|
Sasha Vs PvD (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| sandstorm03 |
| quote: | Originally posted by DavidScott
HUH? |
im guessing that
| quote: | | Sasha doesnt expect you to walk out liking everything. But even if you didnt like it, you can see his creativity with it. With PVD, he just throws that hard driving repetitive bassline with boring simple melodies layed over them. For some reason, everyone goes crazy. |
is confusing you. Probably since Sasha plays a lot of boring stuff, weather it's to get you into a progy dancy "mood" or not, its boring. He does drop some harder stuff that is better, like philth but thats a mear fraction of his set. Maby 3/4 tracks that get you moving in an 2 hour span.
And can you please explain to me about the complexity of melodies in prog? Since i am a n00b. Because the last time i checked prog has a very small melody, most of the time not even noticeble one over a hopefully good bassline. Do people listen to Prog because it has good melodies? I know i don't. Melodic prog, like some of the stuff armin is playing & some other djs play just sucks. It gets floaty, fluffy and pointless. Does GU 13 have good "prog" melodies? Or is it this thing called trance? I couldn't tell you a prog track with a melody even nearingggggg the complexity of the worst trance melody.
It must be a miracle that paul can get millions of people world wide to actually dance.:rolleyes: |
|
|
| intelligent77 |
| i hate all of you cuz i couldn't see any of this! |
|
|
| Cobra Commander |
| quote: | Originally posted by intelligent77
i hate all of you cuz i couldn't see any of this! |
yeah lucky them heh |
|
|
| Choobak |
| quote: | Originally posted by sandstorm03
im guessing that
is confusing you. Probably since Sasha plays a lot of boring stuff, weather it's to get you into a progy dancy "mood" or not, its boring. He does drop some harder stuff that is better, like philth but thats a mear fraction of his set. Maby 3/4 tracks that get you moving in an 2 hour span.
And can you please explain to me about the complexity of melodies in prog? Since i am a n00b. Because the last time i checked prog has a very small melody, most of the time not even noticeble one over a hopefully good bassline. Do people listen to Prog because it has good melodies? I know i don't. Melodic prog, like some of the stuff armin is playing & some other djs play just sucks. It gets floaty, fluffy and pointless. Does GU 13 have good "prog" melodies? Or is it this thing called trance? I couldn't tell you a prog track with a melody even nearingggggg the complexity of the worst trance melody.
It must be a miracle that paul can get millions of people world wide to actually dance.:rolleyes: |
it's not like this is all black. it's all about taste.
but...
one thing is for sure, even pvd thinks sasha plays a more sophisticated kind of electronic music. he's said it in soundgarden. i think the exact quote (translated) was, "sasha is one of my favorite dj's. he plays a more sophisticated sound." |
|
|
| cryo |
| quote: | Originally posted by trancEyes22
THANK YOU!! i hate how everyone says Sasha puts them to sleep. you must be a ing boring person to just think sasha's music is boring. pvd is predictable and every track he plays sounds the same.
SASHA OWNS YOU ALL!!!:D |
sasha needs to come back to the DC area... |
|
|
| Tranz |
SASHA OWNZ YOU ALL!!!!!!
:haha: |
|
|
| PVD_S11DJ |
| why are you guys comparing sasha and pvd? they spin totally different types of music... theyre both really talented at what they do. |
|
|
| Cobra Commander |
| quote: | Originally posted by PVD_S11DJ
why are you guys comparing sasha and pvd? they spin totally different types of music... theyre both really talented at what they do. |
+1 |
|
|
| Phazon |
| quote: | Originally posted by Cobra Commander
+1 |
No one asked u fagboy |
|
|
| pyro264jb |
| quote: | Originally posted by Phazon
No one asked u fagboy |
lol // |
|
|
| kid nyce |
| quote: | Originally posted by Phazon
No one asked u fagboy |
ROFL! I've always thought Sasha's music was ahead of it's time...clearly it is... |
|
|
| Member of X |
Comparing the two isn't apple and oranges because as mentioned, they aren't spinning the same styles. I like both but I prefer PVD most times in a club because it's more hard. Sasha is experimental and for me, it's 50/50 on if that experiment works. For melodic prog, it's Markus Schulz bitches! Sasha GU Ibiza is awesome but Airdrawndagger and that whole tour was a bit off for me...a little too artsy and not enough meat and potatoes.
Having talked to Sasha for a bit, I came away feeling that the guy was an arrogant prick too which kind of made me sour on him as well.
Taking into saying that Sasha's music is more sophisticated.. I give you that. For me, I don't want to be educated when I'm going clubbing, I want to dance. During his intro I was just sitting there waiting for it to kick in for like 10 minutes... I think I went to use the restroom then.
However, it's hard for me to make blanket statements because while listening to PVD live at Nature One it was quite monotonous. It was just too unrelenting and noisy... which didn't translate well with me at home. In a club it's different for me.
Lastly, each only spun for an hour and I don't think that's the typical fair to judge their performance on. |
|
|
|
|
