|
is In My Memory - Tiesto the perfect trance album????
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Drancge |
is In My Memory - Tiesto the perfect trance album????
every track has its own identity and story literally perfect
what do u say |
|
|
| Sykonee |
| Muzik Magazine scored it 2/5, so I'd have to say no. |
|
|
| Drancge |
| quote: | Originally posted by Sykonee
Muzik Magazine scored it 2/5, so I'd have to say no. |
thanks for reply but i don't believe in critics
as for me its just the perfect trance playlist |
|
|
| Drancge |
t | quote: | Originally posted by Sykonee
Muzik Magazine scored it 2/5, so I'd have to say no. |
any reason why it sucks |
|
|
| Paradox Lost |
| It's fine, and I actually appreciate it more than I do most trance LP's, as it tries to hit multiple notes and go in different directions. But the album felt like it depreciated within a year of its release, and certainly didn't age well throughout the remainder of the decade. |
|
|
| rubez |
pvd's seven ways wants a word.
in my memory is far from perfect. |
|
|
| 2techs |
| quote: | Originally posted by Sykonee
Muzik Magazine scored it 2/5, so I'd have to say no. |
2/5?
let's go down the tracklist:
Magik Journey = classic Geert Huinink track.
Close To You = nice downtempo track albeit cheesy.
Dallas 4PM = awesome sample from a 2000 track; can't remember the name.
In My Memory = not really a fan. Airwave's remix is one my all-time favorite remixes though.
Obsession = another big draw from Tiesto's catalogue
Battleship Grey = cut from the same mold as the other cheesy pop tracks.
Flight 643 = one of the best buildups ever.
Lethal Industry = classic.
Suburban Train = saves the best for last. The zenith of Tiesto tracks.
In My Memory has 6 classic cuts that'll always have a mark in trance history, and it's not like there's 12-15 tracks on the LP either - there's 9, which proves how efficient the album in terms of the good/bad track ratio. |
|
|
| Sykonee |
| quote: | Originally posted by Drancge
t
any reason why it sucks |
The byline for their review reads: "The tulip trancemaster tries hard to impress but maybe not hard enough." Full review is here (skip to pg. 101 after the pdf loads) if you're interested. It's a pretty fair review, I'd say, pointing out its strengths and weaknesses. If you think they're being harsh just because it's trance, they also gave Mauro Picotto's The Others and a Gatecrasher compilation 4/5s in that same issue; also, Boards Of Canada's Geogaddi a 2/5.
So take heart. Muzik Magazine figures Tiesto's as good BoC!:gsmile:
Edit: For clarification, Muzik explained their ratings system by way of rappers in that issue.
5/5 = Chuck D
4/5 = Roots Manuva (UK bias, surely)
3/5 = Busta Rhymes
2/5 = Parappa Tha Rapper
1/5 = Ali G & Shaggy |
|
|
| ucforange |
| if I'm listening to Tiesto circa 2000s, it's a Magik CD. Preferably #5 |
|
|
| Drancge |
| quote: | Originally posted by 2techs
2/5?
let's go down the tracklist:
Magik Journey = classic Geert Huinink track.
Close To You = nice downtempo track albeit cheesy.
Dallas 4PM = awesome sample from a 2000 track; can't remember the name.
In My Memory = not really a fan. Airwave's remix is one my all-time favorite remixes though.
Obsession = another big draw from Tiesto's catalogue
Battleship Grey = cut from the same mold as the other cheesy pop tracks.
Flight 643 = one of the best buildups ever.
Lethal Industry = classic.
Suburban Train = saves the best for last. The zenith of Tiesto tracks.
In My Memory has 6 classic cuts that'll always have a mark in trance history, and it's not like there's 12-15 tracks on the LP either - there's 9, which proves how efficient the album in terms of the good/bad track ratio. |
suburban train omg what a track |
|
|
| Drancge |
| quote: | Originally posted by Sykonee
The byline for their review reads: "The tulip trancemaster tries hard to impress but maybe not hard enough." Full review is here (skip to pg. 101 after the pdf loads) if you're interested. It's a pretty fair review, I'd say, pointing out its strengths and weaknesses. If you think they're being harsh just because it's trance, they also gave Mauro Picotto's The Others and a Gatecrasher compilation 4/5s in that same issue; also, Boards Of Canada's Geogaddi a 2/5.
So take heart. Muzik Magazine figures Tiesto's as good BoC!:gsmile:
Edit: For clarification, Muzik explained their ratings system by way of rappers in that issue.
5/5 = Chuck D
4/5 = Roots Manuva (UK bias, surely)
3/5 = Busta Rhymes
2/5 = Parappa Tha Rapper
1/5 = Ali G & Shaggy |
the critic hates tiesto without any valid point
he says the title "magik journey " so stupid that listeners wanna fast forward what a reason man :eyespop: |
|
|
|
|
