|
Students Kicked Off Campus for Wearing American Flag T-Shirts (pg. 4)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| The17sss |
| quote: | Originally posted by yukii
You have a point, you can celebrate your culture everyday of the week, why should 'Americans' be punished for wearing an american flag tshirt? However, put yourself in a foreigners perspective. You wouldn't think it's disrespectful if the day you celebrate a holiday from your country a select group of people, different from you, all just so happen to decide american flag shirts? :rolleyes: I mean c'mon, who gives a if they do it any other day and randomly, but if they're doing it on a specific day and as a group, you don't think they're trying to send out a message of some sort? I would be offended if I lived in Germany and on the 4th of July when I go to school with my american flag tshirt all the german kids wear their german flag shirts.. |
Why?? It's their country! I can honestly can say that if I lived in Germany, and on July 4th, if a bunch of German students were wearing shirts with German flags I would not give a . I would recognize I am in their country, and wouldn't for a second think they were out of line because I felt like American heritage should be respected for that day in their country; it would be absurd if I said, "You guys have 364 days a year to celebrate German nationalism... let us Americans have this day withouth you inciting us with your German flags!" My god... the perpetuation of the "American arrogance" stereotype that would result from doing that would be unbelievable. Besides, if I were a German citizen with parents who were born in America, it would be even MORE rediculous to protest Germans showing their heritage on an American holiday.
| quote: | Originally posted by nefardec
Actually I think YOU are exposing yourself as a racist by assuming that there is something for administrators to assume. |
lol... there's nothing to assume. That IS the reason why they asked the students to remove their shirts or be booted from school; they directly said they feared it would incite violence. Pointing out out the obvious doesn't make me racsit. :stongue: |
|
|
| yukii |
| quote: | Originally posted by The17sss
Why?? It's their country! I can honestly can say that if I lived in Germany, and on July 4th, if a bunch of German students were wearing shirts with German flags I would not give a . I would recognize I am in their country, and wouldn't for a second think they were out of line because I felt like American heritage should be respected for that day in their country; it would be absurd if I said, "You guys have 364 days a year to celebrate German nationalism... let us Americans have this day withouth you inciting us with your German flags!" My god... the perpetuation of the "American arrogance" stereotype that would result from doing that would be unbelievable. Besides, if I were a German citizen with parents who were born in America, it would be even MORE rediculous to protest Germans showing their heritage on an American holiday.
|
Yes, I agree with you again. What I'm trying to get at is that it's not wrong what the American kids did, but how would it not offend or make the other nationalities feel like outcasts? Why must they form a group and wear their national shirt? I'm not talking about rights, I'm just talking about the subliminal message that is being put forth. I wouldn't be mad at the German kids in my example, but I would feel as if they were passively solidifying the line between them and I. Wouldn't you feel that way? |
|
|
| The17sss |
| quote: | Originally posted by yukii
Yes, I agree with you again. What I'm trying to get at is that it's not wrong what the American kids did, but how would it not offend or make the other nationalities feel like outcasts? Why must they form a group and wear their national shirt? I'm not talking about rights, I'm just talking about the subliminal message that is being put forth. I wouldn't be mad at the German kids in my example, but I would feel as if they were passively solidifying the line between them and I. Wouldn't you feel that way? |
Well... maybe, but that's just how it is anywhere; people of similar backgrounds hang together. There are always separate cliques in school based on athletics, culture, science nerds, etc. That's normal IMO, and it doesn't mean that people are "taking sides" and disrespecting other groups. But there is this climate of political correctness, with a mythical fantasy land that exists where we're made to believe that if we don't have a black, asian, handicapped, Indian, and Hispanic person as part of our social circle, than we're just culturally insensitive bigots. Forcing people together doesn't work... it's gotta happen naturally based on individual personal relationships.
In your Germany example, if I saw that happen I'd think, "What can I say? It's their country and I'm in it... it's not my place to tell them how to 'celebrate diversity'". |
|
|
| EddieZilker |
| quote: | Originally posted by yukii
Yes, I agree with you again. What I'm trying to get at is that it's not wrong what the American kids did, but how would it not offend or make the other nationalities feel like outcasts? Why must they form a group and wear their national shirt? I'm not talking about rights, I'm just talking about the subliminal message that is being put forth. I wouldn't be mad at the German kids in my example, but I would feel as if they were passively solidifying the line between them and I. Wouldn't you feel that way? |
Again, to be clear, I believe it's an expression of veiled racism. It's a carefully controlled, measured response to society's disdain for overt racism by disguising it as something else. It makes it difficult to call it what it actually is because they have removed the obvious polemics from the context.
