return to tranceaddict TranceAddict Forums Archive > Main Forums > Music Discussion

Pages: [1] 2 
Who made better techno, Detroit or Germany?
View this Thread in Original format
2techs
Detroit basically started dance music but I prefer records that came out of Germany


https://YouTube.com/watch?v=I2IMKNFeb2c
Lira
London :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TLhJGWxl0Fc
SYSTEM-J
Detroit techno is unquestionably my favourite style of techno, but a great deal of the Detroit techno artists I like aren't actually from Detroit - people like Aril Brikha, Vince Watson, Chymera, Karim Sahraoui, Kirk DeGiorgio, etc. The Detroit sound is definitely classicist: it hasn't really gone anywhere new for about 20 years and has become a familiar library of comforting sonic tropes, but that doesn't make them any less satisfying.

Not sure why the question is in the past tense, though? Has there been a limited nuclear war in the last week that has wiped both cities off the map?
2techs
I don't really follow the pulse of the scene. Can't wait to feel planetaryplayer's wrath for not being techno enough.
Syntonic
Detroit Techno

Sure, there hasn’t been much innovation or a new wave in a while but if it ain’t broke don’t fix.
planetaryplayer
techno

detroit> rest of USA > England >Germany
OrangestO
I'm not as knowledgeable as all the other fellas on here, but I'd say Detroit based on my listening experience. Even techno can have soul, and the stuff from the D has it.

If it's "smarter" you're looking for, you'd probably prefer Germans.
Kilixpree
The amount of producers from Detroit is much lower, so I'll pick Germany purely due to the volume of good productions.
planetaryplayer
that reasoning is pretty dumb
lacksesepsotygh
Reykjavik

2techs
History of Dub Techno

72hrpartyanimal
quote:
Originally posted by 2techs
History of Dub Techno



thank you! Very educational. Is there a thread with other educational videos about the history various musical genres? "Pump Up the Volume" has been my go-to when helping youngsters.
CLICK TO RETURN TO TOP OF PAGE
Pages: [1] 2 
Privacy Statement