|
Dj Sammy Vs Paul Van Dyk (pg. 2)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Demoted |
Once again, I'd like to flame this thread, but I just know others will do it better, and far more eloquently than I possibly could. So I'll just stick with a "heh".
Heh. |
|
|
| kramer333 |
| "Crazy frog - popcorn" was a "bigger" commercial hit than any Paul van dyk tune..... and you think thát makes the freak behind the "crazy frog" project more talented? |
|
|
| RapidFire |
| quote: | Originally posted by kramer333
"Crazy frog - popcorn" is a "bigger" commercial hit than any Paul van dyk tune..... and you think that makes the freak behind the "crazy frog" project more talented? |
um crazy frog has nothing to do with music. even the guy that created him stated that it was a ploy to make a quick buck.
not to mention thats a classic electronic song (probably the first) that crazy frog ripped off (its not a cover if its EXACTLY the same) and added his annoying gimp voice over.
PvD is a legend. you may not like him now but listen to his stuff pre 2003 and compare it to any of the cheeseballs you mentioned in this thread and if you cant distinguish the good from the bad then youre a lost cause. |
|
|
| ASFSE |
| i dont really understand |
|
|
| Sumit_A |
| Jeeeeejjjjjuuussss!!! |
|
|
| cmay119 |
| quote: | Originally posted by all-nite-freak
william hung had a hit that doesnt make him good...
dj sammy is the worst of all time bar none. |
I believe it's tied between Sammy and DJ Alligator Project... |
|
|
| Sumit_A |
| l'by hbbaaaaaa..... |
|
|
| cmay119 |
I'm also confused by the comparison of artists here? Why pick PvD to be compared with DJ Sammy as they are so disimilar it sounds like you just picked the first DJ name that popped into your head and decided to make this thread.
I look at this comparison as a very apples to oranges debate while no real validaty will come from it besides that every post will be screaming PvD is the better Producer/DJ. 'nuf said.
I suggest to you to expand your horizons past the commercial realm of Trance or electronica and you'll soon realize how bad sammy is.
Good day. |
|
|
| Sumit_A |
| All together now, l'by hhbbbaaaaaaaa............. |
|
|
| lucasp_10 |
| quote: | Originally posted by CHRles
Has PVD ever produced a Brian Adams or Don Henley remake? NO. Has he ever played a Brian Adams or Don Henley song in his sets? I think not. Has PVD based his career on remaking other people's music? Big N-O!
Has PVD been one of the pioneers of the Trance scene? Why yes, he's been involved with it since the early 90s.
Has PVD produced vocals? Yes he's dabbled in both instrumental and vocal tunes. In some Progressive and even in Breakbeat projects.
Nothing against DJ Sammy, but he's nowhere in the same league as Paul. |
hahaha
Well said, well said. |
|
|
| IntegraR0064 |
Here's the thing. DJ Sammy is nothing, musically. Yes, "Boys of Summer" may be a catchy tune, but there's nothing there. It's an 80's hit that he basically took the music, ran it through a couple synthesizers, got some girl to sing the lyrics, and that's it. There's nothing to it.
PVD....it depends on the individual production, but as a general trend, his music is much more musically deep than anything dj sammy has even thought about, let alone produced. Lately, he's been kind of hit or miss, but that's a different issue. Even then, at least his music is original. |
|
|
| sikrav |
The reason i chose PVD is because so many of you think of him as your poster boy....and so many of you think of Dj sammy as cheese. Im still going to stick to my argument and say that; yes i loved "nothing but you", pure genius in terms of trance. And PVD is a trance pioneer and played a big part in bringing trance closer to mainstream, But as far as PVD goes thats about it. I made a thread in the past called "reflecting on reflections", in which i was talking about how crap the album was. In terms of quality of production dj sammy wins hands down, in terms of sales dj sammy wins hands down and in terms of hits dj sammy wins hands down. I know i may be the only one who thinks this but hey who cares.
In fact im going to see PVD play at metro in a few weeks so it'll be interesting to see how it goes! |
|
|
|
|
