Originally posted by Kismet7
everything is ok...if you feel its ok.
do whatever you want. dont let my ideals or philosophy supress what you feel is right.
There is no noun in your question. But to answer your vague question,
a mix format is easier to have a critical opinion on, than a album or EP. In a mix there is less artistic context to deconstruct, and less fully controlled artistic expression to digest...in comparison to an album. The work is shared between the DJ and the Producers/Artists. Agreed? Which makes a mix more of technical excercise than something like an album which more of an artistic excercise. A proper review of an album requires the ability of the listener to abstract the context. With a mix you really dont have to, you either enjoy the journey or you dont. And there is usually little left by the DJ, to deconstruct by the listener, again in comparison to an Album or EP. This makes being critical of a mix reasonably easier.
Criticism is fine if it balances a discussion, and a balanced discussion is always useful, because it leads to better understanding. Constructive criticism is also good if it points out a reoccuring problem or pattern in a system.
quote:
If he dont, its pretty much a gimme that Producers who turn into DJs suck phallic at selecting.
Hella constructive'.
And you are right, everything is ok if you feel it is, which is why your explanations on what is acceptable to criticize, think about, or dislike don't mean jack . Just wanted to point that out.
chiprognut
I'm really enjoying this comp, and just getting thru disc 1....can't wait to see what disc 2 has in store.:D
Kismet7
quote:
Originally posted by Clovis
Hella constructive'.
And you are right, everything is ok if you feel it is, which is why your explanations on what is acceptable to criticize, think about, or dislike don't mean jack . Just wanted to point that out.
I dont even get what you are griping about.
What I said is not purely criticism, is it? Its an observation based on plenty of examples. I mean are you saying the last 5-6 major mix CD's that have been put out have been any good? Maybe if you smoke or drop some , maybe they would be more enjoyable, but in that case almost anything is enjoyable.
Most of them have been forgettable for me, and there are many reasons for that. Those reasons being, they've been mixed by DJs who might not done the time, have not developed their selecting skills, have not actually used a wide range of music to license. The Mix CD format has turned into buddy stroking festival. How is this criticism? Its an observation, with plenty of evidence to back it. At least find some criticism lol. And why are you hung up on the whole criticism thing anyway?
And if it makes you happy that my explanations dont mean jack , well I guess they dont mean jack lol.
Protege
I actually really like this comp. One of my favs in recent months. Maybe its cause lately Ive been let down by mix cds and my expectations were lowered, but this is the best one Ive listened to for some time.
Kismet7
quote:
Originally posted by Protege
I actually really like this comp. One of my favs in recent months. Maybe its cause lately Ive been let down by mix cds and my expectations were lowered, but this is the best one Ive listened to for some time.
Wronggg (gong sound). Clovis obviously believes mix CDS lately have been AWESOME. Producers turned DJs are AWESOME. My observation backed by examples and good context is so off, and purely criticism. :stongue:
Schadenfreude
if you cry any harder you will ruin your makeup.
woscar
Kismet, are you really that stupid that you don't see where Clovis' thoughts are coming from?
Kismet7
quote:
Originally posted by woscar
Kismet, are you really that stupid that you don't see where Clovis' thoughts are coming from?
are you a really that much of a drama queen hooker that you jump into every discussion between two people? find a corner, piss in it, and sit there.
or go back to cheerleading. i really dont care for your input.
Schadenfreude
Kismet7
^ another drama queen that really has nothing better to do with herself. are you trying force the idea that someone is crying on a forum? what are you 12?
Schadenfreude
SYSTEM-J
The reason Kismet is fine with criticising DJs but not producers is obvious: he's a producer, but he can't DJ.
