|
Help me understand what happened to Trance... (pg. 11)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| SYSTEM-J |
| quote: | Originally posted by Donkeyness
|
I like seeing you post. It's one of those pleasant reminders that the universe is still running on invisible lines. The speed of light. Planck's constant. The permitivity of free space. And Radagast still desperately thinking that if he hides any personal details and traces of himself, people won't notice that he's responsible for the same God-awful bull every time.
EDIT: And why even bother arguing with Ishkur? It's not as if he's ever actually took part in a meaningful debate on this subject in his life, and he's damned if he won't run away crying if you try. |
|
|
| Zombie0915 |
| I do it for fun personally, its always entertaining doing these big threads. |
|
|
| tactik |
| quote: | Originally posted by Zombie0915
I do it for fun personally, its always entertaining doing these big threads. |
Reading them is also always entertaining. ;) |
|
|
| Cobalt |
| quote: | Originally posted by A.J.
After reading several of your posts, I still have no idea where you come up with some of this self-righteous bull.
Over and over and over again, I read posts from you where you single out the trance genre (today) as some lesser form of music that refuses to accept its own inherent 'cheesyness'. How are you making this distinction? There are cheesy tracks in most, if not all genres if EDM. Yet somehow you always seem to come back to 'holier-than-thou' trance, the music that 'thinks' that it is better than everyone else.
:rolleyes:
Are you basing this on forum posts from 16-year-old n00bs who have just discovered dance music? Are you basing this on idiots that compare trance to classical music? Magazine articles? DJ interviews? People that proclaim Tiesto as some sort of musical genius?
Seriously, I am curious to learn how you have arrived at this assertion that trance music is somehow different from other genres in 'accepting' its cheesiness. |
I'd point out many of the same things. The crux of Ishkur's position is that trance takes itself too seriously, which is a pretty subjective claim, and difficult to evidence. I think in some cases he's right, especially with the new breed of epic producers, but he can't claim to know the "intent" behind all trance he's heard. The argument applies decently to bloated headliners, but there are so many TAs who essentially think the same thing. It quickly becomes indefensible outside a few easy targets.
As for taking itself too seriously as a style, damn, look at Ferry. He obviously doesn't think so, and he's one of the biggest, most commerical names around. Armin and Tiesto get loads and loads of abuse from TA members because they don't have the same attitude towards what they play. |
|
|
| Zombie0915 |
I dont think the above and beyond show takes itself very seriously either, they are joking about stuff all the time on there, and the radio voice blurbs says things like "trance around the world, fun music, news, and stupid commentary!"
I mean, that doesnt sound like taking itself seriously, or claiming to be something its not, at least to me. So many of these trance musicians are really humble people when one meets them, they aren't acting like they are bigger than jesus, the promoters are more responsible for that I think. |
|
|
| isoterra |
| quote: | Originally posted by Donkeyness
You didn't get it.
|
yes i did.
| quote: | | Oh yeah...real goding desperate lengths...like taking 60 seconds to type a message on the internet...wow. |
or perhaps longer than that. and also perhaps frequently, on a regular basis. and also perhaps reregistering countless accounts to say the same thing over & over again after people keep realising who you are and remembering you're a cancerous waste of space no-one likes.
| quote: | | The pop machine transformed trance in order to accomodate those 'reasons'. When it did, the underlying intentions of the music changed from (what ishkur said about classic trance) to (what ishkur said about new trance). The evidence of this is stupid people who take trance too seriously by DJ worship and comparison to classical music and glossy flyers an blah blah blah all that stuff he said about it. Don't you pay attention? |
the music doesn't even have underlying intentions you thick , that's what i was arguing against. do *you* pay attention?
| quote: | | Listeners are like that because that's the way they were born. People are born stupid, and remain that way unless they take action to remedy that fact. |
unfortunately it doesn't work all the time does it, maturing your music tastes doesn't necessarily make you less stupid, as you've proved time & time again. |
|
|
| Ishkur |
| quote: | Originally posted by isoterra
the music doesn't even have underlying intentions |
Yes it does.
Its purpose is to make money. |
|
|
| Rainborn |
| Ishkur pissed on trance and now it's decaying |
|
|
| torontotrance |
| Ishkur takes the piss at everything, you fools just never get it and you wankers that don't, just continue arguing like mofos. Trance is not dead, certain forms just went back underground again, its the music cycle. |
|
|
| Rainborn |
| I know I know, that's what I said in the very first thread I participated in with this subject. |
|
|
| Numidia |
| quote: | Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
And why even bother arguing with Ishkur? It's not as if he's ever actually took part in a meaningful debate on this subject in his life, and he's damned if he won't run away crying if you try. |
Well.. what he says about Ferry Corsten killing trance is complete garbage but his scathing criticisms of mindless DJ worship is spot on if i may say so |
|
|
| Spirit5 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Numidia
Well.. what he says about Ferry Corsten killing trance is complete garbage but his scathing criticisms of mindless DJ worship is spot on if i may say so |
Yeah this is one thing I will also admit to agreeing with Ishkur on, the DJ Worship thing. I used to worship Tiesto and Armin lol, back in 2002 and 2003, but for the past two years or so i've become less and less about all these big name DJs. They still might play some stuff I like, but that doesn't make them godly or anything. I realize they are human and have their faults just like everyone else, people just elevate them to god status like they can do no wrong. They can't remain on top forever, and there are plenty of DJs who aren't number 1, 2, 3 or 4, or even on the DJ Mag Top 100 for that matter that are better. |
|
|
|
|
