial post deserved at the very least a counterargument from someone on the other side of the fence.
Whether or not you wish to turn it into a debate is up to you, but for now, all I'm saying is the following:
Pro Tools runs, no problem whatsoever, on my PowerMac G4 SE, and on my iBook G4. Ableton runs fine with up to 3 VSTI's open at once, however I will admit that beyond that is pushing it and will likely make whatever program you're running crash.
My opinion of Macs is based solely on my experience, and so is yours. So debate or not, we've both offered our opinions and those considering their options are at the very least, not being bombarded with information that is displaying a single clear bias, but rather two very different points on a singular issue.
Cheers. |
word up
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
And again, Apples & Oranges. |
a $2100 difference makes it a highly overpriced orange for the same processor, hd size and speed, etc, so on, amen. you can try to justify that difference with the OS and omg look how CUTE my mac is stuff, but its just not my thing. |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by Blake_Jarrell
its just not my thing. |
And that's all that matters man! :)
** cue Diff'rent Strokes Theme**
:toothless |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| PS: Thumpie still rules! |
|
|
| wolverine16 |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
|
Boo to O'Reilly! At least "no" is crossed out :)
My favorite Franken line about him is "Bill says he stands for traditional values, but harassing your female producer for phone sex isn't a traditional value...telegraph sex maybe. Beep beep beep, yeah baby"
Anyway back to the comp wars.
P.S. Still love the the tracklist Bobby |
|
|
|
|
