|
Final Round - Ends February 3rd 7:07 AM GMT (pg. 14)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| toffy |
Perasma is a fair winner.
All rounds:
Perasma : 95 votes, 70 votes, 71 votes.
Silent Waves : 53 votes, 46 votes, 69 votes.
Not only that, it needed 4 days to get 1st position instead of those 5 minutes in which Silent Waves got 10-12 votes on monday when both tracks where equaled.
For me just Without you could have been 1st instead of Perasma, is a pity.
Then, coongratz Perasma. |
|
|
| Cobalt |
| I think Swing 2 Harmony is a fair winner. Of course everyone will think there are tracks far better, but most everyone liked it. (RJT excepted :) ) |
|
|
| DJ Indus Creed |
On a side note, i would like to mention that Silent Wave is a good track - i never for once said it was bad or anything.
And i would also like to believe many a passionate supporters of Pryda - Aftermath when they say that the track brings the house down and sounds different on a dance floor than in the confines of one's shelter.
I played them both a few times over when they made it to the final-8. I have two CDJs and a 400 Watt stereo system along with a 2-Channel mixer. I played them at different settings too. Just wanted to be sure.
I often drive from Tampa to Miami on the weekends and on those long drives, i usually keep a lot of CDs, often filled with tracks recommended by TAs in different threads (Thank You guys) and if i am tempted to play a song again and again, i know its good.
That is one reason why i was surprised to see "A Tear In The Open (Leama and Moor Mix)", "Air For Life" and "I Found You" miss the cut. And was also surprised to see Tilt-Twelve and Kuffdam and Plant - Summer dream poll so less votes. Even Love Theme Dusk should've polled more than what it did.
I would've loved to see a fight between "Without You", "Love Theme Dusk", "Air For Life", "I Found You", "Summer dream", "A Tear In The Open" and "Swing 2 harmony". Just my thoughts. |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by toffy
Perasma is a fair winner.
All rounds:
Perasma : 95 votes, 70 votes, 71 votes.
Silent Waves : 53 votes, 46 votes, 69 votes.
Not only that, it needed 4 days to get 1st position instead of those 5 minutes in which Silent Waves got 10-12 votes on monday when both tracks where equaled.
For me just Without you could have been 1st instead of Perasma, is a pity.
Then, coongratz Perasma. |
Wow... way to fight a battle after you've already won.... real class... :rolleyes:
But...
| quote: | Originally posted by Cloud
It is not 2005 tho. |
Is still true... So I guess when it comes down to it, if people REALLY wanted to play fair, Perasma wouldn't have been involved at all, now would it?
You Trance-Crackers and your Cheese crack me up... |
|
|
| toffy |
Man, let's be serious. The people in TA has nominated these tracks. If Perasma was in this poll was cause people choice. And if Perasma has won is again cause people wanted it to won, without tricks or double accounts like with Silent Waves.
Other term of discussion is to which year a track belong. If we talk about when it was relled, Perasma has been released in 2005 except for the Ultra release (December 2004). If we talk about when they appeared, Summer Dream should be in a "some years ago" poll. ;)
And man, I dont understand you. You just wanted Silent Waves to win Perasma in the poll, not cause you really thought it deserved to win. In that case, i dont understand a phrase in your post like "You Trance-Crackers and your Cheese crack me up", cause Silent Waves is mainly..trance. |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by toffy
Man, let's be serious. The people in TA has nominated these tracks. If Perasma was in this poll was cause people choice. And if Perasma has won is again cause people wanted it to won, without tricks or double accounts like with Silent Waves.
Other term of discussion is to which year a track belong. If we talk about when it was relled, Perasma has been released in 2005 except for the Ultra release (December 2004). If we talk about when they appeared, Summer Dream should be in a "some years ago" poll. ;)
And man, I dont understand you. You just wanted Silent Waves to win Perasma in the poll, not cause you really thought it deserved to win. In that case, i dont understand a phrase in your post like "You Trance-Crackers and your Cheese crack me up", cause Silent Waves is mainly..trance. |
"Silent Waves" is one of TWO trance tracks released this year that I thought were genuinely good trance, the other being the Ljungqvist remix of "Space Guitar." I like the track, a lot, and a big part of it is because it's not the epitome of standard cheese...
Saying "Swing 2 Harmony" was the Trance track of the year is like saying McDonalds has the worlds greatest hamburgers...
And as far as release, just because something gets a re-release years later doesn't mean that's the year it was released, if it was, Strange World, My Lexicon, Children, etc. would be eligible to win every year...
Bottom line is that I think voting for this track as TOTY speaks volumes about the "State of Trance" right now (pun not intended), and is a PRIME example of why myself and many others are briskly moving away from this type of EDM... |
|
|
| toffy |
As you will never agree with me i stop here, i wont waste my time. Only that..
| quote: | Originally posted by DJ RJT
PRIME example of why MYSELF... briskly moving away from this type of EDM... |
And the happy i am that you dont listening it.Thanks. |
|
|
| BlueFear |
| quote: | Originally posted by Estuera
I'm quite honoured to see a track of mine in the finale but the maker of the poll made a small typo. It's 'Silent waves' instead of wave :o |
Hi:
Hard to believe that a producer himself read this thread. I'm no here to fawn anyone, but Silent Wave is just great. That's where my vote went to.
By the way (as a Bedroom dj) I can not help mixing Castamara after SW everytime.
BTW, does someone knows any other producer reading this? |
|
|
| BlueFear |
| quote: | Originally posted by toffy
New accounts in the last 4 weeks(2006 so far) at least shouldnt be able to vote. If it cant be fixed this shouldnt be a valid round. |
AGREE.
For next year TOTY, I'd say people registered after September must not me allowed to vote. |
|
|
| RapidFire |
| quote: | Originally posted by BlueFear
AGREE.
For next year TOTY, I'd say people registered after September must not me allowed to vote. |
and tracks released before january shouldnt be nominated :p |
|
|
| DJ RJT |
| quote: | Originally posted by RapidFire
and tracks released before january shouldnt be nominated :p |
:haha: :haha: :haha: :haha:
He shoots, he scores! |
|
|
| BlueFear |
Sorry for the spam, I've just realized messages can not be edited.
I'm not bashing those people in charge of this poll, becasue I know it was a hard work reading all posts to get the final 16, and everything else. We all here thank you, at least I do honestly.
But,
I think those round-polls idea did not work.
Why not just do a single 16tracks poll, all over January?
Why not do it now?
Many here would be glad if someone make that post. I think normal users can't, so we need an admin to do so.
Let's do it. |
|
|
|
|
