|
Minimalism lacking direction?! (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| RJT |
One of the biggest things people seem to utterly fail to realize is that mixing what you folks consider "minimal," and doing it well, is not as close to mixing house and trance well as many appear to think.
So in the end, we have this rush of house, trance, and prog DJ's sprinting to bang the trend of the day out who end up doing a miserable job simply because they haven't taken any time to get to know and understand the music they're spinning. |
|
|
| jupiterone |
| quote: | Originally posted by RJT
One of the biggest things people seem to utterly fail to realize is that mixing what you folks consider "minimal," and doing it well, is not as close to mixing house and trance well as many people appear to think.
So in the end, we have this rush of house, trance, and prog DJ's sprinting to bang the trend of the day out who end up doing a miserable job simply because they haven't taken any time to get to know and understand the music they're spinning. |
ing +1million. Couldnt word it better. |
|
|
| jupiterone |
Anyways my input on this:
I'd usually turn to see what the meaning of minimal is in wiki and the dictionary and compare it to the genre, but honestly minimalism (imo) as a form of music is the total opposite of the dictionary meaning.
I believe minimalism has far more emotion and thought put into it than trance could ever have. The state of mind and feelings most people put into a single pulse and arangement of percussion, glitches and melodies through drums is out of this world. Rather in trance all you get is this melody that should reletively tell you the direction of emotional frequencies it is heading towards.
While in minimalism, the atmosphere and patterns that surround all these hypnotic and sounds cooresponds together with eachother to create, really a tune of pure melody and deep thought. Many people don't get it and find it so plain and boring because they're not in the correct mind set.
Same goes with deep house and house itself as a genre. It's less climatic than trance, yet it creates an atmosphere that tells you stories without needing all that hibba jabba saw melodies trance really does. |
|
|
| julien2 |
Minimal, whatever it means: minimal tech, micro house, glitch house, ketamine house, neo-trance, etc, etc, etc
ROCKS.
It rocked 1 year ago when there was no craze about it.
It rocks a little less now that there is a craze.
And it will rock tomorrow. |
|
|
| bobba lou |
| quote: | Originally posted by RJT
One of the biggest things people seem to utterly fail to realize is that mixing what you folks consider "minimal," and doing it well, is not as close to mixing house and trance well as many appear to think.
So in the end, we have this rush of house, trance, and prog DJ's sprinting to bang the trend of the day out who end up doing a miserable job simply because they haven't taken any time to get to know and understand the music they're spinning. |
great post in regards to the matter. Loads of the bandwagon jumpers think that its just like mixing prog, trance or house. It just makes the ones that do it well sound even better.
great post Turner |
|
|
| cherrybarry |
| saw hawtin, loco dice, and tejada over thanksgiving, and let me say that minimal can be amazing when the dj knows what he's doing |
|
|
| zanzilanzi |
| quote: | Originally posted by stren
I enjoy Electro |
A dubious claim in today's day and age.
| quote: | Originally posted by distant
Name your 5 favorite electro records. |
Cyberian Knights - This Is The Sound Of Underground
MAS 2008 - Monochrome
Kronos Device - Qube
Exzakt - Second Wave
Newcleus - Destination Earth (Sbassship Remix) |
|
|
| Zild |
| Am I not wrong but didn't minimal and electro house peak in 2004? I don't see why people care so much two years later. |
|
|
| DOOMBOT |
| Raudive - Here :tongue3 |
|
|
| Zild |
| quote: | Originally posted by zanzilanzi
A dubious claim in today's day and age.
Cyberian Knights - This Is The Sound Of Underground
MAS 2008 - Monochrome
Kronos Device - Qube
Exzakt - Second Wave
Newcleus - Destination Earth (Sbassship Remix) |
I'm so confused. I thought we were talking about that electro house stuff with the farting basslines. Not real electro. |
|
|
| bobba lou |
| quote: | Originally posted by DOOMBOT
Raudive - Here :tongue3 |
wat about this record? |
|
|
| Sykonee |
| quote: | Originally posted by Zild
I'm so confused. I thought we were talking about that electro house stuff with the farting basslines. Not real electro. |
Yeah. People tend to call funkless farting bassline house 'electro' for some reason. Perhaps P-Funk links it, since fart basslines was pioneered by Clinton and his posse. |
|
|
|
|
