|
What would you do? (pg. 12)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| Orbax |
| quote: | Originally posted by M@t
You are now confusing protection and instigation of violence against a person. I would protect my gf to the death, but i would not seek to avenge an attack on her in the same way as you, as i have already stated. |
So your girlfriend comes stumbling home, with half her clothes torn off, and a bloody nose, and says "Someone raped me" and you say "sorry, I wasnt there, I cant do anything about it" |
|
|
| Arbiter |
| quote: | Originally posted by Orbax
So your girlfriend comes stumbling home, with half her clothes torn off, and a bloody nose, and says "Someone raped me" and you say "sorry, I wasnt there, I cant do anything about it" |
Don't worry about that, you can count on M@t to heroically run off to tell the authorities so that they can maybe-eventually reward, er, uh, punish the perpetrator with free room and board for a few years paid for in part by said female's tax dollars! That'll show 'em! |
|
|
| M@t |
| quote: | Originally posted by Orbax
So your girlfriend comes stumbling home, with half her clothes torn off, and a bloody nose, and says "Someone raped me" and you say "sorry, I wasnt there, I cant do anything about it" |
She wouldnt want me to go and kick seven shades of out of someone to get revenge. If i did that, our relationship would be over, and not just because i'd get put up at her majesty's service.
But clearly if im not there i cant protect her, and the police are much more qualified to be able to do something about it, so its not up to me. |
|
|
| Orbax |
| quote: | Originally posted by Arbiter
Don't worry about that, you can count on M@t to heroically run off to tell the authorities so that they can maybe-eventually reward, er, uh, punish the perpetrator with free room and board for a few years paid for in part by said female's tax dollars! That'll show 'em! |
dude, dont be ridiculous.
mat would call them on the phone. |
|
|
| M@t |
| quote: | Originally posted by Arbiter
Don't worry about that, you can count on M@t to heroically run off to tell the authorities so that they can maybe-eventually reward, er, uh, punish the perpetrator with free room and board for a few years paid for in part by said female's tax dollars! That'll show 'em! |
You're cynicism of the judicial system is not the issue here. |
|
|
| Orbax |
| quote: | Originally posted by M@t
She wouldnt want me to go and kick seven shades of out of someone to get revenge. If i did that, our relationship would be over, and not just because i'd get put up at her majesty's service.
But clearly if im not there i cant protect her, and the police are much more qualified to be able to do something about it, so its not up to me. |
im sure that after being raped, all she would want would be a peaceful resolution to the matter and she would never think about it again because it had been resolved so perfectly, and the man learned his lesson. |
|
|
| Dervish |
Ok where would you draw the line here how close would someone have to be to you for you to go off and beat the person who wronged them up? Family, friend, co worker, person you kinda know.....
How much do you beat them up? A punch, till they hit the ground, keep going when they are on the ground, stop breathing?
The fact is you don't know you would be acting impulsively, not rationally.
And last time I checked rational thought is a good thing. |
|
|
| Arbiter |
| quote: | Originally posted by M@t
You're cynicism of the judicial system is not the issue here. |
Well in a situation such as this one has two options:
1. to take matters into one's own hands, or
2. to leave the matter of dealing with the perpetrator in the hands of someone else (typically the police/judicial system.)
In determining the comparative ethicality of these two options, it would seem to me the dependability of the "someone else" in option number two is rather central to the issue. |
|
|
| CraveTheRave |
"...Chinese triads are reputed to be among the most dangerous of organized crime organizations..."
Link
That's my culture for ya. |
|
|
| M@t |
| quote: | Originally posted by Orbax
im sure that after being raped, all she would want would be a peaceful resolution to the matter and she would never think about it again because it had been resolved so perfectly, and the man learned his lesson. |
Whether the man learns his lesson by imprisonment or via a thugs vindictive actions can hardly be guaranteed. |
|
|
| M@t |
| quote: | Originally posted by Arbiter
Well in a situation such as this one has two options:
1. to take matters into one's own hands, or
2. to leave the matter of dealing with the perpetrator in the hands of someone else (typically the police/judicial system.)
In determining the comparative ethicality of these two options, it would seem to me the dependability of the "someone else" in option number two is rather central to the issue. |
Well clearly the basis of my argument is that one (orbax) shouldnt have the need for two options, because he shouldnt have it in his mindset to commit such an act. The fact that he might believe the judicial system incapable of exacting a suitable revenge for him is not the matter here |
|
|
| Dervish |
| quote: | Originally posted by Arbiter
Well in a situation such as this one has two options:
1. to take matters into one's own hands, or
2. to leave the matter of dealing with the perpetrator in the hands of someone else (typically the police/judicial system.)
In determining the comparative ethicality of these two options, it would seem to me the dependability of the "someone else" in option number two is rather central to the issue. |
Yes, but you have to realise that in taking option 1 you are stepping outwith the laws of the nation your a citizen of and as such you can prosecuted yourself.
And in the "highly rational" state you are in you can assess how much jail time you are going to get for the "exact set of actions" you are going to carry out upon this person? |
|
|
|
|
