|
Ta Dj Ranking (Competition) (pg. 20)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| DJ.MD |
| Thanks for the good scores guys. I currently judging challenge 7 and will be done by tomorrow. One of the judges sent me his scores too which I will forward on to sphere |
|
|
| djsphere |
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ.MD
Thanks for the good scores guys. I currently judging challenge 7 and will be done by tomorrow. One of the judges sent me his scores too which I will forward on to sphere |
Don't send me the scores. One of you will post the final results. |
|
|
| Rockabye |
| challenge 5 judging is finished by me. I've send my results to DJMarkV. |
|
|
| DJ Mark V |
| alright, i'll calculate everything and post them soon! |
|
|
| mr2gti |
| Good man, Challenge 5 seems to have quite a high status to it. |
|
|
| DJ Mark V |
OPPONENT 1
Rockabye
Track Selection & Play Order: 23
Beat Matching: 23
Transition Harmonics: 22
Total: 91%
DJ Mark V
Track Selection & Play Order: 25
Beat Matching: 24
Transition Harmonics: 24
Total: 97%
Jay M (Yarune)
Track Selection & Play Order: 21
Beat Matching: 21
Transition Harmonics: 24
Total: 88%
TOTAL: 92%
OPPONENT 2
Rockabye
Track Selection & Play Order: 20
Beat Matching: 18
Transition Harmonics: 19
Total: 76%
DJ Mark V
Track Selection & Play Order: 20
Beat Matching: 21
Transition Harmonics: 20
Total: 78%
Jay M (Yarune)
Track Selection & Play Order: 23
Beat Matching: 19
Transition Harmonics: 21
Total: 84%
TOTAL: 80%
Winner: Opponent 1
Runner-Up: Opponent 2
DJ Mark V - Score Explanations
Competition 5
Opponent 1
Track Selection and Play Order:
One word --- Superb. The track selection was amazing; you had some really great tunes in there. The play order was chiseled to perfection.
Score: 24
Beat Matching:
Incredible beat matching skills, you are well above adequate, keep doing what you’re doing because it bought you points for this competition.
Score: 25
Transition Harmonics:
Transition 1: What can I say about this transition besides, “absolutely beautiful” That was a very professional sounding transition; you brought in the sounds and made a great long stretching transition and hit the vocals perfectly.
Transition 2: Yet another beautiful transition here. The cymbals clicked great with the track you mixed into. The deep bass and the kick matched the flow flawlessly; and again, the vocals were perfectly placed, great job.
Transition 3: Nice long transitional phase here, I really enjoyed that. The electric guitar strings from the previous track you mixed out of and the drums of the transitional track harmonized to precision. This was another professional quality transition.
Transition 4: Great transition, for the average listener, to pick up on that would be tough. It was a very nice flow into the transitional track.
Transition 5: Another unnoticeable transition to the average listener, I barely picked up on in myself and I was listening closely, quite intriguing if you ask me.
Overall Transition Harmonic Overview:
The definition of harmonic is:
Pleasing to the ear: harmonic orchestral effects.
With that in mind, I feel that this is a professional quality mix, there’s no other real explanation. You did exactly what a DJ is supposed to do, entertain the listener!
Where to Improve: The one thing I’ll tell you to do is this. Find an internet radio station and apply for a residence, put your skills to work! Great mix set.
Score: 24
Competition 5
Opponent 2
Track Selection and Play Order:
The track selection was decent and the play order went alright, I feel that perhaps you could have chosen songs that fit better with each other rather than forcing them together.
Score: 20
Beat Matching:
An ever improving field is this one, just practice and you’ll be able to find small techniques of your own that will help you to master the challenge of beat matching.
Score: 21
Transition Harmonics:
Transition 1: I had to wait for the entire transition to figure out the effect you were aiming for. To me, it felt like you track faded out and the other forced its way in. The beat matching was alright, it needed to flow better and contain more melody, or otherwise it wouldn’t be an issue.
Transition 2: Not a bad transition at all, the vocals hit perfectly and your stings came in pretty well; however the kicks on your beats along with the bass at certain points faded out a bit. But decent transition nonetheless
Transition 3: You brought in the transitional track a pretty decent mix point; I thought that was a good improvement on the last two. One thing you might consider is having there be more action while transitioning, if you’re going to the beats kicking, make them exciting or at least melodic, add some melody to it by bringing in some strings.
Transition 4: One thing you have to be careful about, is knowing the difference between matching melodies and matching sounds. The sounds matched, but the melodies of the two tracks didn’t so much, and that’s why you were forced to cut this transition short. But I noticed the effort put into improving that on this transition. Good improvement.
Transition 5: The cymbals went perfectly with that track! You should have brought them in earlier! The melodies even swayed decently together, bring in your transitional track earlier is all I can tell you.
Overall Transition Harmonic Overview:
The definition of harmonic is:
Pleasing to the ear: harmonic orchestral effects.
With that in mind, I thought the mix went alright, wasn’t bad, but didn’t live up to the potential it had. Beat matching is key, you did fairly well, but fighting that with good track selection will help the situation.
Where to Improve: I feel that there can be improvement on making wiser decisions of tracks being played and bringing in the transitional phase earlier rather than later.
Score: 20 |
|
|
| tommyd |
| Thanks for the Judging guys, i cut 6 tracks out of a trance promo i did a few mounths ago cause i ran out of time! Def going do a new mix for the next challenge because the comp is tough, cheers for the detailed breakdown! |
|
|
| DJ Mark V |
| fo sho, good set |
|
|
| DJ Trancedelic |
| Tomorrow i'll be living for Germany... Pls Sphere may I be put on Passive Mode (no challenges?). For about 3 weeks? |
|
|
| tommyd |
| going on holiday for 2 weeks on the 11th so no more challenges till i get back pls! Cheers! |
|
|
| d-kristopherre |
mark v -- another beautiful, clear, concise bit of feedback. thank you so much for your words. i really enjoyed throwing that mix down. not bad for a one shot deal. i figured if we were doing a 'live' competition it should simulate 'live'ness.
oh, and how does one go about applying for a radio residency? all new stuff to me |
|
|
| Pinokio |
| quote: | Originally posted by d-kristopherre
oh, and how does one go about applying for a radio residency? all new stuff to me |
i know of The rising stars on Etn.fm, if you send them your demo, it can be broadcasted, and if you are thqat awesome maybe they will give you residency, i'm not sure, but you can try there.
http://www.etn.fm/news.asp?id=99 |
|
|
|
|
