|
wall street protests...is this the start of the revolution? (pg. 8)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| TranceArmstrong |
| quote: | Originally posted by Joss Weatherby
utopian ideal |
I'd prefer Ron Paul to any of the other republican presidential candidates, and certainly to Obama... hoping for some utopian ideal is more fun than accepting the status quo election after election. |
|
|
| Joss Weatherby |
| quote: | Originally posted by TranceArmstrong
I'd prefer Ron Paul to any of the other republican presidential candidates, and certainly to Obama... hoping for some utopian ideal is more fun than accepting the status quo election after election. |
I don't think you understand the term Utopian Ideal... :conf: |
|
|
| srussell0018 |
| He had me until Ron Paul. |
|
|
| Vector A |
| quote: | Time has a new poll up today showing that 54% of the people polled view the Occupy Wall St. movement favorably (very, or somewhat), whereas only 27% see the Tea Party movement in the same light.
On the flip side 13% of those polled view the Wall St. protesters in a 'very unfavorable' light whereas 27% think that of the Tea Party. |
http://www.businessinsider.com/poll...a-party-2011-10 |
|
|
| TranceArmstrong |
You said that libertarianism is a utopian ideal. I don't agree with that, but even if it is, I would much rather try it out than elect one of the other republicans or re-elect Obama.
To me, the belief that the US federal government can smoothly and efficiently deliver productive employment, economic growth, education, healthcare, stable monetary policy, protection of civil liberties, and a whole bunch of other things it purports to do is also a utopian ideal. (Not to say you're an advocate of any/all of these things, I don't know where you stand on anything other than disliking Ron Paul) |
|
|
| nefardec |
looks like the they are going to get evicted tomorrow morning. i was planning on going back tomorrow afternoon.
the mayor is planning a 'cleaning' ruse whereby they kick people out 'temporarily' from parts of the park while they clean. then they are introducing a set of new park rules that state you're not allowed to either lay down or set up sleeing bags and tarps.
how do you end a revolution? take away their blankets |
|
|
| GoSpeedGo! |
| quote: | Originally posted by Arbiter
Do you have any idea how much corporate money is being poured into spreading this little movement at this very moment? |
No. Do you? I don't have any insider information.
It's definitely plausible though, this is how this kind of real capitalism we're living in works, and how it makes people feel comfortable in their passivity. Things like Live 8 or whatever's the crap called. "Let's all pretend we're helping the poor so that noone actually helps them." |
|
|
| Joss Weatherby |
| quote: | Originally posted by TranceArmstrong
To me, the belief that the US federal government can smoothly and efficiently deliver productive employment, economic growth, education, healthcare, stable monetary policy, protection of civil liberties, and a whole bunch of other things it purports to do is also a utopian ideal. (Not to say you're an advocate of any/all of these things, I don't know where you stand on anything other than disliking Ron Paul) |
It is not a Utopian ideal because plenty of other countries provide their citizens with much better versions of the services you all mentioned. So its not utopian because it exists elsewhere. Its just an issue if we can get the US to do it or not. Libertarians do not even want to try though. They want to give it all to the private corporations that are the issue right now.
You realize thats what libertarianism is right? Its mainly based on the idea that corporations can do everything better than government. They wrap it up in "individuals" but they put no limitations on where and what big business plays a roll in. It's basically selling everything out to the corporations who have absolutely no vested interest in keeping people happy, healthy, and educated. That is how the corporations act in this country (sadly, its not even a utopian ideal that you have strong care-taking corporations, because a lot of corporations in other countries are far more aligned with their national interests than those in the US). |
|
|
| smokeu |
All parties seem to agree that Wall Street bankers should have never got bailed out, but it was a Democratic Congress which factually passed the legislation to make it happen.
A little disparaged, as of most Americans are, about the message the protestors are trying to make with their protest. Got the Wall Street part, and we can't change what already happened unless we want to spend more taxpayer money to send a few scapegoats to jail while the main culprits and the rest go free which is a given.
If the protesters had any kind of message other than far left blather about redistributing wealth from the rich to the poor (aka communism), then its not happening. I don't know if they really expect finance brokers to walk out of the NYSE Stock Exchange and write them a check to make them feel good. A large portion of the protestors are probably living that dream now through welfare where those same NYSE Brokers are, in effect, paying the taxes to write them paychecks for doing nothing now.
[[[smoke]]] |
|
|
| Joss Weatherby |
| quote: | Originally posted by smokeu
All parties seem to agree that Wall Street bankers should have never got bailed out, but it was a Democratic Congress which factually passed the legislation to make it happen.
A little disparaged, as of most Americans are, about the message the protestors are trying to make with their protest. Got the Wall Street part, and we can't change what already happened unless we want to spend more taxpayer money to send a few scapegoats to jail while the main culprits and the rest go free which is a given.
If the protesters had any kind of message other than far left blather about redistributing wealth from the rich to the poor (aka communism), then its not happening. I don't know if they really expect finance brokers to walk out of the NYSE Stock Exchange and write them a check to make them feel good. A large portion of the protestors are probably living that dream now through welfare where those same NYSE Brokers are, in effect, paying the taxes to write them paychecks for doing nothing now.
[[[smoke]]] |
Its not communism idiot. No one is saying nationalize all the banks, no one is talking about disbanding all private property. They are talking about socialism, which the top rated countries all implement to varying degrees, all more than the US does. |
|
|
| smokeu |
| quote: | Originally posted by Joss Weatherby
Its not communism idiot. No one is saying nationalize all the banks, no one is talking about disbanding all private property. They are talking about socialism, which the top rated countries all implement to varying degrees, all more than the US does. |
Socialism has failed in Europe and banks there are struggling to keep Greece, Turkey, Italy, and others afloat.
Not a good system to mirror our economy off of which Obama has tried to do. Has ended up in a historic debt that our grandkids will inherit (your kid's kids), a steady and abysmal unemployment rate more like 16% than the advertised 9%, and an economy faltering which could topple the world's economy without some drastic and immediate action. That would mean firing the incumbents, including the Fed chief and the rest of the "ill" advisors which have sunk us into a funk, and putting someone else in charge to solve the problem.
Free enterprise has always proven to be a better substitute over socialism.
[[[smoke]]] |
|
|
|
|