Psychologically speaking, this would be termed as gas-lighting or ambient abuse. It's something that, when it is noticed, is hard to define because it is so nebulous. Still, it has a rather chilling if not altogether insidious effect. It charges the atmosphere with tension, revealing the motivations of those who use it but calling into question the perception of that revelation. It is psychological warfare for cowards; bigots and failures of men who without a cause to antagonize for, would be not worth their notice they've achieved. With so many other things to do, in this world, they chose something which is corrosive, divisive and insipid. |
|
|
| yukii |
| quote: | Originally posted by EddieZilker
Again, to be clear, I believe it's an expression of veiled racism. It's a carefully controlled, measured response to society's disdain for overt racism by disguising it as something else. It makes it difficult to call it what it actually is because they have removed the obvious polemics from the context.
Psychologically speaking, this would be termed as gas-lighting or ambient abuse. It's something that, when it is noticed, is hard to define because it is so nebulous. Still, it has a rather chilling if not altogether insidious effect. It charges the atmosphere with tension, revealing the motivations of those who use it but calling into question the perception of that revelation. It is psychological warfare for cowards; bigots and failures of men who without a cause to antagonize for, would be not worth their notice they've achieved. With so many other things to do, in this world, they chose something which is corrosive, divisive and insipid. |
True. |
|
|
| Palladium |
| ayayay im in jo contri steelin jo contri :toothless |
|
|
| Lews |
I don't know dude... I might... I might be on Kev's side for once.
I really don't get how it's racist for them to wear the American flag, ************ of the holiday. If it was the Confederate flag, obviously that's racist, but if it's just an American flag... What's wrong with that =/
Maybe I missed something where they were asking the Mexican kids for their green cards or calling them racial slurs or something... but it seemed fine to me.
I think it's kind of stupid to wear an American flag shirt :p but I'm really not sure how they can get in trouble for it.
I feel like they can sue the school for this. |
|
|
| EddieZilker |
| quote: | Originally posted by Lews
I don't know dude... I might... I might be on Kev's side for once.
I really don't get how it's racist for them to wear the American flag, ************ of the holiday. If it was the Confederate flag, obviously that's racist, but if it's just an American flag... What's wrong with that =/
Maybe I missed something where they were asking the Mexican kids for their green cards or calling them racial slurs or something... but it seemed fine to me.
I think it's kind of stupid to wear an American flag shirt :p but I'm really not sure how they can get in trouble for it.
I feel like they can sue the school for this. |
I think it's the fact that they did it as a group which indicates their intention. May 5 is considered by Mexican-Americans/Hispanics to not necessarily be a celebration of Mexico as a nation but as one of their heritage - where their ancestry comes from. The flag is a symbol of that unifying fact.
White people see the flag and hear the language and assume that it signifies an invasion. The boys in question weren't just wearing shirts but also wearing bandannas with the American flag on it - clearly mocking behavior. There were five of them, sitting together, and it's somewhat clear what the intention was; that it wasn't a happy accident that they all decided to wear similar clothing on the same day.
I'm not saying that they don't have a right to speak their peace but when it's clear that they're behavior is antagonistic towards others, however they might try to claim that it was otherwise, the school was right to ask them to leave. |
|
|
| idoru |
| quote: | Originally posted by jonSun
Deport the illegals or make it law that they can be shot on site. :whip: |
| quote: | Originally posted by jonSun
I agree. Every president in the past 40 plus years had faced this problem with illegals entering this country & trashing it. None have done about it. |
What in the blue do illegals have to do with this issue? |
|
|
| jonSun |
| quote: | Originally posted by idoru
What in the blue do illegals have to do with this issue? |
It's a known fact that 98.2% of all mexicans that are in this country are here illegally. |
|
|
| yukii |
| quote: | Originally posted by jonSun
It's a known fact that 98.2% of all mexicans that are in this country are here illegally. |
:wtf: ur kidding dude right?? |
|
|
| igottaknow |
 |
|
|
|
|
