|
Illegal music downloading (pg. 2)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Abercrombie |
| Anyone have any bar charts on CD and music sales in Canada? I'm curious as how downloading has affected the industry over the years. I heard conflicting info, like music sales are down for big name comemrcial artists, but the internet has increased sales for independants... So what is it? |
|
|
| infinity HiGH |
| quote: | Originally posted by Abercrombie
Anyone have any bar charts on CD and music sales in Canada? I'm curious as how downloading has affected the industry over the years. I heard conflicting info, like music sales are down for big name comemrcial artists, but the internet has increased sales for independants... So what is it? |
that sounds pretty reasonable to me.
plus, you can't really attribute sales, whether increasing or decreasing, to the internet alone. there could be a number of other factors that could be affecting sales. |
|
|
| Silky Johnson |
| quote: | Originally posted by infinity HiGH
why couldn't you just change the 3 to a 4?
|
I dunno? I'm weird okay??!! |
|
|
| infinity HiGH |
| quote: | Originally posted by jennypie
I'm weird okay??!! |
...
are you asking me? |
|
|
| MarkT |
There is far less of an excuse to not pay for music now that you can d/l singles from places like iTunes and Beatport for under $2.00 a track.
Before this, I didn't really have as much a problem with some file sharing. When artists and labels stopped caring about putting out quality ALBUMS, and instead would give us 1 or 2 decent tracks along with a bunch of filler *crap*, they shouldn't be surprised to see people unwilling to spend $15-20 for a CD or $5+ for a single.
It didn't make illegal file sharing "right"...but if you give us a quality product at a reasonable price, and a convenient method of obtaining it, most people will pay for it. I think that's happening now with downloads and with the ability to preview a portion of every track online as well. |
|
|
| psiico111 |
I'm not a rabid downloader or anything but I do occasionally download a track or two. The majority of my mp3 collection (905% of it) is obscure covers, I like hearing a country act do a Metallica song, stuff like that. To buy those tracks would require a lot of effort to hunt them down. But don't we pay premium on cassettes (since the 80's) and blank cd's because of downloading? What's the government doing with that revenue? Aren't they redistributing it to the artists?
Just playing devil's advocate. I know people who say as far as they are concerned it's legal to download in this country because of that premium we pay. |
|
|
| Jayx1 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Porky
can it be the other way around? with viral marketing from music oriented websites like myspace, alot of underground artists have gotten greater exposure that they wouldn't have gotten otherwise in a traditional non-digital bricks+mortar scheme
the bottom line... if you're talented, and produce good music, ppl will find you. if you suck, then you won't make money. |
so people discover these bands... then they go and download their songs.
So the artist still doesnt make much money.
Its a really bad cycle. At 1 to 2 bucks a song people really dont have an excuse for stealing music |
|
|
| Jayx1 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Orko
I agree 100% that you need to support the artist, and my music collection reflects that.
What I do not buy are the sales stats that downloading is 100% responsible for the decline in sales. Yes this is the same old argument, but so is blaming downloaders for an already weak library of music.
Lets face it, music is not the same as it used to be. I spent $1000s in the 90's for quality music that I loved, and just could not live with out. Since about 1999, I have switched music genres, and the only reason my spending even comes close is because the CDs I know buy (EDM) are twice as expensive as mainstream CDs that I used to buy.
So yes, support the artist, but don't blame people for not paying for music when they do not think its worth it. |
i dont really blame people for not buying hard copies. That part of the industry still needs to sort its out. And im talking both label and retailer here. But like i said, online at a buck or two there is no excuse to steal the music.
And downloading is responsible for most of the decline. The stats show a massive drop off between 99 and 2000 when napster got big. |
|
|
| Abercrombie |
| In Canada, I believe we are paying either $0.21 or $0.77 per CD-R in to offset the downloading. I guess an issue is if this money is properly used. |
|
|
| Jayx1 |
| quote: | Originally posted by Abercrombie
In Canada, I believe we are paying either $0.21 or $0.77 per CD-R in to offset the downloading. I guess an issue is if this money is properly used. |
its not... its just a tax grab |
|
|
| Dj Smitty20 |
I own over 90 cd's and recently sold my vinyl collection of about 78 records. I support my artists but I still download the odd track if I really, really want to listen to it. For instance, I remembered that Porno - Music Power track from a couple years ago after hearing it on Saturday night again. Where else am I supposed to get this track? I looked on ITunes and didnt' find it. And i'm certainly not going to buy the LP for something i'll listen to for a few days and then most likely delete.
But I figure I've given a lot to the industry, at least compared to most people. Certainly guys like Tiesto, PvD adn Ferry have done well off me but I also own 2 Mark Oliver CD's, Sander's albums, etc.
But you know, I have to be honest. THe music industry ed themselves by pricing their cd's at 30-40 dollars while the artist actually sees very little of that. That's what you call corporate greed. |
|
|
| Matt |
http://www.bradsucks.net/
| quote: | Why would I buy your music when you give it away for free?
Well I don't know, but people have been doing it and I hope they
continue. Maybe they like a CD to hold in their hands, maybe they just
want to support artists, maybe it's just flat-out pity.
I put my music online because I want people to hear it. I'd
obviously love to make a living making music, but if the worst-case
scenario is becoming a well-heard artist that never gets paid, I can
live with that. |
I am not advocating being able to download all music for free... I just only think quality stuff deserves to be purchased. |
|
|
|
|
