|
Japan's Tsunami 2011 (pg. 32)
|
View this Thread in Original format
| geroin |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
|
you don't know what you're talking about but you always have something to say as i can tell.
this does not happen every couple of hundred years as i have stated in the past, there is a potential of it happening anytime, especially in Japan.
There are scientists called geologists that study earth, volcanic activities, earthquakes and tsunamis. When a nuclear power plant is planned on being built a group of geologists will study and determine where is the safest place to build it and what are the potential consequences of the worst disaster happening at that location. Note that they cannot prevent or tell in advance, even 10minutes before if a 9.0 earth quake is approaching but they what they can tell is what is the worst possible earthquake/tsunami that could happen in that location. If a plant was built 40 years ago with different codes and it does not guarantee safety now up to today's standards then after inspection it must be closed as there is a potential for a big risk.
In terms of "shutting it down a long time ago", that's not how the world works unfortunately. Since it was still operating perfectly there was no need of shutting it down. People always start thinking about this after it happens, they never imagined of a disaster on such scale happening close to this plant BUT they should have, that is the reason why there is so much negative attention towards this event.
Again, if a country is dependant on nuclear power/energy and has load of nuclear plants all around the country in an extremely unstable location then they must build nuclear plants according to those conditions no questions asked. |
|
|
| srussell0018 |
I think I trust the judgment of the geologists that you speak of over...you? Thank you captain hindsight for your invaluable observations on what happened. Unfortunately, A) You're not a geologist, B) You're not an engineer, and C) You're not a nuclear physicist, so really all you're doing is talking out of your ass.
Why don't you leave these things up to the people who are actually experts in their respective fields.
Right, but then you wouldn't have anyone to blame. My bad. :rolleyes:
Going by your logic nobody should ever be concerned about tornadoes in the Midwestern US because since they're so prone to them, all buildings would be built to withstand any force of tornado fathomable. Be realistic. |
|
|
| geroin |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
I think I trust the judgment of the geologists that you speak of over...you? Thank you captain hindsight for your invaluable observations on what happened. Unfortunately, A) You're not a geologist, B) You're not an engineer, and C) You're not a nuclear physicist, so really all you're doing is talking out of your ass.
Why don't you leave these things up to the people who are actually experts in their respective fields.
Right, but then you wouldn't have anyone to blame. My bad. :rolleyes:
Going by your logic nobody should ever be concerned about tornadoes in the Midwestern US because since because they're so prone to them, all buildings would be built to withstand any force of tornado fathomable. Be realistic. |
why did you even reply to me? to say that i'm talking out of my ass and to say that i'm not a geologist? i don't think i've ever claimed that i am nor nowhere in my post i was observing what happened. You have some serious lack of reading comprehension skills, maybe you should stop replying to every single post in this forum? |
|
|
| VDub |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
Going by your logic nobody should ever be concerned about tornadoes in the Midwestern US because since because they're so prone to them, all buildings would be built to withstand any force of tornado fathomable. Be realistic. |
Because since because??
And the 30 year old building would've been built to standard 30 years ago...
But today's would be built to new standards right???
That's the stuation here, there, almost everywhere, no?? |
|
|
| VDub |
| That was more for you G.. |
|
|
| srussell0018 |
| quote: | Originally posted by geroin
why did you even reply to me? to say that i'm talking out of my ass and to say that i'm not a geologist? i don't think i've ever claimed that i am nor nowhere in my post i was observing what happened. You have some serious lack of reading comprehension skills, maybe you should stop replying to every single post in this forum? |
1. Because I can.
2. Yes.
3. You seem to think that you could have done a better job designing a ing nuclear power plant than teams of engineers, geologists, and nuclear physicists.
4. Your pension for using hyperbole and logical fallacies to try and support your points makes you look like an idiot, and as such, you should probably stop.
Basically I'm sick of you talking like you're some kind of expert on this matter. A freak series of events that causes a disaster like this doesn't mean "someone ed up." It's called ing nature, and it's unpredictable in some cases. Saying that nuclear power should be abandoned because of this is the most retarded thing I've ever heard, but it doesn't surprise me at all coming from you. |
|
|
| geroin |
| quote: | Originally posted by VDub
That was more for you G.. |
yes but we're talking about nuclear power plants, if by today's building standards they are outdated then they must be closed/shutdown. |
|
|
| geroin |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
|
:stongue: ok |
|
|
| srussell0018 |
| quote: | Originally posted by geroin
:stongue: ok |
I realize that you're a complete imbecile and have just run out of pitiful attempts to insult me in the desperate hopes that it will somehow make you look like less of a moron, but your posts speak for themselves.
God you're dumb.
You're claiming that nuclear power should be abandoned because of one freak disaster. Let's just forget about the fact that fission can produce more power, with less pollution, than all of the fossil fuels in the ing world. Do you even think about what you say before you make wild claims like that? If anything, this is an opportunity to learn how to better construct these plants, and should lead to the expansion of nuclear programs.
Finally, I'd just like to reiterate how dumb you are. |
|
|
| geroin |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
Basically I'm sick of you talking like you're some kind of expert on this matter. |
if you're sick of me "talking like an expert" why don't you gather some facts to disprove me instead replying to me with senseless bull (ie. your opinions and what you think is going on and you're right i'm wrong etc etc.) that has no merit in this discussion. Any other person would have given up 4posts ago. |
|
|
| srussell0018 |
| quote: | Originally posted by geroin
if you're sick of me "talking like an expert" why don't you gather some facts to disprove me instead replying to me with senseless bull (ie. your opinions and what you think is going on and you're right i'm wrong etc etc.) that has no merit in this discussion. Any other person would have given up 4posts ago. |
The burden of proof is on you you ing idiot. "Prove me wrong" is not a ing defense when someone argues against you. Why don't you prove yourself right instead. Jesus christ how ing dumb can you be? You're just like those neanderthals who argue for the existence of god by saying "prove me wrong."
You want me to gather facts to disprove your opinion that nuclear power should be completely abandoned? Really?
I don't have enough hands for the amount of palms my face requires right now. |
|
|
| hardcore trancer |
| quote: | Originally posted by srussell0018
I realize that you're a complete imbecile and have just run out of pitiful attempts to insult me in the desperate hopes that it will somehow make you look like less of a moron, but your posts speak for themselves.
God you're dumb.
You're claiming that nuclear power should be abandoned because of one freak disaster. Let's just forget about the fact that fission can produce more power, with less pollution, than all of the fossil fuels in the ing world. Do you even think about what you say before you make wild claims like that? If anything, this is an opportunity to learn how to better construct these plants, and should lead to the expansion of nuclear programs.
Finally, I'd just like to reiterate how dumb you are. |
Holy what a troll you are. Get a life.. |
|
|
|
|
